@001 ##BIBLIOTHECA INDO-TIBETICA SERIES-XXIX## prajJApAramitAvajracchedikAsUtram ##WITH## prajJApAramitAvajracchedikAtIka ##OF## AcArya kamalazIla [DD] bhoTa vidyA saMsthAnam ##Critically edited the Tibetan version and Restored into Sanskrit with Introduction and Indexes by Pema Tenzin, Acharya Supervisor Prof. Ram Shankar Tripathi CENTRAL INSTITUTE OF HIGHER TIBETAN STUDIES SARNATH, VARANASI B.E. 2538 C.E. 1994 @002 BIBLIOTHECA INDO-TIBETICA SERIES-XXIX Chief Editor : Prof. Samdhong Rinpoche First Edition : 550 copies, 1994 Price: Hardback: Rs. 160.00 Paperback: Rs. 110.00 @ Copyright by Central Institute of Higher Tibetan Studies, Sarnath, Varanasi -221007, India, 1994. All rights reserved. Publisher: Central Institute of Higher Tibetan Studies, Sarnath, Varanasi-221007, India. Printed at Khandelwal Offset Printer, Mahmoorganj, Varanasi.## @003 bhoTa-bhAratI granthamAlA- 29 prajJApAramitAvajracchedikAsUtram evaM AcAryakamalazIlaviracitA AcAryaprajJApAramitAvajracchedikATIkA [DD] bhoTa vidyA saMsthAnam sampAdaka evaM punaruddhArakarttA pemA tenajina, AcArya paryavekSaka pro. rAmazaMkara tripAThI kendrIya ucca tibbatI zikSA-saMsthAna, sAranAtha, vArANasI buddhAbda: 2538 san 1994 I^ @004 bhoTa-bhAratI granthamAlA- 29 pradhAna sampAdaka : pro. samadoG rinapoche prathama saMskaraNa : 550 pratiyAM^, 1994 mUlya : ajilda : rU^ 160.00 sajilda : rU^ 110.00 @ kendriya ucca tibbatI zikSA saMsthAna, sAranAtha, vArANasI - 221007 bhArata, 1994 prakAzana sambandhI sabhI adhikAra surakSita | prakAzaka : kendriya ucca tibbatI zikSA saMsthAna, sAranAtha vArANasI - 221007 mudraka : khaNDelavAla AphseTa prinTarsa, mahamUragaMja, vArANasI | @005 viSayAnukramaNikA viSaya: pRSTham prakAzakIya (tibbatI) 1 prakAzakIya (hindI) 2 puro vAk 3-4 viSayAnukramaNikA 5-6 bhUmikA (tibbatI) 1-21 bhUmikA (hindI) 22-91 zabdasaMketasUcI 92 saMskRtagranthapATha: (punaruddhRta:) 93-226 maMgalAcaraNam 95 nidAnam 98 upodghAto buddhavaMzAnupacchedazca 105 pratipattilakSaNam 108 pratipattisthAnam (aSTAdazasthAnAni) 110 1. cittotpAdasthAnam 111 2. pAramitAyogasthAnam 121 3. rUpakAyAptikAmatAsthAnam 129 4. dharmakAyAptikAmatAsthAnam 131 5. bhAvanAvizeSalAbhe’nabhimAnasthAnam 146 6. buddhotpAdArAgatAsthAnam 151 7. kSetravizuddhipraNidhAnasthAnam 152 8. sattvaparipAkasthAnam 153 9. bAhyazAstreSu vyapagatarAgatAsthAnam 154 10. sattvabhAjanalokayo: piNDagrAhavizIrNatAyogasthAnam 160 11. tathAgatapUjAsatkArasthAnam 162 12. kAyacittaparizrAntau vIryavaimukhyAnArambhalAbhasatkAravirahitatA 162 13. du:khAdhivAsanasthAnam 168 14. dhyAnarasAsvAdaviratisthAnam 175 15. abhisamayakAle’hamiti vikalpayogasthAnam 183 @006 16. avavAdaparyeSaNam 184 17. abhisamayasthAnam 188 18. buddha bhUmiparyeSaNam (saptadhA) 190 1. kSetraparizuddhisampad 190 2. anuttaradRSTiparizuddhisampad 192 3. anuttarajJAna parizuddhisampad 193 4. prAptapuNyaskandhAdhipatyasampad 195 5. kAyasampad 196 6. vAksampad 197 7. cittasampad (saptadhA) 195 1. smRtyupasthAnam 200 2. abhisambodhi: 201 3. mahAdharmArthaprajJapti: 203 4. mahAvavAdArthaprajJapti: 204 5. dharmakAyaparigrahaNam 206 6. saMsAre nirvANe cApratiSThAnam 210 7. prasthitiparizuddhi: (trividhA) 216 1. IryApathena prasthiti: 216 2. bhAjanasattvalokAdhipatyena prasthiti: 218 3. asaMklezena prasthiti: (dvidhA) 223 1. dezanA’saMkleza: 223 2. saMsArAsaMkleza: 224 bhoTapAThasya viSayAnukramaNikA 227 bhoTagranthapATha: 229-416 pariziSTAni : 1. akArAdikrameNa sahAyakagranthAnukramaNI 417 2. akArAdikrameNa granthAgatagadya-padyoddharaNAnAmanukramaNI 421 3. " " " granthaprayuktaviziSTasaMskRta-bhoTazabdAnukramaNI 424 4. AcAryakamalazIlakRtAnAM granthAnAmanukramaNI 447 @007 zabdasaMketa-sUcI a. ka. = amRtakaNikA a. ko. = amarakoza: a. ni. = aMguttara nikAya a. pra. = aSTasAhasrikAprajJApAramitA a. vi. sU. = arthavinizcayasUtram a. vi. sU. ni. = arthavinizcayasUtra-nibandhanam a. a. = abhisamayAlaMkAra: abhi. ko. = abhidharmakoza: A. TI.= AlokaTIkA A. ratna. sU. = AryaratnakaraNDasUtram kA. da. = kAvyAdarza: ga. vyU. sU. = gaNDavyUhasUtram catu. = catustava: ta. saM. = tattvasaMgraha: ta. saM. paM. = tattvasaMgrahapaJjikA tri. za. kA. = trizatikAprajJApAramitAkArikAsaptati: triM. vi. mA. si. = triMzikAvijJaptimAtratAsiddhi: dharmasaMgIti = dharmasaMgItinAmamahAyAnasUtram nyA. vi.= nyAyabindu: pra. pi. = prajJApAramitApiNDArtha: pra. vA. = pramANavArtikam bo. ca. = bodhicaryAvatAra: bo. ca. paM. = bodhicaryAvatArapaJjikA bhA. kra. = bhAvanAkrama: ma. a. = madhyamakAlaMkAra: ma. ni. = majjhima nikAya ma. vi. = madhyAntavibhaGga: ma. vi. bhA. = madhyAntavibhaGgabhASyam ma. zA. kA. = madhyamakazAstrakArikA ma. zA. vR. = madhyamakazAstravRtti: ma. sU. saM. = mahAyAnasUtrasaMgraha: ratna. sU. = ratnameghasUtram ratnA. = ratnAvalI laM. sU. = laMkAvatArasUtram vajra. TI. = vajracchedikAprajJApAramitATIkA vajra. sU. = vajracchedikAprajJApAramitAsUtram vi. magga = vizuddhimagga vi. mA. si. = vijJaptimAtratAsiddhi: vyA. yu. = vyAkhyAyukti: zi. samu. = zikSAsamuccaya: zAli. sU. = zAlistambasUtram saddharma. pu. sU. = saddharmapuNDarIkasUtram samAdhi. sU. = samAdhirAjasUtram sU. a. = sUtrAlaMkAra: ha. kA. sU. = hastikakSyasUtram @008 AryaprajJApAramitAvajracchedikAsUtram evaM AcAryakamalazIlaviracitA AryaprajJApAramitAyA vajracchedikAyA vistRtaTIkA @095 AryaprajJApAramitAvajracchedikAsUtram AcAryakamalazIlaviracitayA AryaprajJApAramitAyA vajracchedikAyA vistRtaTIkayA sahitam namo maJjuzriye kumArabhUtAya maGgalAcaraNam kAya: prasiddha: paridRzyamAno janeSu sarveSu sphuTaM tathApi | svabhAvato vastutayA na prApto nidarzita: so’pi ca prAptihetu: || phalasya zreSThasya ca nityabhUta- paramasya cAgryasya jinai: samastai: | atazca traiyadhvikasarvabuddha- prasUM namasyAmyanizaM hRdA tAm ||1|| @096 alpIyasA’bhyAsabalena yasyA:, mahAnti puNyAni hi saJcinoti | utkhAtamUlAni ca pApakAni, sarvANi cApAdayati kSaNena || atazca tasyAzcirabhAvanArthaM, mArgaM pravakSye svabalAnurUpam | gurUpadiSTaM suparIkSitaM ca matiM svakIyAmanuvartayitvA ||2|| tatrAdau sUtraM vyAcikhyAsu: sAdhyavasAya(viSaya-)grahaNAdau zrotR#NAmavatAraNArthaM prayojanamAha | na hi prayojanamantareNa prekSAvAn kvacit pravartate {1. saprayojanasya hi zAstrasya pratyAsa: sAdhurbhavati, na niSprayojanasya | -abhi. ko. (sphuTArthA) pR. 14, bau. bhA. pra., 1987 |} | tadanantaraM prayojanopAyamupadarzIyatumabhidheyastAvad vakSyate, (yato hi) abhidheyarahitaM sUtraM dazadADimAnItyAdivAkyavanneSTaprayojanaM sAdhayati | tata: saukaryeNa tadabhidheyagrahaNArthaM piNDArtho vakSyate | tadanantaraM samAsArthapratipattaye padArtho’bhidhAsyate | tata: kramasyAvirodhaM nidarzayituM padAnAmanusandhirdarzayiSyate | tadanantaraM pUrvAparayuktivirodhApanodanAya codakaM prati samAdhAnaM vakSyata ityeva nyAya: | {2. prayojanaM sapiNDArtha padArtha: sAnusaMdhika: | sacodyaparihArazca vAcya: sUtrArthavAdibhi: || dRSTavyam- vyA. yu., (uddhRtam Aloka: pR. 277); dra^- ##T oh: 406 1 Sde-bstan (Sems-tsam, phi. p.30)} tatra vajracchedikA iti sUtrasya nAmadheyam | anenaiva tAvad abhidheya: prayojanaM cAbhidhIyete | @097 atra dvidhA vajracchedikA | sUkSmaklezajJeyAvaraNAni vajravaddurbhedyAni, teSAM chedanAt | etenAsya (granthasya) AvaraNadvayaprahANaM tAvat prayojanaM nirdiSTam | athavA chedanaM hi vajrAkArasAdRzyena vajravaditi | vajrasya hi ubhe zikhare sthUle madhyaM ca sUkSmam | tathaiveyaM prajJApAramitA’pyAdAvadhimukticaryAbhUmim{1. evaM kRtadharmapravicaya: samAhitacittazta sarvadharmanairAtmyaM... sa eva Anantaryo nAma samAdhi: | sarvAzcaitA avasthA: dRDhAdhimuktito’dhimukticaryAbhUmirucyate |} (dr^ Aloka:, pR. 301-302.) mithilA saMskaraNam, 1960 |} ante ca buddhabhUmiM vistareNa nirdizati | sUkSmeNa tAvanmadhyabhAgena zuddhAdhyAzayabhUmiM nirdizati | ata eveyaM vajrAkAravaditi | {2. dra^-AryabhagavatIprajJApAramitAvajracchedikA-saptArthaTIkA, AcArya vasubandhu:, ##Toh: 3816 Sde-bstan (Sher phyin, ‘Ma’. p.)} etena bhUmitritayamasyA: (vajracchedikAyA:) abhidheyo nirdiSTa: | piNDArthastu saMkSepeNa paJcadhA, tadyathA-nidAnam, upodghAta:, buddhavaMzAnupaccheda:, pratipattilakSaNam, tatsthAnaJca | tatra nidAnaM tu sUtrArambhanimittam, taccApi evaM mayA zrutam{3. dharmasaMgItisUtre-“evaM mayA zrutamiti kRtvA bhikSavo mama dharma: saMgAtavya: tathA sambandhAnupUrvI pratipAdyA” ityAdi | (uddhRtam_ Aloka: pR. 270); dra^- ##Toh: 238 Sde-bka (Mdo sde, Zha)##} ityArabhya tena khalu AyuSmAn subhUti: ityetAvatparyantaM dezitam | tasya{4. de. ge. saMskaraNe “tasmAt” iti pATha: |} ca saGgItikArairAtmaprAmANyapratipAdanAyoktatvAt | evaM sUtrAntareSvapi vAcyam | upodghAtastAvat pakaraNena sUtrArthavyutpAdanArtha saMyujyate | aprastutAbhidhAnena sarvam asamaJjasaM syAditi tannirAkartuM sarvatrApi prakaraNena yojyam | atha khalvAyuSmAn subhUtirutthAyAsanAt ityAdinA tannirdiSTam | buddhavaMzAnupacchedo’pi ca tenaiva darzita: | AryasubhUtinA imAM prajJApAramitAM buddhavaMzAnupacchedakatvena viditvA yathA buddhavaMzAnupacchedo bhavet tathaivAdau saMsthApitA | pratipattilakSaNaM tu bodhisattvayAnasamprasthitena kathaM sthAtavyam ? ityAdinA proktam | @098 evaM mayA zrutam | ekasmin samaye bhagavAn zrAvastyAM viharati sma – tasya pratipattilakSaNasya sthAnaM tAvat kasmin viSaye bodhisattvena sthAtavyam ? pratipattavyam ? cittaM pragrahItavyam ? yadetat tattasya sthAnamiti | tadapi iha subhUte | bodhisattvayAnasamprasthitena evaM mayA ityAdinArabhya tArakA timiram ityantimagAthA yAvadabhihitam | pratipattilakSaNaM tasya sthAnaM cetyetAbhyAM dvAbhyAM bodhisattvAnAmazeSakaraNIyaparipUrNatA samprakAzitA, ityeSa tAvat piNDArtha: | nidAnam : padArthAdayazceme sAmpratamabhidhIyante- tatra evam{1.tathAgataguhyanirdezAdhikAreNa sarvathA bhAdrakalpikasarvatathAgatAnAM rUpakAyasaddharmakAyarakSAyAM kRtAdhikAratvAt vajrapANyabhiSekAdau pratyarpitazAsanatvAcca anyeSAM vizeSavacanAbhAvAt aDakavatInivAsI dazabhUmIzvaro mahAvajradhara: sarvalokAnugrahAya prajJApAramitAsUtraratnasaMgItiM pratyadhISTavantamAryamaitreyAdimahAbodhisattvagaNam evam ityAdyAha, iti pUrvAcAryA: | anye tu atraiva parIndanAparivarte “yatheyaM jambudvIpe prajJApAramitA pracariSyati" ityAdinA pratyarpitaprajJApAramitAdAryAnanda: saMgItikAra iti manyante | tatra evam iti nizcayArthIbhidhAyinA svAnirUpajJ#nAvadhAritanikhilasUtrArthasyopadarzanapareNa evametadditi aviparItatvamAha | -dra^ Aloka:, pR. 270, mi. saM. 1960 |} iti zabdo’bhyupagamAdinAnArtheSu dRzyate | atra prakaraNAdibalena sannidhApitArtho grAhya: | ayaM hi vakSyamANasaMkalasUtrArthaM vyavasthApayati | mayA{2. iti Atmavacanena bhagavata: sakAzAtsAkSAt zravaNam | -Aloka: pR. 270 |} ityanyavyavacchedena arthasya sAkSAcchravaNaM nirdizyate | Atmanaiva zrutaM na zravaNaparamparAyAtamityartha: | zrutam{3. zrotravijJAnena anubhavavacasA ca | tathAgatAdRte’nyasyaivaMbhUtasamastadharmAdhigamasAmarthya- vaikalyAdadhigamAbhAva: | etaJca padatrayaM bhagavadvacanAdeva sUtrArambhe nirdiSTam | -Aloka:, pR. 270; dharmasaMgItisUtre- evaM mayA zrutamiti kRtvA bhikSavo mama dharma: saMgAtavya: | -(uddhRta) Aloka:, pR. 270; ##See- Toh: 238 Sde bka (Mdo sde; Zha).} ityadhigamo niSedhyate | tathAgatAd Rte nAnye svatastathAbhUtadharmAdhigamavanto bhavanti | etenAnAptatvaM nirAkriyate | ekasmin samaye iti ekasmin kAle, sarvakAlamevaMvidhadharmaratnazravaNaM durlabhamityAkhyAtam | @099 yadvA svagataM bAhuzrutyamupadarzitam | ekasmin kAle idaM zrutamanyadA anyadapi zrutamiti darzyate | atha vA, ekasmin samaye bhagavAn viharati sma ityuttareNa sambadhyate{1. dezAntaravineyArtha tatsthAnAM tarpaNAya ca | zrAvakAnekavAsArthamanAsaktiM ca darzayan || dezAnAM caityabhAvArtha puNyArtha caiva dehinAm | ityAdijJApanArtha ca buddhazcarati cArikAm || -Aloka: pR. 271-72 |} | aparimitavineyAnAM teSAM hitAya anyadA anyatra viharati sma iti pratipAdyate{2. ekasmin samaye zrAvastyAM viharati sma | anyadA anyatra viharaNAt | uktaM cASTasAhasrikATIkAyAm AlokAbhidhAyAm- ekasmin samaye gRdhrakUTe viharati sma ityuttarapadena saMbadhyate, anyadA anyatra viharaNAt | -pR. 274} | kleza-skandha-mRtyu-devaputrarUpANAM caturNaM mArANAM bhaJjakatvAnniruktyA bhagavAn iti smaryate{3. klezakarma tathA janma klezajJeyAvRtI tathA | yena vaipakSikA bhagnAsteneha bhagavAn smRta: || -Aloka:, pR. 272; ##See- Toh: 3997 Sde-bsten (Mdo-hgrel,chi.) page 236;## klezAdikaM bhagnavAniti bhagavAn | dra^- Aloka:, pR, 272} | atha vA aizvaryAdimattvAt ‘bhagavAn’ ityucyate{4. tulanIyam- yatraitadguNamAhAtmyaM sa buddho bhagavAn iti rUpakathanam | tatra sakalapadArthAvabodhena prakRSTA buddhirasyeti buddha: | akArapratyayo’tra arza AderAkRtigaNatvena kArya: | prakRSTA ca buddhirnavabhirAkArai: - sarvajJajJAnena, ayatnajJAnena, anupadiSTajJAnena, savAsanaklezAvaraNaprahANajJAnena, nikhilajJeyAvaraNaprahANa- jJAnena, sarvAkArasarvasattvArthakaraNazaktyA, karuNAsaMpattyA, akSayasaMpattyA, atulatAsaMpattyA ca | samagraizvaryAdiyogena bhagavAn | -Aloka:, pR. 352-253; api ca tu^- navabhireva padairyathoktai: sakalaM vivakSitaM guNamAhAtmyamabhidyotitam | yatraitad guNamAhAtmyaM sa buddho bhagavAniti pradarzanArtham | padAnAM puna: piNDArtha:- bhaGktvA vibandhaM zAstRtvasaMpadaM yAM hi yena sa: | yathAgata: zAstRkarma yacca yaizca parigraha: || -a. vi. sU. ni., pR. 247, ke. pI. jAyasa. saMskaraNam, 1971, paTanA |} | yathoktam{5. buddha bhUmivyAkhyAnam (uddhRta Aloka:, pR. 272, mi. saM. 1960) ##T oh: 3997 Sde-bstan (Mdo-hgrel, chi. page 235-36## upalabdhasaMskRtazlokasya prathamapAda: bhoTapAThAt bhinno’sti | bahavo’tra pAThabhedA: saMskRtagrantheSUpalabhyante |} – aizvaryasya samagrasya rUpasya rUpasya yazasa: zriya: | jJAnasyAtha prayatnasya SNNAM bhaga iti zruti: || @100 jetavane’nAthapiNDadasyArAme mahatA bhikSusaMghena sArdham ardhatrayodazabhirbhikSuzatai: saMbahulaizca bodhisattvairmahAsattvai: | zrAvastI iti zravastestannAmakarSerAzramatvAcchrAvastI nagarI, tayopalakSito dezavizeSo’pi tatsambandhena zrAvastItyucyate | dezoktyA aya dezo’pi caityabhUto’bhidhIyate, tadyathA caityabhUta: sa pRthivIpradezo bhaviSyati{1. anayaiva hi kauzika prajJApAramitayA pRthivIpradeza: sattvAnAM caityabhUta: kRto vandanIyo mAnanIya: pUjanIyo’rcanIyo’pacAyanIya: satkaraNIyo gurukaraNIya:, trANaM zaraNaM layanaM parAyaNaM kRto bhaviSyati tatropagatAnAM sattvAnAm | -a. pra. pR. 28; dra^- vajra. sU., adhyA. 15} ityatrApyuktam | atha ca saGgItikArairAtmavacanAnAmAdeyatApratipAdanAyaitat sarvamuktam{2. prajJApAramitApiNDArthe ca yathoktam- zraddhAvatAM pravRttyaGgaM zAstA parSacca sAkSiNI | dezakAlau ca nirdiSTau svaprAmANyaprasiddhaye ||3 saMgItikartrA loke hi dezakAlopalakSitam | sasAkSikaM vadan vaktA prAmANyamadhigacchati ||4 -pra. pi., 3, 4 kA. |} | lokapratyAyanArthaM tAvat (sa) pradeza: sAkAra: samRddhazcetyukta:, evaM sati parai: grAhyaM bhavati vacanam, nAnyathA tadAdeyavacanamiti | zrAvastIpradezasya atyantaM vistIrNatvAt kutra viharatIti sthAnanizcayAbhAvAd jetavane ityuktam | ‘jetR’ ityAkhyasya rAjakumArasya vanatvAd jetavanamiti | tadapi tAvat kasyacidaprasiddhamiti sambhAvanAyAm anAthapiNDadasyArAme ityuktam | gRhapati-anAthapiNDada ityanAthebhyo dayayA piNDadAnena tathA prasiddha:, sa khalu bhagavadarthaM nirantaratayA ratnAni vikIrya jetu: rAjaputrAdArAmaM krItavAn | rAjaputrajetRNA’pi tatra kAcid bhUmirAvAsAdibhi: samalaGkRtA, atastayostad vanamiti prasiddhiM gatam | kasyacidekasyopAdAnena abhipretadezavizeSasyAnavabodhAt padatrayamuktam{3. jetavane’nAthapiNDadasyArAme | vajra. sU., adhyA. 1 |} | athavA zrAvastItyanena bahunAM madhye viharaNAt parArthasampadabhihitA | jetavane’nAthapiNDadasyArAma ityanena (ca) vivekaviharaNAt svArthasampat | @101 atra ka: sAkSIti cintyamAne mahatAbhikSusaMghena ityuktam | bhinnaklezA hi bhikSava:{1. mahAnubhAvena bhikSuNAM traivAcikena karmaNA jJapticaturthenAghAtapaJcamena ehibhikSutvena copasampannAnAM bhinnaklezAnAM samUhena | - Aloka:, pR. 272; tatra traivAcikAdikarmaNopasaMpanno bhikSu: | -Aloka:, pR, 387; dhammapade coktam, yathA- yodha puJJaM ca pApaM ca, bAhetvA brahmacariyavA | saMkhAya loke carati sa ve bhikkhUti vuccati | -19/12;} | mArAdibhi: pratyarthibhirabhedyatvAt teSAM samUha: saMgha:{2. buddho dharmastathA saMgho mArakoTizatairapi | bhettuM na zakyate yasmAttasmAtsaMgho’bhidhIyate || dra^- Aloka:, pR. 272 |} ityucyate | mahAn bhikSusaMghastAvat bhUyastvena AnubhAveneti dvaividhyena, AnubhAvastAvad darzita: | {3. mahatA iti saMkhyAguNamahattvayogAt | tu^- Aloka:, pR 272 |} kathaM bhUyastvati ced ? sArdhamardhatrayodazabhi: (bhikSu)zatai: ityAdyucyate | tasmin samaye tAvatAmeva sattvAt | bhikSusaMghAt bodhisattvAnAM bAhulyaM tu teSAmevArthAya sUtrANAM bhASitatvAt | bodhau sattvamAzayo yeSAM te ‘bodhisattvA:’{4. bodhau sarvadharmAsaktatAyAM svArthasaMpadi sattvamabhiprAyo yeSAM te bodhisattvA: | -Aloka:, pR. 282 ; api ca- yasmAt sarvadharmANAm eva AlambanasthAnIyAnAm anubodhArthena samyagubhayasatyAnatikramAlambanena yA asaktatA, tasyAM satyAmAlambanavizuddhigamanena anuttarAM samyaksambodhimabhisaMbudhyate nAnyathA | ato bodhyAlambanaprayojanena sarvaprakArasvArthasaMpAdanAt bodhisattva ityucyate | -Aloka:, pR. 307; dra^- a. pra., pR. 9-10; api ca bodhicaryAvatAre- nAzayatyapi saMmohaM sAdhustena sama: kuta: | kuto vA tAdRzaM mitraM puNyaM vA tAdRzaM kuta: || kRte ya: pratikurvIta so’pi tAvatprazasyate | avyApAritasAdhustu bodhisattva: kimucyatAm || -bo. ca., 1/30,31} | zrAvakeSvapi bodhau sattvaM vidyate, atasteSAM vyavacchedAya mahAsattvai:{5. mahatyAM parArthasaMpadi sattvaM yeSAM te mahAsattvA: | - Aloka: , pR. 282 ; mahata: sattvarAzermahata: sattvanikAyasya agratAM kArayiSyati, tenArthena bodhisattvo mahAsattva ityucyate | -a. pra., pR 9 |} ityAha | dharma-cittotpAda-adhimukti-adhyAzaya-sambhAra-kAla- sampratipattilakSaNai: saptabhirmahattvairupetvAd mahAsattvA: | tatra dharmamahattvaM bodhisattvebhya: zatasAhasrikAprajJApAramitAdivipuladharmANAMM dezanAt | cittotpAdamahattvaM tAvadanuttarAyAM samyaksambodhau cittotpAdAt |- @102 atha khalu bhagavAn pUrvAhNakAlasamaye nivAsya pAtracIvaramAdAya zrAvastIM mahAnagarIM piNDAya prAvikSat | atha khalu bhagavAn zrAvastIM mahAnagarIM piNDAya caritvA kRtabhaktakRtya:- adhimuktimahattva tasminneva gambhIrodAra{1. prastuta: pATha: pe. saM. anurodhena pastuta:, de. ge. saMskaraNe “mahodAradharme” iti pATha: |} dharma’dhimuktatvAt | Azayamahattva tu sarvasattvahitasukhotpAdAzayAt | sambhAramahattva tAvadaparimitapuNyajJAnasambharaNAt | kAlamahattvaM khalu tribhirasaMkhyeyakalpairbodhiprApte | sapratipattimahattva hi anuttarasamyaksambodherniSpAdanAt | viharati iti caturbhirIryApathai:,{2.dra^- vajra. sU., adhyA. 28 |} athavA anuttareNa brahma-deva–AryavihAreNa viharati | sma iti vihRtavAniti darzitam | tatra bhikSusaMghastu kRtakRtyatvAd mRdukAruNikatvAcca sarvakAla tathAgatasya pAdAntike niSadyata iti viditvA sthAsnutvasaMdarzanArthaM pUrvamukta: | bodhisattvAstu aparimeyasattvArthakriyAsAdhana- pariniSpattau akRtakAryatvAt, adhimAtrakaruNayA jagadarthakaraNAya lokadhAtuSu viharaNAt sarvakAlaM bhagavata: pAdAntike’niSIdanAcca pazcAduktA: | ata eva zrAvakasUtrAnteSu nocyante bodhisattvA:, na ca tAni (zrAvakasUtrANi) tadarthAni, aniyatAni ceti | atha iti tadanantaram | samaye iti niyate | etena niyatastAvat piNDakAla iti | kAlaniyatatvaM tu asminneva kAle piNDapAto grahItavya iti, tadapi kimiti aparijJAnAt tadarthaM pUrvAhNa: iti vacanenAbhidhIyate | pUrvAhNaJca kAlasamayazceti samAsa: | upavasatAM pravrajitAnAM ca piNDakAlopalambhena pUrvAhNalakSaNaM bhagavatA dezitamekAntenetyavabodhanArthaM kAlasamaye ityuktam | anyathA pUrvAhNa ityetadvacanena tadekAntatvanirdezo nAvagamyate | bhagavatA svecchayA kRtamiti sambhAvyamAnatvAd etat padatrayamuktamiti vA | nivAsya iti gRhapravezAnurUpaM vastradhAraNam | tadapi zikSAsu zrotRNAM gauravasampAdanArtham, anyathA svasyaiva vineyatvAbhAve kathaM parasya vineyatA syAt | cIvaramAdAya ityatra cIvarAdAnaM @103 tAvat prAvaraNalakSaNaM draSTavyam, nAstyanyasyAvakAza iti | mahAnagarI iti dezavizeSa:, zrAvastImAtravyavacchedArtham | kimarthaM bhagavAn piNDAya prAvikSat iti | zrAvakeSvalpecchatApravRtti:, daridra-rogi-gRhiNI-vRddhAdiSvanugraha:, andhAdibhyo netrAdisamprAptiriti, vividhavismayahetUnAmanavarataM pradarzanena bhagavati ca pareSAM prasAdotpAdanArthaM ityetAnyaparimitAni prayojanAnyavagantavyAni | kRtabhaktakRtya: iti ya: khalu bhojanAdibhaktakRtyaM sampAditavAn, sa evamucyate | alpakuzalamUlebhyo nirjAtA api brahmAdaya: kavalIkArAhAravirAgAnnaiva bhaktakRtyaM kurvanti,{1. kAmAvacarANi gandharasaspraSTavyAyatanAni sarvANyeva kavaDIkRtyAbhyavaharaNAt, mukhanAsikAgrAsavyavacchedata: | -abhi. ko., 3/39, pR. 492 |} tarhi acintyakuzalamUlanirjAto hi bhagavAn(buddha:) kathaM kuryAditi ? tathA AryadharmasaMgItau{2. ##Toh: 238 Sde-bka (Mdo-sde. ‘zha’ p. 8)##; tu^- “tatra prathamaM tAvad yogI bhAvanAkAle sarvam itikaraNIyaM parisamApya kRtamUtrapurISa: kaNTaka-svarAdirahite mano’nukUle pradeze sthitvA” ##See- Bhavanakrama 3 cheapt.p. 224, Tib. Inst. Ed. 1985.} api bhASitam- “tathAgatastu kSutpipAsAvarjita: mUtrapurISavirahito’kSINakAyazca bhavati” iti | satyamevaitat tathApi yadi bhagavata: sa kAyo na paramArthabhUta:, tadA syAt sarvopAlambhAvasaro’pi, yadA tvayaM bhagavato nirmANakAya:, evaMvidhacaritapradarzanena vineyasattvAzayAnurUpaM pravartate, tadA kathamupAlambhAvakAza: | manuSyabhAve eva vIryArambheNa etAdRzamanuttarapadaM labhyata iti vineyAnAmutsAhanArthaM manuSyabhAvaM darzayitvA evaMrUpaM piNDabhaktaM darzitavAn | ye dAyakA dAnapataya:, teSu piNDaparikarmaprakAzanena praharSa: samupajAyate | bhAgyavanto’pi kiJcitkarmAvaraNavazAt pretAdiSu samupajAtA: mahaujaskA{3. mahojaskA mahAnubhAvA: | taduktam- yasmAdevaM prasiddhA mahojaskA yatra gRhAdAvAgantavyaM maMsyante, tasmAt tadgRhAdi teSAmanubhAvena surakSitaM bhaviSyati iti | -Aloka:, pR.373 |} yakSAdaya: bhagavatAM karanakhAmRtena saMspRSTaM paramAkSayadivyarasamAdAya paribhuJjAnA: paramasukhasaMtRptacetasa uttamAM samAdhiM samavApnuvanti | ata: aparimeyaM tAvad bhagavato bhaktakRtyam | @104 pazcAdbhaktapiNDapAtapratikrAnta: pAtracIvaraM pratizAmya pAdau prakSAlya nyaSIdatprajJapta evAsane paryaGkamAbhujya RjuM kAyaM praNidhAya pratimukhIM smRtimupasthApya | atha khalu saMbahulA bhikSavo yena – kena prakAreNa bhaktakRtya kRtamiti cet ? tadartha pazcAd ityAdyAha | sarvamAdAya tadanu yat piNDapAta bhaktaM tat pazcAdbhaktapiNDapAtam | pUrvametatsamAdAnaM tu zrAvakANAM dhUtaguNeSvavatAraNArtham | bhaktamiti (bhakSaNakRtyaM) sampAditamityartha: | athavA pazcAditi yad dvitIyavAramAdAna tat pazcAdbhaktam | tadeva pazcAdbhaktamapi piNDazcApIti padayojanA | athavA aparAhNabhaktatvena ya: paribhujyate piNDa: sa evamucyate | atazca dhUtaguNavattvAt{1. dvAdazadhUtaguNA: - dharmasaMgraha:, (ma. sU. saM. 1. pR. 333; mi. saM., 1961) ; Aloka:, pR. 476 ; ##Toh: 4346 Sde-bstan (Sna-tshogs, Cho) p. 24.} vikAlabhojanaparihRtatvAcca tadvirahitametad bhaktaM syAdityartha: | pratizAmya iti pratiSThApyetyartha: | tacca zakrAdayastu bhagavadAjJAmAdAtuM samudyatAstadantike sadaivopatiSThante, kintu pravrajitAstu svayamevAnutiSThanta iti nidarzaIyatuM bhagavatA svayaM pAtracIvarapratiSThApanaM kRtam, alabhyamAnabhRtyAnAM manda bhAgyAnAM daurmanasyaparihANArthamapIti | azucyAbhAsaM satatasamitamapAkartuM kamaleSu pAdanikSepaNam, kriyAtantrAdyadhimuktasattvAzayAnuvartanaM vA sarajaskapAdAbhyAM zayanAsanAnAmanavamardanam iti zikSAyAmAdaraM darzayituM pAdaprakSAlanaM draSTavyam | prajJapta evAsane iti devAdibhi: prajJapte | RjukAyaM praNidhAya iti nAtinamraM nAtistabdhamityartha:{2. tu^ - mayA sarvasattvA bodhimaNDe niSpAdayitavyA iti vinizcayan, sakalajagadabhyuddharaNAzayo mahAkaruNAm AmukhIkRtya, dazadigavasthitAn sarvabuddhabodhisattvAn paJcAGgena praNipatyAgrato buddhabodhisattvAn pIThAdau sthApayitvA anyatra vA yathAvattebhyazca yathAruci pUjAstavanaM kRtvA svapApaM pradezya, sakalasya jagata: puNyam anumodya, mRdutarasukhAsane vairocanabhaTTArakabaddhaparyaGkeNa ardhaparyaGkeNa vA niSadya nAtyunmIlite nAtinimIlite nAsikAgravinyaste cakSuSI kRtvA, nAtinamraM nAtistabdham RjukAyaM praNidhAyAntarmukhAvarjitasmRtirupavizet | - ##BhavanakramA# 3 chapt. p- 225, Tib. Inst. Ed., 1985; See-## Aloka:, pR. 275 |} | kathaM dharmadezanAkAle bhagavAn samAhitena IryApathena @105 bhagavAMstenopasaMkrAman | upasaMkramya bhagavata: pAdau zirobhirabhivandya bhagavantaM triSpradakSiNIkRtya ekAnte nyaSIdan | tena khalu puna: samayenAyuSmAn subhUtistasyAmeva parSadi saMnipatito’bhUtsaMniSaNNa: | nyaSIdaditi cet ? samAhitaireva dharmo’yaM dezayituM jJAtuM zrotuM vAM zakyate nAnyairiti samAdhau yatnotpAdAya lokAnA pravartanAt | pratimukhIM smRtimupasthApya iti pUrvaM bodhisattvAvasthAyAM tAvad anuttarapada prApya yathA buddhavaMzAnupaccheda: syAttathAhaM kariSye iti yat praNidhAnaM kRtaM tat praNidhAnaM smaraNAbhimukhIkRtamityartha: | bhagavAstu buddha: sadA samAhita: sannapi sarvathA smRtau viharati | asamayasmareNa na kiJcit syAt | samaye praNidhAnasmaraNaM hi saphalaM bhavati | samaye smareNanApi bhagavata: sadA samAhitatva na virudhyate | atha khalu saMbahulA bhikSava: ityanena kimuktam ? yatparimANena bhikSusaghena saha bhagavAn zrAvastyAM viharati sma, sa sarva: dharmadezanAkAle tatra naiva sannipatita: | tribhyo’dhikAstatra sannipatitA ityuktam | tacca saGgItikArai: parasampratyayotpAnAdanArtha nirdiSTam | sannipatita: iti sannihita eva | sanniSaNNa: ityAsane upaviSTa: | loke prAya: samAnyapUrvakaM vizeSa: sthApyata iti lokaprasiddhyanurUpamubhayamAha | anyathA niSaNNa: ityetAvatmAtreNa apyubhayamuktaM syAditi | uktA nidAnapadArthA: | upodghAto buddhavaMzAnupacchedazca : samprati upodghAto buddhavaMzAnupacchedazca kathayiSyete | paramAzcaryamAdarzayituM dvirabhidhAnam | sugata{1. lokottara mArgeNa zobhanaM jJAnaprahANasampadaM gata: sugata: surUpavat | apunarAvRttyA vA suSThu gata: sugata: sunaSTajvaravat | nizeSaM vA gata: sugata: suparipUrNaghaTavat | -Aloka:, pR. 352; sugatatvaM vyAcikhyAsurAha-heto: samudayasya prahANaM nirodha: sugatatvam, tacca triguNaM guNatrayamuktam | su zabdasya trividho’rtha: - 1. prazastatA surUpavat, 2. apunarAvRtti: sunaSTajvaravat, 3. ni:zeSatA ca supUrNaghaTavat | -pra. vA., 1/141 ; sugata ityanena yathAgantavyaM gatastaM darzayati | suSThu gata: sugato'punarAvRttyarthena sunaSTajvaravat | nizeSa vA gata: sugata: ni:zeSajJeyagamanArthena supUrNaghaTavat | -a. vi.sU., pR. 244,kA. jAyasa. saMskaraNam, 1971} | iti sambodhanam | nairAtmyadvayamArgeNa @106 atha khalvAyuSmAn subhUtirutthAyAsanAdekAMsamuttarAsaGgaM kRtvA dakSiNaM jAnumaNDalaM pRthivyAM pratiSThAya yena bhagavAMstenAJjaliM praNamya bhagavantametadavocat- AzcaryaM bhagavan, paramAzcaryaM sugata, yAvadeva tathAgatenArhatA samyaksaMbuddhena bodhisattvA mahAsattvA- samyag gata iti suSThurUpeNa gata: sugata:, surUpavaditi | athavA nikhilasavAsanAzeSaklezajJeyAvaraNAni prahAya gata: sugata:, supUrNaghaTavat | athavA apunarAvRttyA gata: sugata:, sunaSTajvaravat | yAvataivAnugrahItA:, tAvataivAnuparigRhItA ityartha: | rAjAdayo’pi AzritAn prajAdIn yathAzakti anuparigRhNanti kintvatra bhagavati AzcaryamityAzaGkAkAyAM kimAzcaryamiti tathAgatenArhatA samyaksaMbuddhena ityuktam | yathAvadvastutattvadezanAt tathAgata: | athavA yathA pUrvakA nairAtmyadvayamArgeNa gatA:, klezajJeyAvaraNaprahANamadhigatA:, atrApi tathA gatatvAt tathAgata:{1. sarvAkArAviparItadharmadaizikatvena parArthasaMpadA tathAgata: | -Aloka: pR. 300; prajJApAramitA jJAnamadvayaM sA tathAgata: | -pra. pi., 1 kA.; acalitA hi tathatA |… yA ca tathatA, sa tathAgata:, …yA ca bhUtakoTi: sa tathAgata:, … yA ca zUnyatA, sa tathAgata: | …yA ca yathA vattA, sa tathAgata: | yazca nirodha: sa tathAgata: | -a. pra. 31 pari., pR. 253; bhUtavAdI subhUte: tathAgata:, satyavAdI tathAvAdI ananyathAvAdI tathAgata:, na vitathavAdI tathAgata: | -vajra. sU. pR. 36, ti. saM. saM., 1978; vastutattvaM yathAsthiti: tathaivAdhigamyate adhigatatvAd tathAgata: | -prastutA TIkA, pR. 217; vaktRtvamaviparItadharmadezakatvaM yena bhagavAn tathAgata ityucyate | -a. vi.sU. ni., pR., 242, jAyasa. saM., 1971 |} | sarvalokAbhyarhaNIyatvAt, arINAM klezAnAM vA hantRtvAd arhan{2. pUjAdakSiNAguNaprakarSAdyarhatayA arhanta: | -Aloka:, pR. 273; samyak samAdhivazAt sakalavikalpaklezAnarIn hatavAn (ityarhan) | -a.ka. pR. 240; savAsanaklezajJeyAvaraNaprahANayogAt svArthasaMpadA arhanta: | -Aloka:, pR. 300; dhyAnadhyeyasamAdhivimokSabalAbhijJAnaklezadu:khavikalpAbhAvAdarhannityucyate | laM. sU., pR. 49, vaidyasaMskaraNam, 1963; hatAritvAt arhanta: | -Aloka:, pR. 273; arIn hatavAnarhan | -Aloka:, pR. 351; yasmA rAgAdisaGkhAtA sabbepi arayo hatA | paJJAsatthena nAthena tasmApi arahaM mato ti || -vi. magga., 7/6; dra.- ma. ni., bhAga 1.pR. 280; prahANasampadA bhagavAnarhannityucyate, arIn hatavAniti kRtvA nairuktena vidhinA | arayo hi klezA:, sarvakuzaladharmopaghAtArthena | -a. vi. sU., pR. 242. jAyasa. sa., 1971.} | samastajJeyAnAM samyagavabodhAt samyaksaMbuddha:{3. samyaksaMpadvyAvAhakamArgAdhigamAt samyaksambuddhA: | -Aloka:, pR. 301; jJAnasampadA samyaksambuddha ityucyate; samyagaviparItaM samantAd dharmAn buddhavAniti kRtvA | -a. vi. sU. ni., pR. 242, jAyasa. saM., 1971; samyak aviparItaM samantAddharmAvabodhAt samyaksambuddha: ityanena jJAnasaMpaduktA aviparItasarvajJajJAnAdhigama- yogAt | -Aloka:, pR. 351 |} | ebhi: padairbhagavata: prahANajJAnarUpA sva-parArthasampadupadarzitA bhavanti | @107 anuparigRhItA: parameNAnugraheNa | AzcaryaM bhagavan yAvadeva tathAgatenArhatA samyaksaMbuddhena bodhisattvA mahAsattvA: parInditA paramayA parIndanayA | etenaivamabhidhIyate- rAjAdInAM prajAdiSvanugrahe tAvannaivAzcaryam, yato hi te lAbhasatkArAdisvArthIrthatayA parAnanugRhNanti, bhagavatastAvat tathAgatatvenArhattvena samyagabhisambuddhya adhigatAzeSasampattitayA yo’nugraha: sa khalvatra AzcaryamityAdarzitam | Rte karuNAM bhagavato’nugrahe’smin nAsti kiJcidanugrahakAraNAntaramityanenAbhihita eva bhavati bhagavAn mahAkAruNika: | anuparigRhItA: iti abhisambuddhena bhagavatA dharmacakrapravartanAkAle paripakvakuzalamUlA bodhisattvA bhUmiSvavatAritA:, dharmatAyAM bodhisattvAnAM pratiSThApanena | parInditA: iti aparipakvakuzalamUlAnAm AdikarmikANAma- nugrahAya ta eva parInditA:, dharmatAyAM bodhisattvAn pratiSThApayitum | mama parinirvANapradarzanaM tu yuSmAsvaprAptaguNAnAmadhigamAya, prAptAnAM ca samyagaparihANAyeti | evamanugrahaparIndanetyubhAbhyAM buddhavaMzAnupaccheda: samprakAzita: | bodhisattvaSvanugrahastu paJcadhA samyag veditavya: - kAla-vizeSatA- udAratA-sthiratA-vyApakatAbhi: | tatra kAla:- janmajanmAntaratvAt | vizeSatA- tairthika-zrAvaka-pratyekabuddhebhyo’nugraheNa viziSTatvAt | udAratA-anuttaratvAt tadanugrahasya | sthiratA- AtyantikatvAt | vyApakatA- tadanugraheNa tu sva-parasantatyorhitasampAdanAt | @108 tatkathaM bhagavan bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitena kulaputreNa vA kuladuhitrA vA sthAtavyaM kathaM pratipattavyaM kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyam ? parIndanA’pi tridhA samyaga draSTavyA, Azraya dharmatAprApaNa:, jJaptivacane | kIdRzastAvadAzraya: ? kalyANamitreSu{1. cittAnavalInatvAnutrAsAdinA upAyakauzalyena yathAzayaM “kSitIzeSTarAjJImaraNanivedananyAyena” mAtsaryAdi dharmaviyukta: samastavastunairAtmyAdidezaka: sugatiphalAdiprApakatvena kalyANamitram | -Aloka:, pR. 305 |} parIndanAta sA bhavatyavipaNSTA | kiM tAvad dharmatAprApaNam ? anuparigRhItA bodhisattvA dharmatayA parAnanugrAhyanti | kiM tarhi jJaptivacanam ? tvayA anye bodhisattvA anugrahItavyA ityAjJApitam, na tvanAdarabhAva | upodaghAta-buddhavazAnupacchedapadArthA uktA | pratipattilakSaNam | pratipattilakSaNa tAvaducyate-tadadhikAreNa katham ityuktam | kAryasubhUti: khalu SaDvidhaprayojanArthaM pRSTavAn | 1. saMzayopacchedAya, 2. adhimukti- samutpAdAya, 3. gambhIreSvartheSvavatAraNAya, 4. avinivartanAya, 5. paramapramoda- saJjananAya, 6. saddharmasya cirasthityai ca | tatra prajJApAramiteyaM kathaM buddhavazasya anupaccheda karotIti sandehakAriNAM saMzayopacchedanArtham | aparipakvasantatInA bodhisattvAnA puNyabAhulyakhyApanena prajJApAramitAsu adhimuktisamutpAdanArtham | paripakvasantatInAM tAvad gambhIreSvartheSvavatAraNArtham | abhUtapratipattiparibhUtAnAM tadudgrahaNadhAraNayorvyAyacchatAM puNyabAhulyAbhikAGkSayA avinivartanArtham | anugRhIteSu vizuddhAdhyAzayeSu svAdhigatataddharmadarzanena paramapramodasaJjananArtham | anAgate kAle mahAyAnasaddharmasya ciramavasthAnArtham | samAsatastu sandigdhAnAM samyak samprakAzanAya, puNyAbhikAGkSaNAm aparipakvabodhisattvAnAM samyagavatAraNAya, vipratipattivihatAnAM sampraharSaNAya, zuddhAdhyAzayAnAM pramodAya ca | tatra sthAtavyam chandapraNidhAnAbhyAm | pratipattavyam yogasamApattyA | cittaM pragrahItavyam vikSepanigraheNa | tatra @109 evamukte bhagavAnAyuSmantaM subhUtimetadavocat- sAdhu sAdhu subhUte, evametatsubhUte, evametadyathA vadasi | anuparigRhItAstathAgatena bodhisattvA mahAsattvA: parameNAnugraheNa | parInditAstathAgatena bodhisattvA mahAsattvA: paramayA parIndanayA | tena hi subhUte zRNu, sAdhu ca suSThu ca manasi kuru, bhASiSye’haM te- chandastAvadabhilASa: | praNidhAnaM tu abhilaSitArthe’bhisaMskAralakSaNena yaccintanam {1. samyaksaMbodhikAmatA ca tatprArthanA kuzalo dharmacchandazcaitasika:, iti kathaM sa cittotpAdo bhavet ? satyametat | kiM tu du:khArNavanimagnaM jagadatrANamabhisamIkSya taduddharaNAbhiprAya: kuzaladharmacchandalakSaNAyAM prArthanAyAM satyAM buddhatvAya cittamutpAdayati, iti kAraNenAtra kArya nirdiSTam | evaM chandaprArthanasya bodhisattvasya sarve kuzalA dharmA vRddhiM yAnti | -Aloka:, pR. 283} | yogasamApatti: khalvavitarkasamAdhi: | vikSepanigrahastAvat samAdhito vikSiptaM cittaM vikSepebhyo nivArya tatraiva viniyojanam | prathamena prayogamArga:, dvitIyena pariniSpattimArga:, tRtIyena tvavipraNAzamArga: paridezita: | sthAne pRcchato bhagavAn AryasubhUtaye sAdhukAramadAt | zRNu ityavahitazrotrAbhyAM zrotuM pravartasva | sAdhu ityaviparItapratipattyA udgrahItum | suSThu ca manasi kuru samyaktayA udgrahItumudyukto bhava ityartha: | tadapi avAGmukha-azuci-sacchidra bhANDAnAmiva zrotRjanAnAM yathAkramaM trividhadoSa- parihArArthImadamudIritamiti{2. yathA deve varSatyapi avAGmukhe ghaTe na kiJcidapyudakaM pravizati, tadvattvamavAGmukho bhUtvA apratipattyA mA zRNvityAha | sAdhu ca iti | yathA uttAne azucighaTe yadudakaM pravizati tat sarva azuci bhavatyakAryopagatam, tadvat tvaM viparItapratipattyA zrutamazucIkurvan mA zRNu ityAha- suSThu ca iti | yathottAnazucichidraghaTaM pravizatyudakaM na tu tiSThati, tadvat tvamasthirapratipattyA mA zRNu | kiM tu zRNu yathA paTutarAnubhavadvAreNa cetasi sthirIbhavatItyAha- manasi kuru iti | -Aloka:, pR. 333; zruNu ityAdi vyAkhyAtam | athavA, yasmAdAdita eva bhaktihetutayA tAvatkalyANaM tasmAt sAdhu zRNu | yatazca madhye puSTihetutvAt kalyANaM tata: suSThu zRNu | yena ca paryavasAne muktihetutayA kalyANaM tena yonizo manasikuru | athavA, mRdumadhyAdhimAtrANAM doSANAM pratipakSatvAt yathAkramaM sAdhvAdivacanam | dra^- Aloka:, pR. 335 |} | bhASiSye iti tebhya eva samprakAzayiSyAmi, nAnyebhya iti | anyathA avAGmukha-azuci-sacchidrabhANDeSu ambuvRSTiriva @110 yathA bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitena sthAtavyaM yathA pratipattavyaM yathA cittaM pragrahItavyam | evaM bhagavan ityAyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavata: pratyazrauSIt | dharmavRSTirapIya nirarthakaiva syAdityartha: | athavA ahaM tu kevala dezayiSyAmi tvameva tAvad yatnata: pratipadyasvetyartha: | bodhisattvayAneti bodhisattvAnAM yAnam, yena bodhisattvA niryAnti | tacca dazabhi: pAramitAbhi: dazabhizca bhUmibhi: parigRhyate | tatra samprasthAna tAvat praNidhiprasthAnacittAbhyAM{1. tadbodhicittaM dvividhaM vijJAtavyaM samAsata: | bodhipraNidhicittaM ca bodhiprasthAnameva ca || - bo. ca., 1/15; api ca draSTavyam- yathA AryagaNDavyUhe varNitam- bodhicittaM kulaputra | bIjabhUtaM sarvabuddhadharmANAm “durlabhAste, kulaputra, sattvA: sattvaloke ye’nuttarAyAM samyaksambodhau praNidadhati iti | tato’pi durlabhAste sattvA ye’nuttarAyAM samyaksambodhim abhisamprasthitA: |” –ga. vyU. sU., pR. 395, darabhaMgAsaMskaraNam |} sampravartanam | etadvizeSaNaM tu zrAvakAdibodhipatiSedhArtham, bodhisaMprasthitena ityetAvaducyamAne bodhInAM tritvAdanyasyA api bodheravagama: syAditi | pratyazrauSIt ityabhyupagamAdityartha: | uktA: pratipattilakSaNapadArthAdaya: | pratipattisthAnam : sAmprataM tatsthAnAnyabhidhIyante | tatsthAnAni tAvat samAsato’STAdazaprakArANi; tadyathA- 1. cittotpAda: 2. pAramitAyoga: 3. rUpakAyAptikAmatA 4. dharmakAyAptikAmatA 5. bhAvanAvizeSalAbhe’nabhimAna: 6. buddhotpAdArAgatA 7. kSetravizuddhipraNidhAnam 8. sattvaparipAka: @111 bhagavAnasyaitadavocat- iha subhUte bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitenaivaM cittamutpAdayitavyam- yAvanta: subhUte sattvA: sattvadhAtau- 9.bAhyazAstreSu vyapagatarAgatA 10. sattvabhAjanalokayo: piNDagrAhavizIrNatAyoga: 11. tathAgatapUjAsatkAra: 12. kAyacittaparizrAntau vIryavaimukhyAnArambhalAbhasatkAravirahitatA | kAyacittaparizrAntau vIryArambhato’vinivRtti:, na Arambha ityanArambha: | aho, ArabdhavIryo’yamiti pareNa jJAyamAne sati zraddhAmAgamya lAbhasatkArAdhyavasitatvam | tasmAd bodhisattva etebhya: sarvebhyo vimucya prajahyAt | 13. du:khAdhivAsanam 14. dhyAnAsvAdavirati: 15. abhisamayakAle’hamitivikalpaviyoga: 16. avavAdaparyeSaNam 17. abhisamaya: 18. buddhabhUmiparyeSaNaM ca | etAni tAvadaSTAdazavidhAni sthAnAni, yatra bodhisattvena sthAtavyaM pratipattavyaM cittaM ca pragrahItavyamiti | etai: sthAnairbhUmitrayaM saMgRhyate, tadyathA- SoDazabhi: sthAnairadhimukticaryAbhUmi:, abhisamayasthAnenaikena zuddhAdhyAzayabhUmi:, buddhabhUmiparyeSaNena ca buddhabhUmi: saMgRhyate | sarvasattvaparinirvApaNacittamutpAdya pAramitAyogI tAvat tathAgatasya rUpakAya-dharmakAyaprAptau chandamutpAdayati | tata: A abhimAnam antimam ahaM-vikalpaM yAvadabhisamayasyAntarAyebhyazcittaM viprakarSati | tatazcAbhisamayArthamavavAdaM paryeSate, tadanantaramabhijAnAti, tadUrdhvaM buddhabhUmiM paryeSate | ayameva teSAM krama: | 1. cittotpAda-sthAnam : tatra bodhicittamadhikRtya yAvanta: sattvA: ityAha | yAvat iti parimANam | kiM tatra parimANam ? sattvasaMgraheNa ityuktam | sattvadhAtustu @112 sattvasaMgraheNa saMgRhItA aNDajA vA jarAyujA vA saMsvedajA vA aupapAdukA vA rUpiNo vA arUpiNo vA saMjJino vA asaMjJino vA naiva saMjJino nAsaMjJino vA, yAvAn kazcitsattvadhAtu: prajJapyamAna: prajJapyate, te ca mayA sarve’nupadhizeSe nirvANadhAtau parinirvApayitavyA: | - aparimita:, athApi sattva: sattva iti yastatsvabhAva: taditaravyAvRtta- zabdAdhyAropitArthasabhAgarUpeNa khyAta: sa eva sattvena saMgRhyate | tena dRzyavikalpyayorekatvenAbhisaMkSipya tadrUpeNAdhyavasitatvAd rUpAdiskandha- vizeSairupAdIyante | ataste AyuSmAniva pratIyante | evaM sAmAnyato nirUpya vizeSato darzayitumAha- aNDajA: ityAdi | vizeSalakSaNaM tAvat tribhi: prabhedairabhihitam | yonibhedenANDajAdayazcattvAra: | sthAnabhedena tu rUpiNAmarUpiNAM ca pRthaksthAnatvAt | kAmAvacarA rUpAvacarAstAvad rUpiNa:, arUpAvacarAstu arUpiNa: | nimittodgrahaNabhedena saMjJina: ityAdaya: | bRhatphalasyaikadezaM bhavAgrajAMzca sattvAn vihAya sarve sattvA: saMjJina: | bRhatphalasyaikadezastAvad asaMjJina: | ayamapi nimittodgrahaNabhedAtmaka eva, tadabhAvabhedenopalakSitatvAt | bhavAgrajAstAvad naiva saMjJino nAsaMjJino vA | prabhedo’yaM mandamedhasAmanugrahAyaiva kRta:, anyAvadhyAnaparihArArthaM tAvannaiva prapaJcita: | `sarve dharmA: ni:sattvA:’ ityanena saha vacanasyAsyAvirodha: pradarzita: | atra sattvadhAturiti sAMvRte satye sattvadhAtustaM darzayituM yAvAn ityAdyAha | prajJapyamAna: iti paJcaskandha- vizeSAtmakatvena prajJAyata iti, na tu tairthikA: prajJaptyA prajJapayantItyartha: | anenApavAdAntastAvat parihRta:, prajJaptAvapavAdAbhAvAt | yasmin apratiSThitanirvANadhAtau sAsravopadhirnAvaziSyate, sa tathocyate | zrAvakANAM parinirvANaM tAvad nAtra nirvANadhAtu:, tasya hInatvAt | praNItaphale saMvidyamAne kRpAlUnAM hInaphalArthitA na khalu yuktimatI | saMvidyamAne’pi praNItaphale prAptumazakyatvAdevaM prArthyata iti cet ? tvanmatAnusAraM tAvad trividhagotratvAdagotratvAcca sarvai: hInaphalamapi prAptuM naiva zakyate | @113 evamaparimANAnapi sattvAn parinirvApya na kazcitsattva: parinirvApito bhavati | tatkasya heto: ? sacetsubhUte bodhisattvasya atha bodhisattvagotraM tAvattathAvidhaM yadvazatayA mahAkaruNAvegAbhibhUtena (mayA) kathamidaM zakyamiti, saMvidyamAneSvapareSu parArthakAriSu buddhabodhisattveSu nirarthakena mayA’tra praNidhAnena kimiti vicArAn santyajya parapratyayatAM ca dUrIkRtya mahAkaruNArdra: jAjvalyamAnena du:khAgninA pIDyamAnaM jagad vilokya ahameva tArayiSyAmIti cintayamAna: praNidadhAti | yathoktam- duSkarAduSkarAM veti kalpanAM parihAya ca | abhyupetaM jagaccArtamityAsyena svayaM tvayA || iti | yadyapyevam, tathApi priyaputrasya nRpatvAya praNidhAnamiva satyapyaprApye praNItaphale kathanna praNidhAnamiti | kimarthaM hInameva prArthyate | ata evApratiSThitanirvANam evAtra anupadhizeSanirvANadhAturyujyate {1. na vidyante upadhaya: skandhA: sarvarAgAdiprahANazeSIbhUtatvena zeSA yasminnirvANe tattathoktam | -Aloka:, pR. 335} | tatra sAsravopadhe: zeSatvAbhAvAt | nirvApayitavyA: ityetAvanmAtraM kasmAnnoktam ? prathamAdidhyAnAnAM vyAvRttyarthamiti | tAni tAvadadhobhUmiklezAbhAvAd nirvANaparyAyeNoktAni bhagavatA | sopadhizeSe nirvANadhAtau iti kasmAnnoktamiti cet ? du:khopadhizeSasyAprahINatvAttatra | sarvasattvanirvApaNAzayastu bodhisattvAnAM tribhirhetubhirdraSTavya:, tadyathA- 1. akSaNotpannebhya: kAlAntarAvasthAnam, akSaNAvasthA tAvadupalakSaNamiti | naitAvanmAtram | tasyAmavasthitau parinirvANaM naiva sambhAvyate | 2. aparipakvAnAM paripAcanam | 3. paripakvAnAM vimokSaNaM ca | tasmAnnAzaktA’rthitA (teSAm) | nikhilasattvAnAM parinirvApaNAzayena anena audAryaM tAvad bodhicittasyAdarzitam | chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM kathaM sthAtavyaM- @114 sattvasaMjJA pravarteta, na sa bodhisattva iti vaktavya: | tatkasya heto: ? na sa subhUte bodhisattvo vaktavyo yasya AtmasaMjJA{1. bhoTapAThe “AtmasaMjJA” iti pATho nopalabhyate |} | pravarteta sattvasaMjJA vA jIvasaMjJA vA pudgalasaMjJA vA pravarteta | tadapyatrAveditam | kathaM yogasamApattyA pratipattavyamiti taddezayitumAha evam ityAdi | saMvRtau sarvasattvAnAM parinirvApaNe’pi yathA paramArthato na ko’pi sattva: bodhisattvenopalabhyate, tasyAbhAvAdityevaM yogasamApattyA pratyavekSaNIyam | vyutthito bhUtvA na paramArthata: ko’pi sattvo mayA parinirvApita: iti yazcittotpAdastena gambhIratvaM paramArthabodhicittatvaJca darzitaM bhavati, pUrveNa tu saMvRtiriti | tena vikSepanigraheNa kathamatra cittaM pragrahItavyamityAdarzayitumAha- tatkasya heto: ? sacet iti yadItyartha: | atha ya: pudgalAdisaMjJayA pravartate kiM sa bodhisattva iti vaktavya: ? sattva ityuktau puna: kasya heto: iti praznenetarAbhirapi (saMjJAbhi:) na vaktavya: ityAha | asyAyamabhiprAya: - kumatibhistAvat paJcaskandhAtirikta: antarvyApAravAMzcaturNA bhogAnAM bhoktA eka: puruSa iti parikalpyate sattva:, jIva ityAdizabdaizca vyavahriyate | ye cAnirvacanIyatvena pudgalamicchanti{2. yathoktam- bhAraM vo bhikSavo dezayiSyAmi bhArAdAnaM bhAranikSepaM bhArahAraM ca | tatra bhAra: = paJcopAdAnaskandhA:, bhArAdAnam=tRSNA, bhAranikSepa: = mokSa:, bhArahAra: = pudgalA: | -ta. saM. pa., bhAga 1. (uddhRtam) pR. 165, (saM. ni., ska. saM. 22sU.)} tairapi tasya skandhasvabhAvavilakSaNatvenAbhyugatatvAt tadbalenArthAntara evAbhyupeyate | na kadApi padArtho’nirvacanIya: sambhavati, sarvasyApyanirvacanIyatvaprasaGgAt | tatsAdhakapramANAbhAvAd bAdhakasadbhAvAcca taddraSTA bodhisattvo viparItAbhinivezena viparyasta eva bhavati | ya: khalu viparyasta: sa kathaM paramArthabodhisattva: ? anye punarAhu:- asti tAvadAtmasAdhakaM pramANamiti | tathA hi- bandha-mokSa-mArga-hetuphalasambandhasmRtipratyabhijJAdInAmekAdhikaraNakatve tAvat prasiddhe nairAtmyavAdinAM yuSmAkaM mate tu yastadAdhAra eka: prasiddha: sa nAsti kazciditi kastAvadAdhAra: ? vijJAnakSaNAnAM pratikSaNaM pRthaktvAt | baddho @115 devadatta: muktazcAnyo yajJadatta iti naiva vyavasthA, na cAnya: pratyanubhaviSyati anyena kRtasya karmaNa: phalamityatiprasaGga: | kRtavipraNAzo’kRtAbhyAgamazca prasajyete{1. yenaiva kRtaM karma zubhAdikaM tenaiva tatphalamupabhujyate- iti loke pratItam | na hi devadattena kRte karmaNi zubhAdikaM yajJadattastatphalamiSTamaniSTaM copabhuGkta iti prasiddham | nApi zAstre, yathoktam- “anenaiva kRtaM karma ko’nya: pratyanubhaviSyati |” iti | taccaitat kSaNikapakSa virudhyate; karmaphalaparigrAhakasyaikasya karturabhAvena kRtanAzAkRtAbhyAgamadoSaprasaGgAt | -ta. saM., paM., bhAga 1. pR. 208. bau. bhA. pra., 1981 |} | tathA hi – kartRtvena prajJapto yo hi vijJAnakSaNa:, tasya phalenAnabhisambandhAt kRtavipraNAzAkhyo doSa: | akartuzcaiva tasya phalena yogAdakRtAbhyAgamo doSa: syAt | smRtyAdikaM ca bhinnAdhikaraNakamiti na loke pratItam | atha kathamiti cet ? ekAdhikaraNakameva | devadattasya cittAnubhava: yajJadattacittena na smaryate vA pratyabhijJAyate vA | yenAnubhUyate tenaiva smaryate pratyabhijJAyate veti prasiddham | phalatazcaika eva puruSa: sarvAvasthAsvanugantA bhavati | prayoga:- yau bandhamokSau tAvekAdhikaraNakau, yathA- devadattasyaiva zRGkhalAbandhanaM mokSazca | vivAdAspadIbhUtau bandhamokSAvapi bandhamokSAveveti svabhAvahetu:{2. ekAdhikaraNAvetau bandhamokSau tathA sthite: | laukikAviva tau tena sarva cArutaraM sthitam || 499 prayoga: - yau bandhamokSau tAvekAdhikaraNau, yathA-laukikau bandhamokSau | bandhamokSau ca vivAdAspadIbhUtAvetAvanuzayatadvisaMyogalakSaNau bandhamokSAviti svabhAvahetu: | -ta. saM. paM., bhAga 1, pR. 214, bau. bhA. pra., 1981 |} | tathaiva kartrAderapyekAdhikaraNatvasAdhane prayogA: kalpayitavyA iti | tatra yadi svatantrasyaikasya paramArthasato nityasya puruSasyAdhikaraNatvaM sAdhyate, tadA tathAvidhena puruSeNa saha kvApi heto: sambandhAsiddheranaikAntikatvam, sarveSAM saMskArANAM kSaNikatvAt, devadattAde: nityatvaikatvasvabhAvAsiddhe: dRSTAntasyApi sAdhyavikalatvam | ata eva viruddho hetu: tadviparyayavyAptatvAt | atha ekAdhikaraNatvamAtraM sAdhyate, tadA siddhasAdhanam | ekasantAnapravRttatvena tena bandhanAdInAmekAdhikaraNatvamiSyata eva | @116 api ca, yadA yatra santAne’vidyAdikaM kAryakAraNabhAvenAvicchinna nirantaraM pravartate, tadA sa baddha: ityucaryate, sa eva puna: zrutamayAdikrameNAryamArgotpAdAd avidyAdinirodhenAzrayaparAvRttau mukta: ityupacaryate{1. kAryakAraNabhUtAzca tatravidyAdayo matA: | bandhastadvigamAdiSTA muktirnirmalatA dhiya: ||543 kevalamavidyAdaya: saMskArA jarAmaraNaparyantA du:khotpAdahetutayA ‘bandha:’ iti vyavahriyante | tathA coktam- “evamasya kevalasya hetordu:khaskandhasya samudayo bhavati” iti | teSAM cAvidyAdInAM tattvajJAnAd vigatau satyAM yA nirmalatA dhiya: sA nirmuktirityucyate | yathoktam- cittameva hi saMsAro rAgAdiklezavAsitam | tadeva tairvinirmuktaM bhavAnta iti kathyate ||iti | -ta. saM. paM., bhAga 1, pR. 230, bau. bhA. pra., 1981 |} | ubhAvapi tau bandhamokSau nityaikaparamArthavastuviSayakau natarAM siddhau | laukikabandhamokSayorapi tathAtvAt | yasmin santAne zubho vA azubho vA cittAnubhava samutpadyate, tasminneva kAlAntare santatiparipAkamAgamya mastuluGgalAkSAdirasAvasiktasantatiparipAka iva sukha-du:kha-smRtyAdiphalodayo dRSTA:, tasmAcchubhAdInAmekAdhikaraNatva tAvat prasiddham | naiva khalu kazcideka: kartA bhoktA smartA vA | sarveSAmeteSAM vyavahArasya prajJaptervA kAryakAraNabhAvamAtreNa prabhAvitatvAt | na cAtiprasaGga:, niyatasAmarthyavato bIjAderiva kAraNazakte: pratiniyatatvAt |{2. nanu bIjAMkurAdInAM kAryakAraNatekSyate | niyatA tatra sUkSmo’pi nAMzo’styanugamAtmaka: || -ta. saM., 506 kA., 1981; yathA hi niyatA zaktirbIjAderaMkurAdiSu | -ta. saM., 502, bau. bhA. pra., 1981 |} tatazca yeSu kAryakAraNabhAva: pratiniyata: teSu naivaM kazcid ekonugata: bhinnAvasthazca paridRzyate | iha sattvahetostathAtve sati kimanenAtmanA parikalpitena | AtmopacArasya yA khalu kartrAdyavasthA, sA tAvad hetu:, yA khalu bhoktrAdyavasthA, sA phalamityevaMvidho hi kAryakAraNabhAvo’vazyamabhyupetavya iti | anyathA tayorubhayorapyavasthayoranupapannatve parasparopakArakatvAbhAve vA AkAzamiva kathaM tAvat sidhyet bhoktrAdi:{3. yo’parityaktAkartrabhoktravastha:, sa na karoti na cApi bhuGkte, yathA-AkAzam | -ta. saM. pa., bhAga 1, pR. 137 |} | zaktipratiniyamo’pyabhyupagantavya eva | itthaM pratiniyatAtmanA sambandhena sukhAdInAM sambhava:, na tu sarvatra | ata: @117 kAryakAraNabhAvena dRzyamAnAni kuzalAdInyeva kartA, bhoktA ca syAt, kimanenAdRSTasvabhAvena AtmanA parikalpitena | atha nAnumAnena AtmA siddha: syAt, tathApi pratyakSaviSayatvAd ahaMbuddhe: pratyakSata evAtmA sidhyatIti cet ? tadapi tAvanna yujyate, bhrAntatvAt savikalpatvAd asiddhatvAcca pratyakSeNa tatrAhaMbuddheriti | ahaMbuddhau pratIyamAnatve yathA khalu pratyakSa eko nityo vibhuzcAtmA svasiddhAntairupakalpyate tathA naivopalabhyata ityavazyameva draSTavyam | anyathA ahaMbuddheryadi pratyakSatvaM syAt tadA vivadamAneSu tAvannaiva pravarteta AtmaviSaye kazcana vivAda:, savikalpAyA ahaMbuddhernizcayAtmakatvAt, nizcayena ca viSayIkRte adhyAropAbhAvAcca | evamevAnyo’nyeSvapyevaJjAtIyeSu sambhavAd vipralambha: | anAdi- kAlAbhyAsavazAt pratiniyateSu rUpAdiskandheSu ekatvamadhyAropya paraM vyAvarttayitumahamiti pratIti:, tasyAM pratItau teSAmeva rUpAdInAM pratibhAsamAnatvAt | kAye cAyamAtmagraha:, kathaM tarhi mama deha iti bhedamAtragrahaNamiti cet ? taccAtmAlambane’pi tulyam | yadi cAtmani ayamAtmagraha:, kathaM tarhi mama AtmA iti cintyate | atha vastuto’bhinne’pi bhedAntaraparihAreNa tanmAtrajijJAsAyAM zilAputrakasya zarIravad bhedopacAreNa grahaNAnnAsti virodha iti cet ? dehAlambane’pi caitat samAnam | AtmA khalu viSaya: puna: kramotpattyA virudhyata iti pazcAt vakSyate | na kevalamAtmagraha AtmA apitu tadviSayo rUpAdirAtmA’stItyapi vaktuM na zakyate, tadavilakSaNatvAttasya | krameNopalabhyamAnatvAnna te ekasvabhAvA:, na ca svatantrA: | ata evoktam {1. ma. sU. 6/8, darabhaMgA saMskaraNam |} – na cAtmadRSTi: svayamAtmalakSaNA na cApi du:saMsthitatA vilakSaNA | nAmavyavahArasya tu abhISTatvAnnAtra kazcidapi vivAda: | ata eva nAsti kiJcidAtmaprasAdhakaM pramANam | nAsti pratyakSamanumAnaM ca vyatiricya pramANamityanyatra vicAritam | @118 bAdhakapramANaM tAvannirAkriyate- yadyevamAtmA skandhebhyo’bhinnastadA skandhavat kSaNika: syAd athavA skandhA: khalvAtmavannityA: syu:, tadabhinnatvAt, skandhavadanekatvaprasaGgo’pi durnivAra: syAt | ata: skandheSveva Atmeti prajJapyate, na tAvannAmni vivAda: | atha skandhebhyo bhinna AtmA iSyate tadA sukhAdinA’sambaddhatve na sidhyet tasya bhoktRtvAdikam | tatra prayoga:- yo nAsti sukhadu:khAdibhi: sambaddha: sa nAsti kartA vA bhoktA vA, mukta: saMsArI vApi na yujyate, yathA vandhyAputra: | AtmA’pi tathA’rthakriyAdibhirna kathaJcanApi sambaddha iti vyApakAnupalabdhi: | na cAyamasiddho hetu:, tathA hi- sukhAdinA hi sambandhe sati AdhArAdheyalakSaNo vA saMyogalakSaNo vA kAryakAraNalakSaNo veti pakSatrayam | na tAvat prathama: pakSa:, akiJcitkaratvAt | tathA hi- adha:prasarpaNadharmiNAM jalAdInAmadhogamanapratibandhakatvena vyavasthApyate tAvadAdhAra: | sukhAdInAmamUrtatvAnna sambhavati (teSAm) adhogamanamiti kathamiva Atmana AdhAratvamiti {1. syAdAdhAro jalAdInAM gamanapratibandhata: | agatInAM kimAdhArairguNasAmAnyakarmaNAm || -pra. vA. 1/70; api ca tulanIyam- syAdAdhAro jalAdInAM gamanapratibandhaka: | agatInAM kimAdhArai: sAmAnyAnAM prakalpitai: || -ta. saM. 801 kA. |} | sthityA’pi nAdhAra:, sthite: sthAturabhinnatvAt, tasyaiva kArakatvamiti ? tadapi tAvanniSidhyate | sthite: pRthakatve sati sA naiva tAvatsthAturupakArikA arthAntarabhUtatvAttasyA: {2. sthitimAn nAzraya: sarva: sarvotpattau ca sAzraya: | tasmAt sarvasya bhAvasya na vinAza: kadAcana || -pra. vA. 1/73} | nAstyeva tasyAM sthAturutpAdasAmarthyam, asAmarthyasya sarvatraivAbhivyaktatvAt | svayaM bhaGgAtmana: tAvannAsti kazcana sthApaka:, anavasthitatvAttasya, anyathA tena bhaGga eva tasya syAnna tAvadavasthAnam | avipariNAmAtmani tAvat sthApakena kiM kriyate, sthirAtmanA svabhAvena svayamavasthitatvAt | {3. svayaM vinazvarAtmA cet tasya ka: sthApaka: para: | svayaM na nazvarAtmA cet tasya ka: sthApaka: para: || -pra. vA. 1/74} @119 ata evAkiJcitkaratvena saMyogasambandho’pi tAvannaiva yujyate, atiprasaGgAt | evaM hi sati sarvasya sarvasaMyogahetutvam | evaM ca naivopapadyate tAvad bhinnArthena bhinnArthasya saMyoga:, sarvasya svayamavasthitatvAt lauhazalAkAvat | api ca, saMyogabalena yadi AtmA sukhI vA du:khI vA bhavet, tadA saMyogaikatvameva syAt, aviziSTatvena pratiniyatAtmabhi: sukhAdibhirnaiva syAt sambandha: | tata evAtmanA sahaikatve sukhAdinA naiva syAt kazcit sukhI vA du:khI vA | adarzane’pi balenAbhyupagate nizcaye tenaiva nizcita: syAttadA kiM tAvat saMyogaparikalpanayA, sarvasAmarthyavirahitatvAttasya | sambandhibhedena bhinnAyAmapi prajJaptau paramArthata: bhAvAnAmabhinnasvabhAve sati kathaM svabhAvabhedAzrita: pRthagarthIkriyAbheda: syAditi kumatiparikalpita evAyaM khalu sambandha: | na cApi kAryakAraNasambandha: | krameNa vedyamAnatvAt sukhAdInAm | avikale hetau sati na yujyate tAvat kAdAcitkakAryasambhava:, aviziSTatvAt | parairanAdheyAtizayo’pratibaddhasAmarthyo vA khalvAtmA kathaM sahakArikAraNamapekSya krameNotpAdayet, na hi sahakAriNi tadapekSA | du:khotpAdahetutvAd yadi baddhastadA sarvathA baddhatvAnnaiva mukta: syAt, tatsvabhAvAparityAgAt, parityAge vA kathaM nitya: syAt | adu:khAvasthotpAdahetutvAd yadi muktastadA vimukta eva bhavenna kadAcidapi baddha: syAttadA kathaM tAvat kalpyeta AdheyanibandhanaM bandhamokSatvamiti |{1. du:khasyotpAdahetutvaM bandha:, nityasya tat kuta: || adu:khotpAdahetutvaM mokSa: nityasya tat kuta: | -pra. vA., 1/204-5 |} yadi caitanyAdilakSaNatvenotpAdasAmarthyena vA kartA syAttadA kartA eva sadA bhavet kathaM tAvad bhoktA ?{2. ekarUpe ca caitanye sarvakAlamavasthite | nAnAvidhArthabhoktRtvaM kathaM nAmopapadyate ||-ta. saM. pa., bhAga 1/288, bau. bhA. pra. |} atha sukhAdyutpAdahetutvena yadi bhoktA syAttadA bhoktaiva bhavet kathaM tAvat kartA ? kiJca kApilaparikalpitasya{3. caitanyavyatiriktaM hi na didRkSAdi vidyate | tasyodayavyayAveze durvAra: puruSe’pyasau || zubhAzubhaM ca karmAsti naiva cedAtmanA kRtam | tadeSa bhogabhedo’sya kuta: samupajAyate || yasya yadbhAvavyavasthAnibandhanaM nAsti, nAsau prejSavatA tadbhAvena vyavasthApya: yathA- AkAzaM mUrttatvena | nAsti ca bhoktRvyavasthAnibandhanaM puruSasya didRkSAdIti kAraNAnupalabdhe: | na cAyamasiddho heturiti pratipAditam | -ta. saM. pa., bhAga 1, 290-291 kA., pR. 143|} (Atmana:) @120 sukhAdibhirAkAzavannirvikAratvena naiva khalu yujyate bhoktRtvam, atiprasaGgAt | sati vA vikAre nityatAhAni: | na khalu hetumAtratayA kartA vA bhoktA vA, atiprasaGgAt | tathaiva smRtyAdiSvapi nAzrayitvamupayujyata iti yojyam | tasmAnnairAtmyavAdinyeva pakSe bandhamokSAdivyavasthA yuktimatI | kAryakAraNavaiziSTyamAtreNa tasyA vyavasthAyA prabhAvitatvAt | sa ca kAryakAraNabhAvastAvadanityeSveva sambhavati, na khalu nityeSu | teSu nAsti kasyacidapi kAryasya krameNotpAdasAmarthyam, yathoktaM prAk | na cApi yugapad, tathAvidhaphalotpAdasamarthasvabhAvAnugame phalotpAdAbhAvastAvanna yujyate prAgvat | {1. atrocyate-dvitIye hi kSaNe kAryaM prajAyate | prathame kAraNe jAtamavinaSTaM tadA ca tat || kSaNikatvAttu tatkAryakSaNakAle na varttate | vRttau vA viphalaM kArya nirvRttaM tadyatastadA || avinaSTAdeva kAraNAt kAryaM bhavatIti na: pakSa:, na caivaM yaugapadyaprasaGga: | tathA hi– prathamakSaNabhAvikAraNamAsAditAtmalAbhamavinaSTameva pratItya dvItIye kSaNe kArya prajAyate | tacca tathA jAyamAnamavinaSTAdeva jAyate; prathame kSaNe tasyAvinaSTatvAt | kAryasattAkAlaM ca na kAraNamanuvarttate; kSaNikatayA’navasthAnAt | satyAmapi cAnuvRttau na tadAnIM tasya kAraNatvam; niSpanne kArye tasyAkiJcitkaratvAt | -ta.saM. pa., bhAga 1, 509-510 kA., pR. 217 |} ananugame ca prAksvabhAvatAhAni: | kramayaugapadyAbhyAM vyatirikto nAstyeva kazcidAkArAntara:, ya: syAdarthakriyAyAM prabhaviSNu:, parasparaparihArasthita- lakSaNatvAttayo: | ata eva yAvanta: paraparikalpitA AkAzAdayo’kSaNikA bhAvAste sarve arthakriyAsAmarthyarahitatvAd abhAvavyavahAraviSayA ucyante paramavicakSaNairbauddhairiti | zazaviSANAdAvapi abhAvavyavahAraprajJapti: arthakriyAyAM sAmarthyAbhAvamAtranibandhanaiva, etadbalenArthakriyAsAmarthyaviSayikA khalu bhAvavyavahAraprajJapti:, parasparaparihArasthitalakSaNatvAd bhAvAbhAvayo: | evaMvidhe sarvasAmarthyazUnye zazaviSANAdyavizeSe’pi ‘bhAva:’ iti nAma vyavahAre sati nAsti nAmni vivAda: | tathApi arthakriyArthino hi prekSAvanta: @121 api tu khalu puna: subhUte na bodhisattvena vastupratiSThitena dAnaM dAtavyam, na kvacitpratiSThitena dAnaM dAtavyam | tathAvidhAnupalambhasvabhAve vandhyAputrAdyavizeSe ca bhAvavyavahAro na yujyata ityAhu: | ata eva nAsiddho hetu: | na cAnaikAntika:, AkAzAdiSvapi kartRtvaprasaGgAt | sapakSe sattvAnna ca viruddha: | tasmAdAtmano lakSaNAntarAbhAvAd vandhyAputrasadRza eva | vinazvaratve sati skandhAntargatA eva pudgalA: prasajyeran, sarvasaMskRtAnAM skandhasaMgRhItatvAt | athAvinazvaratve tAvat skandhAntargatadharmavisadRzatvAdarthAntarA eva te bhaveyuriti doSo’yamuktapUrva eva | ato nAsti kazcidanirvacanIyo bhAva iti | ata: ‘sarve dharmA nirAtmAna:’ iti bhagavata: siMhanAda: samastatairthikakuJjaravRndAnAM bhIkara:, anavamardanIyatvAt | alamativistareNa | 2. pAramitAyoga-sthAnam : pAramitAyogamadhikRtyAha- api tu khalu puna: ityAdi | etacca padadvayaM sAmAnyavizeSasvabhAvAtmakaM draSTavyam | dAnaM dAtavyaM na tu- vastupratiSThitena bodhisattvenetyartha: | dAnam ityanena trividhadAnamadhikRtya SaT pAramitA darzitA:, na tu dAnamAtram | tatrAmiSadAnena dAnapAramitA nirdiSTA, abhayadAnena tAvad zIla-kSAntipAramite, dharmadAnena tu vIrya-dhyAna-prajJApAramitA: | {1. ye sada pAramitAsu carantI te pratipanna iho mahAyAne | -zi. sama.. pa. 6. mi. pra., 1960 |} vIryAbhAve dharmAdAna-pravacanayo: parikhinnatvAnna dharmaM dezayet | dhyAnAbhAve zraddhAtirekakarmAbhilASatayA saMkliSTA bhaved dezanA | prajJAyAzcAbhAve sa tad viparItatayA dharmaM dezayet | tasmAt trayAbhAve na sidhyati dharmadAnam | vIryaM sarvatragamityapare | dAnaM dAtavyam ityanena SaTsu pAramitAsu chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM kathaM sthAtavyamiti nirdiSTam | na vastupratiSThitena ityAdinA’tra yogasamApattyA @122 kathaM pratipattavyamityAveditam | evaM hi bodhisattvena dAnaM dAtavyam {1. dAnaM hi bodhisattvasya bodhiriti | -ratna. sU. (uddhRtam- zi. samu., 1 pari., pR. 22), ##Toh: 231 Sde bka (mdo Sde, wap. 12)} ityAdinA vikSepaM nigRhya kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyamityetannirdiSTam | tatra na vastupratiSThiteneti prajJApAramitAyAM yogasya yAthAvattvaM tAvannirdiSTam | tatra deya-dAyaka-pratigrAhakAdivastuSu yattattvato’bhinivezanaM tat pratiSThAnam | yadi bodhisattva: vastunyabhinivizya pAramitAyAM yuJjIta, mithyAyogo bhavet, paramArthata. kasyacidapyabhinivezyavastuna: sarvathA’bhAvena viparItAbhinivezAt, tatsAdhakabAdhakapramANAbhAvabhAvatazca | tathA hi- parai: paramArthata iSTA vijJAnavyatiriktA arthAstAvanna pratyakSasiddhA:, arthAntareNa jJAnena grahaNAyogAt | arthe sati sAkAreNa nirAkAreNa anyAkAreNa vA jJAnena grahaNamiti traya: pakSA:{2. anirbhAsaM sanirbhAsamanyanirbhAsameva ca | vijAnAti na ca jJAnaM bAhyArthaM kathaJcana || na nirAkAreNa nApi sAkAreNa nApi viSayAkArAdanyAkAreNa bAhyasya grahaNaM yuktam, anyazca prakAro nAsti | -ta. saM. pa., bhAga 2, 1998 kA., pR. 682. bau. bhA. pra., 1982 ; puna:- tadAkAreNa nirAkAreNa anyAkAreNa ca jJAnena grahItumazakyatvAdyathAkramaM vAcyam | -Aloka: pa 392 darabhaMgA saMskaraNam 1960 |} | tatra tAvanna sAkAreNa citravarNAdidarzanakAle ekajJAnAbhinnatvAdAkArANAmapyekatvaM prasajyeta, athavA AkArAbhinnatvAdAkAravajjJAnasyApyanekAtmakatvaM prasajyeta | anekatvaM tAvanna yujyata eva, ekaikaparamANugrAhyajJAnAnubhavAbhAvAnna sidhyati tAvajjJAnasyaikatvam, tadasiddhAvanekatvamapi khalvasiddham, ekaikasaMhatisvarUpatvAd anekasya | citrAkAravyavasthApanAyai anekajJAnotpAdaparikalpanayA’pi jJAnasya viSayaM vyApya sthitatvAd grAhakajJAnAnAmutpAdo’pi na sambhavati, amUrttatvAjjJAnAnAm | anyacca, sArUpyaM tAvadekadezena bhavet sarvAtmanA vA | tatra na tAvat sarvAtmanA- arthavajjJAnasyApi jaDasvabhAvaprasaGgAt | na caikadezena- ekasya tAvanniravayavatvAd | vyAvRttibhedenAMzopacAre’pi vastvAdisArUpyadharmANAM sarvatra @123 vidyamAnatvAt sarveNa sarvamavagamyeta | atha tadutpannaM tatsArUpyaM cetyetaddvayena vedayatIti arthasArUpyasya samanantarapratyayasyApi grAhakatvaprasaGga: | satyapi sArUpye paramArthata: bAhyArtho na pratyakSasiddha:, nIlAkArAtmano jJAnasya svasaMviditatvAt | yato hi pratyakSaiva nIlAdivijJaptirnAparA | yattad vijJAnaM tadevArthagrAhakamiti cet ? bhavatu nAma prajJaptita:, na tu paramArthatastad vedanam, AtmAkArasya svasaMviditatvAt, atyantaparokSatvAdarthAnAM kathaM tadAkAraM jJAnaM bhavediti | svAkArAdhAnena tAvadutpAdako heturnaiva niyamena sidhyati, vyabhicArAt | paramANava: khalunaiva sthUlapratItiviSaya:, sUkSmatvAtteSAm | na ca saMhitA:, tebhyo’narthAntaratvAt vikalpaviSayANAm asattvAcca | saMhatArthAntaratve pRthak pratibhAsa: syAt | AvRtAnAvRtayozca virodhAnnaiva tAvad yujyata ekatvam | anekatve saMghAtasya paramANureva sa syAnna tvarthAntara: | na ca tAvannirAkArapakSa:- nIlAdiSvakiJcitkaratvAttasya | bhAvamAtreNa vedane sati sarvai: sarvavedanaprasaGga:, aviziSTatvAt sarvasya | ato nIlasaMvedanamidam, na pItamiti vyavasthA na syAt, vyavasthAyA: kasyApi hetuvizeSasyAbhAvAt | vizeSasya kasyacidabhyupagame sa eva tAvat sAkAratvAbhyupagama: | pratItisvabhAvamAtre tAvad vizeSAbhAvAjjJAnAtmani nAkArAtiriktaM bhedakamanyat syAt | naivAnyAkArapakSa:, atiprasaGgAt | evaM hi sati rUpaviSayakamAkAravijJAnaM tAvat parIkSAmarhati, tathA hi-na tAvat pratyakSato’rtha: sidhyati, nAnumAnAdapi | apratyakSasyArthasya jJAnasya ca kenApi hetunA sambandhAsiddhe: | phalajJAnAd bhinnasya kAraNamAtratvAnumAne neSTasiddhi:, itarasya samanantarapratyayasya vidyamAnatvAt | itarat pramANaM nAsti, ato tAvannaiva sidhyati bAhyo’rtha: | na tAvat paramArthata: jJAnasvabhAvatA pratyakSeNa sidhyati, advaitasvabhAvatAyA asaviditatvAt, anyathA na ko’pi tattvadraSTA syAt | nAnumAnenApi evavidhenAkAreNa kasyApi heto: sambandhasyAsiddhe: | nanvevaM kathaM saMklezavyavadAne syAtAmiti cet ? na, tvanmate tAbhyAM saha tasya kasyavidapi sambandhasyAsiddhatvAt | tayo: paramArthata: kvacidapi vastuni @124 sambandhAsiddhe: | na tAvat tadutpattilakSaNasambandha:, sarvathA parokSatvAttasya | parokSeNa saha sambandhastu na kenApyarvAgdarzinA grahItuM zakyate | avidyAdInAmavicAraramaNIyatve’pi saMklezamUlatve nAsti virodha:, avidyAdau vicAreNa tRSNAnivRttau vyavadAnam, tato vipakSabhUtalakSaNam avicAraika- ramaNIyamupapadyate, tadA paramArthato vastvabhAvena kathaM tayorapyabhAvaprasaGga: | ye etayorekAntena nirhetukatvamabhyupagacchanti, teSvevAya prasaGga:, na tu saMvRtita: pratItyasamutpAdavAdiSu | ata eva paramArthata: bhAvasvabhAvasAdhakaM kiJcidapi pramANaM nAsti, astyeva ca bAdhakam | ityevaM tAvat- yadekAnekasvabhAvavigata tat paramArthato ni:svabhAvam, gaganAravindavat{1. ni:svabhAvA amI bhAvAstattvata: svaparoditA: | ekAnekasvabhAvena viyogAtprativimbavat || - ma. a., 1 kA. (uddhRtam- bo. ca., 9/2), ##Toh: Sde bstan (Dbuma, Sa p. 53)} | parairiSTA: sarve jJAnajJeyAtmakA: bhAvAkArA:, ekAnekasvabhAvazUnyA ityato vyApakAnupalabdhi:, ekAnekAbhyA vyAptatvAt svabhAvasya | dvayametat tatra nAsti | eva tAvad rUpAdyAyatanAnA bAhyavastUnAM naikatvam, AvRtyanAvRtyorviruddhadharmayostatropalabdhe: | api ca, viruddhadharma- saMsarge’pyekatve vizvamapyekadravyaM syAt | tato yugapadutpattivinAzau syAtAm | nAnekatvamapi, tathA hi- anekasmin vibhajyamAne sati vibhaktA: paramANava eva syu:, tatazca paurvAparyAvasthAnaM na syAnniravayavatvAt paramANUnAm, cittacaitasikavat | tato dizaM vyApya avasthitA na pratibhAseran | ata eva digbhAgabhedo’bhyupagantavya eva | sati cAbhyupagame kathaM nAma bhavedekatvam | {2. SaTkena yugapadyogAt paramANo: SaDaMzatA | SaNNAM samAnadezatvAt piNDa: syAdaNumAtraka: || -viMzikA, 12 kA. ; api ca tulanIyam- aNUnAM pUrvAparasthitAnAM pUrvAdidigbhAgatvena vibhidyamAnAnAm asiddhAvapyaNusaMcayAtmakatve nAnekasvabhAvo yukta:, na caikAnekasvabhAvavyatirekeNApara: kazcid bhAvasvabhAvo’stIti ni:svabhAvA evAmI paramArthata: svapnAdyupalabdharUpAdivad rUpiNo bhAvA: | etacca bhagavataiva coktam AryalaMkAvatAre (2 pari. pR. 24) “go viSANaM punarmahAmate, aNuzo’pi vibhidyamAnaM nAvatiSThate | punarapyaNavo’pi bhidyamAnA aNutvalakSaNena nAvatiSThante” iti | -bhA. kra., pR. 179 (ti. saM. saMskaraNam)} ata: siddha eva tAvadekAnekasvabhAvavirahatvaM bAhyArthAnAm | @125 nIlAdipratibhAsino jJAnasyApi naikasvabhAvatvam, citrAkAra- grAhitayA’vabhAsyamAnatvAt, bhinnasantAnavarttyanekavijJAnakSaNavat | {1. citrAvabhAseSvartheSu yadyekatvaM na yujyate | saiva tAvatkathaM buddhirekA citrAvabhAsinI || -pra. vA., 2/208 kA., bau. bhA. pra. ; api ca tulanAyam- ye cArUpiNaste’pi tathaiva vicAryamANA ni:svabhAvA eva | tathAhi, bAhyasya nIlAderarthasyAbhAvAt sAmarthyata eva vijJAnAdayo’rUpiNa: skandhA nIlAdirUpeNa pratibhAsanta ityabhyupeyam | uktaM ca bhagavatA- “bahirdhA nAsti vairUpaM svacittaM dRzyate bahi:” | iti | (la. sU., 10/489) tatazca nIlAdicitrAkAranirbhAsatayA grAhyagrAhakAkAranirbhAsatayA naikasvabhAvA amI yuktA: | na caikasyAnekarUpatA yuktimatI, ekAnekavirodhAt | ekasya kasyacit svabhAvasyAsiddhAvanekarUpatA’pyayuktimatI, ekasamUharUpatvAd anekasya | -bhA. kra., pR. 179-180 (ti. saM. saMskaraNam) |} yathAsaMkhyam anekavijJAnAni yugapat pravartanta ityapi vaktuM na yujyate niravayavAnAmamUrtAnAM khalu paurvAparyAvasthiterayuktatvAt | tathAvasthAnAbhAve na tathAvabhAsa: | atha syAt- vijJAnaM tvekameva, mithyAkArANAM tatrAvabhAsyamAnatvAnna nAnAtvadoSa iti cet ? sati caivaM kathaM te tatra bhAseran mRSA: | avabhAsa iti prakAzAtmaka ucyate | tasya jJAnagatadharmatve sati mithyAkArANAM zazaviSANAdivadatyantAbhAva: syAditi kathamavabhAseranniti | tata: prakAzAtmakAkArebhya: mRSAtvenAbhyupetebhya: kastAvadanya: jJAnasvabhAva: sadbhUtaste’vaziSyate, prakAzAtmalakSaNatvAd vijJAnasya | nIlAdayo’pi prakAzAtmakA: svabhAvenAvabhAsyamAnatvAt | nIlAdInAM svasvabhAvAd bhinnaM yadanyat prakAzarUpamiti sadbhUtaM kimapi nAsti, anyavyavacchedApekSayA vizeSe prAyazo vyavahArAt | vizeSANAM mithyAtve sarveSAM mithyAtvamativispaSTaM syAt | nirAkArasya (mithyAkArasya) satyAkArAtmani (sAkArAtmani) jJAne kathaM niyamenAvabhAsa: syAt, tayostAvat tAdAtmyalakSaNo vA tadutpattilakSaNo vA sambandha eva nAsti | sambandhAbhAve na khalu yujyate’vabhAsanam, atiprasaGgAt | ata eva nAsti tAvadasiddho hetu: | bhAvAnAmanyAkArAbhAvAnnApyanaikAntika: | na cApi viruddha:, sapakSe sattvAt | ata evaM yathA yathArthAzcintyante vizIryante tathA tathA | {2. yathA yathArthAzcintyante vizIryante tathA tathA | -pra. vA., 2/209 kA. |} tathA coktam- @126 vastusvabhAvacintAyAM yathA na satsvabhAvatA | ekAnekasvabhAvo’pi na teSAM vidyate tathA || api cAryalaGkAvatAre bhagavatoktam {1. laMkAvatArasUtram, 10/709, 2/173 |} yathA hi darpaNe rUpamekatvAnyatvavarjitam | dRzyate na ca tannAsti tathA cotpAdalakSaNam || buddhyA vivecyamAnAnAM svabhAvo nAvadhAryate | tasmAdanabhilApyAste ni:svabhAvAzca dezitA: || tathA cAryasamAdhirAjasUtre’pi | {2. samAdhi. sUtram, 9/22 |} yathaiva Ardra kadalIyaskandhaM sArArthika: puruSu vipATayet | bahirvA adhyAtma na sAramasti tathopamAn jAnatha sarvadharmAn || tasmAt sarvabhAvAnAM mAyAvadavicAraramaNIyatvAdanabhinivezena dAnaM dAtavyam, na tu vastupratiSThitena ityayamartho’tra yuktisaGgata: | evaM dAnAdiSu yathA yogastathA Adarzita:, nAnyatra | {3. dAnaM saMbuddhabodhiprAptaye prathamaM kAraNam, puNyasaMbhArAntarbhUtatvAt | tacca zIlAlaMkRtameva sugatiparamparAM sukhabhogopakaraNasampannAmAvahadanuttarajJAnapratilambhahetu: | kSAntirapi tadvipakSabhUtapratighapratipakSatayA dAnazIlasukRtamayaM saMbhAramanupAlayantI sugatatvAdhigataye saMpravartate | etacca zubhaM dAnAditritayasaMbhUtaM puNyasaMbhArAkhyaM vIryamantareNa na bhavatIti tadapi ubhayasaMbhArakAraNatayA sarvAvaraNaprahANAya samupajAyate | samAhitacittasya ca yathAbhUtaparijJAnamutpadyata iti dhyAnapAramitApi anuttarajJAnaheturupapadyate | evamete dAnAdaya: satkRtya saMbhRtA api prajJAmantareNa saugatapadAdhigamahetavo na bhavantIti nApi pAramitAvyapadezaM labhante | prajJAkRtaparizuddhibhAja: puna: avyAhatodArapravRttitayA tadanukUlamanuvartamAnA: taddhetubhAvamadhigacchanti, pAramitAnAmadheyaM ca labhante | tathA dAtRdeyapratigrAhakAditritayAnupalambhayogena prajJAparizodhitA: sAdaranirantaradIrghakAlam abhyasyamAnA: prakarSaparyantamupagacchanta: avidyApravartitasakalavikalpajAlamalarahitaM klezajJeyAvaraNavinirmuktamubhayanairAtmyAdhigamasvabhAvaM sarvasvaparahitasaMpadAdhArabhUtaM paramArtha- tattvAtmakaM tathAgatadharmakAyamabhinirvartayantIti prajJApradhAnA dAnAdayo guNA ucyante | -bo. ca. paM., 9/1 pR. 168, mi. saM. 1960 |} yadi paramArthata: kasyacidapi vastuno bhAvAbhAvAd vastupratiSThitena dAnaM na dAtavyam, tadA avastvabhinivezena tu dAnasya kathaiva kA, ata eva na @127 na rUpapratiSThitena dAnaM dAtavyam | na zabdagandharasa- spraSTavyadharmeSu pratiSThitena dAnaM dAtavyam | evaM hi subhUte bodhisattvena mahAsattvena dAnaM dAtavyaM yathA na nimittasaMjJAyAmapi pratitiSThet | kvacitpratiSThitena ityuktam | bodhisattvenAbhAvavikalpo’pi prahAtavya:, bhAvagrAhAbhAve sati tasyApyabhAvAt | {1.kAtyAyanAvavAde cAstIti nAstIti cobhayam | pratiSiddhaM bhagavatA bhAvAbhAvavibhAvinA | -astIti, kAzyapa, ayameko’nta: | nAstIti, kAzyapa, ayameko’nta: |… -ma. zA. vR., pR. 117, bau. bhA. pra., 1983 |} saMvRtau tAvad deyadAyakAdayo bhavantyeva | tato vastuno’bhAve’pi tAvadabhinivezo na yujyata evetyabhiprAya: | na rUpa- pratiSThitena ityAdinA bodhisattvena na kvacitpratiSThitena dAnaM dAtavyamityeva vistareNAbhihitam | dharma: ityanena zabdena dharmAyatanaM parigRhyate, Ayatanena prapaJca: abhivyajyate, atazcakSurAdIni AdhyAtmikAyatanAni nocyante | anutpAdAdayo vikalpA api na karaNIyA iti nidarzanArthaM subhUte, {2. zobhanA araNAvihAriNAM madhye agrA bhUti: cetasa saMpattiryasya sa subhUti: | -Aloka:, pR. 281 |} yathA ityAdyuktam | nimittaM tu vastusvalakSaNaM liGgaM vA’nutpAdAdi, tasyodgrahaNaM saMjJA {3. nimittodgrahaNAtmikA saMjJA | -abhi. ko., 1} | tatra nirvikalpantu apratiSThitam | ata eva na kvacit pratiSThitena iti nirdiSTam | athavA samagreNaitena gAmbhIryamasya vyapadiSTam, adhyAropAvAdAntau pratiSiddhau ceti | asmin darzane upalambhakAnAM jJAnapuNyasambhArapAripUriyogyatvaM pratiSidhyate, evaM pUjAnugrahakAmyayA yad dIyate, tenAtitarAM samprasAdo janyate, {4. dIyate dAnaM pUjAnugrahakAmyayA....dra^- abhi. ko. 4/113 pR. 740 ; punazca- yena pUjAnugrahakAmyayA’rthine’narthine vA dIyate tad dAnam | -vi. mA. si., pR. 219 |} na tu deya-dAyaka-pratigrAhakAnupalambhe pratiSThitatvena, evaM hyabhAva:, deyAdyanupalabdhatvAd viSayasyAbhAvAcca | prathamapakSe kenApi kasyacidapi deyasyAbhAvAt puNyAbhAva: prasajyate, (dvitIyapakSe tAvat) bodhisattvai: yo hi sattvArthaM zrama Asthita:, so’pi vyartha: syAt sattvAbhAvAt | ata eva nAbhAvamAtram | @128 tatkasya heto: ? ya: subhUte, bodhisattvo apratiSThito dAnaM dadAti, tasya subhUte, puNyaskandhasya na sukaraM pramANamudgrahItum | tatkiM manyase subhUte, sukaraM pUrvasyAM dizi AkAzasya pramANamudgrahItum ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | bhagavAnAha- evaM dakSiNapazcimottarAsu adhaUrdhvadigvidikSu samantAddazasu dikSu sukaramAkAzasya pramANamudgrahItum ? subhUtirAha - no hIdaM bhagavan | bhagavAnAha– evameva subhUte, yo bodhisattvo’pratiSThito dAnaM dadAti, tasya subhUte puNyaskandhasya na sukaraM pramANamudgrahItum | evaM hi subhUte, bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitena dAnaM dAtavyaM yathA na nimittasaMjJAyAmapi pratitiSThet | bhagavatA deyAdivastUnAM dRSTatvAt, na ca viSayasyApyabhAva: | anyathA kathaM bhagavatA’rthijanebhya: putrAdaya: pradattA iti sarvANyetAni codyAni manasi nidhAya tatkasya heto: ? iti pRcchAyAM ya: subhUte, bodhisattva: ityAdinA visarjitam | ayamabhiprAya:- samyagdRSTivihitAni dAnAdIni suvizuddhatayA viziSTeSTaphalAni abhinirvartayanti, na viparItatayA samudbhUtAni, mithyAdRSTi- pravartitazIlAGgAdivat | deyAdivastUni yathoktanyAyena kathaJcidapyasattvAt mithyopalabdhAnyeva, marIcikAsu udakopalambhavat | tasmAt tadudbhUta: sarvapAramitAvidhistAvad AtmAtmIyaviparyAsodgatadAnAdivadavizuddhaheto: sambhUtatvAt kSINabala:, deyAdyupalakSaNaprAptAnupalambhastu bhUtArthagocaratvAdaviparyasta:, marIcikAyAmudakAnupalabdhivat | tasmAdupacitahetusambhUtadAnAdIni bRhatphalAni, puSTabIjAbhinirvRttAGkurAdivat | ata eva anupalambhapratiSThitAni dAnAdIni samyagdRSTisambhUtAnIti vipazcitsu prasAdAtizayaM janayanti, nAnyeSu | tatazca dAnAdiSvapravRttatayA puNyAbhAvo deyAdInAM caikAntAbhAvo neSyate, savRtisattvAbhyupagamAt | asamAhitAvasthAyAM mAyAvadupalambhAnna sarvatrAnupalambha: | tadA cAdhimuktita: prAdurbhAvAdevAnupalambho vyavasthApyate | samAhitAvasthAyAm upalambhasyAtyantAbhAvamAtram, tadA dAnAdiSu pravRttirnAbhyupeyate prayogAvasthAyAM @129 tatkiM manyase subhUte lakSaNasampadA tathAgato draSTavya: ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan, na lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: ? {1. jozI saMskaraNe idaM vAkyaM nopalabhyate, vaidyasaMskaraNe bhoTasaMskaraNe copalabhete | prastutA TIkAyAmapi ayaM pATha upalabhyate | ata eva mayA’pi TIkAnusAramupAdatta: |} tatkasya heto: ? yA sA bhagavan lakSaNasaMpattathAgatena bhASitA saivAlakSaNasaMpat | evamukte bhagavAnAyuSmantaM subhUtimetadavocat– yAvatsubhUte lakSaNasaMpat tAvanmRSA, yAvadalakSaNasaMpat tAvanna mRSeti hi lakSaNAlakSaNastathAgato draSTavya: | vyutthitAvasthAyAM vA kriyayopAlambho na yujyate | ato mahAphalatvAya pAramitAyogasyaudAryamabhidhIyate | saMvRtau kAryakAraNabhAvasyopadarzanAd apavAdAnto’pi niSidhyate | 3. rUpakAyAptikAmatA-sthAnam : tridhA puNyamAkAzasamaM bhavati- sarvatragodArAkSayatvai: | laukikalokottara- puNyaprasavanAt sarvatragatvam, laukikaM tAvat puNyamasamAhitAvasthAyAM prasUyate, lokottaraM tu samAhitAvasthAyAmeva | viziSTa-viziSTataragamanAdudAratvam | yAvatsaMsAramaparyAdAnAdakSayatvam | tadabhAvAnna rUpapratiSThitena dAnaM dAtavyamiti bodhisattva: tathAgatarUpakAyAptikAmanayA dAnAdiSu kathaM pravarteteti cediti codyamAzaGkya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdinA rUpakAyAptikAmatA sthAnaM nirdiSTam | arthato’tra rUpakAye tathAgatatvAbhimAnalakSaNo vipakSo’pAkriyate | lakSaNasampadA {2. atra vajracchedikAyA prasaGge mahApuruSANAM dvAtriMzallakSaNAnyeva lakSaNasampadA |} iti nimittamAtrAbhidhAnena tathAgatasya nikhilo rUpakAya: lakSaNAnuvyaJjanairalaGkRta: paridIpita: | tatra lakSaNAni tAvat cakrAGkahastapAdatAdIni dvAtriMzat padabAhulyabhiyA nollikhyante, sUtreSu yathoktAni tathaivAvadheyAni {3. dra^- dha. saMgra, (ma. sU.saM.) pR. 334 ; abhi. samaya. pR. 85, ti. saM. saM., 1977 ; a.vi. sU., pR. 53, Aloka:, pR. 537; mahA.vyu., ##Toh: Sde bstan (Sna Tsogs, Cap. 7)} | sthAnasthottaptapUrNatvena niSpatti: | {4. tu^- sthAnasthottaptapUrNatvena niSpatte: | -Aloka:, pR. 299} @130 evamukte AyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavantametadavocat- asti bhagavan, kecitsattvA bhaviSyantyanAgate’dhvani pazcime kAle pazcime samaye azItiranuvyaJjanAni tAmravarNanakhAdIni, yathAsUtraM jJAtavyAni | {1. dha. saMgra., (ma. sU. saM.) pR. 336 ; abhi. samaya., pR. 87 ; Aloka:, pR. 539 ; a.visU. pR. 63, 308 ; ##Toh : Sde bstan (Sna Tsogs, Ca p. 9).} tAni lakSaNAdInyapi mAyAnirmitabuddhalakSaNavanmithyaiva | ata eva tathAvidhe rUpakAye chandapraNidhAnAbhyA sthAtavyamiti nirdeza: | athemAni lakSaNAni paramANusaJcayasvabhAvAni vA tadArabdhAvayavirUpANi vA bhaveyuriti ? na tAvat prathama: pakSa:, paramANUnAM pUrvameva nirastatvAt | nApi dvitIya, asati cArambhake tadArabdhAvayavino’pyabhAvAt, pUrvoktAvaraNAdi- viruddhadharmopalambhAcca | taduddiSTenAbhihito’bhiprAya: | etad vicintya subhUtirAha no hIdam iti vyaktIkRtam | yadi lakSaNAni mRSA bhaveyustarhi kathaM bhagavatA tattatsUtreSu lakSaNAni samupadiSTAnIti cintayan tatkasya heto: iti pRSTvaivaM saivAlakSaNasampad ityAha | sA lakSaNasampat tAvannoktA paramArthata: | mAyAnirmitabuddhavadityanena mRSAsvabhAvatvamAtramuktamityartha: | AryasubhUtinoktamevArtha paripUrayituM bhagavatA yAvat ityAdyAha | yAvallakSaNasampad iti paramArthato yAvallakSaNasampatsvabhiniveza:, tAvanmithyAbhiniveza evetyartha:, yathoktameva pUrvam | yAvallakSaNasampad iti tadviparItatayA abhihitetyavagantavyam | etena yogasamApattyA kathaM pratipattavyamiti taddezitam | kathamantadvayaM parivarjya cittaM pragrahItavyamiti tannirdiSTam | evam iti mAyAnirmitabuddhavallakSaNatastathAgato draSTavya: | anenApavAdAnto nirAkriyate, saMvRtau bhagavato rUpakAyasyApratyAkhyAnAt | alakSaNaM tAvat paramArthe draSTavyam, kasyApi lakSaNasyAsiddhatvAt | anena tAvat samAropAnto nirAkriyate | tathAgatasya rUpakAyAvAptaye praNidhAnaistvaudAryamuktam | tadanupalambhatayA ca gAmbhIryam | rUpakAyAptikAmatAsthAnaM tAvaduktam | @131 pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAM saddharmavipralopakAle vartamAne, ye imeSvevaMrUpeSu sUtrAntapadeSu bhASyamANeSu bhUtasaMjJAmutpAdayiSyanti ? bhagavAn Aha- mA subhUte tvamevaM voca: | asti kecatsittvA bhaviSyantyanAgate’dhvani pazcime kAle pazcime samaye pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAM saddharmavipralope vartamAne, ye imeSvevaMrUpeSu sUtrAntapadeSu bhASyamANeSu bhUtasaMjJAmutpAdayiSyanti | api tu khalu puna: subhUte, bhaviSyantyanAgate’dhvani bodhisattvA mahAsattvA: pazcime kAle pazcime samaye pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAM saddharmavipralope vartamAne guNavanta: zIlavanta: prajJAvantazca bhaviSyanti, ye imeSvevaMrUpeSu sUtrAntapadeSu bhASyamANeSu bhUtasaMjJAmutpAdayiSyanti | 4. dharmakAyAptikAmatAsthAnam : (a) pravacanadharmakAya: dvividha: khalu dharmakAya: - pravacanadharmakAya:, adhigamadharmakAyazca {1. zAsanaM dvividhaM zAsturAgamAdhigamAtmaka: | -abhi. ko., 8/39} | adhigamadharmakAyo’pi dvividha: - jJAnahetuka: puNyahetukazca | tatrAnAgate puruSeSu paJcakaSAyANAmAdhikyAdevaMvidhadharmaratnasya atyantagambhIrodAraphalatvAt pravacana- dharmakAye’nAptatvAzaGkayA asti iti pRSTavAn | asti iti padaM tu kecit sattvA: ye imeSvevaMrUpeSu sUtrAntapadeSu bhASyamANeSu bhUtasaMjJAmutpAdayiSyanti ityarthapadena yojyam | pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAm ityatra zatAnAM paJcakaM paJcazatI, bhagavatAM zAsanaM paJcazatavarSANi sthAsyatIti prasiddhe: | ata eva pazcimeti vizeSaNaM vihitam | tasmin kAle paJcakaSAyANAmadhimAtratA bhavati | saddharmavipralopastAvad adhimukti-vAcana-svAdhyAya-upadeza-AkhyAna- zravaNa-cintAdInAM hAni: | evaM iti gambhIrodArArtha: | sUtrAntapadeSu iti sUtrAntadezanAvAca:, tAbhirarthasya pratipAdyamAnatvAt jJApyamAnatvAcca | anena nimittamAtrAbhidhAnena samastapravacanadharmakAyastAvat paridIpyate | athavA sUtrAntapadeSu ityabhidhIyamAnArthakeSu | asmin kathane ‘evam’ ityanena tAvad gambhIraudArye yojanIye | bhASyamANeSu iti prathamatayA abhidhIyamAneSu | dvitIyatayA @132 na khalu punaste subhUte, bodhisattvA mahAsattvA ekabuddhaparyupAsitA bhaviSyanti, naikabuddhAvaropitakuzalamUlA bhaviSyanti | api tu khalu puna: subhUte, anekabuddhazatasahasraparyupAsitA anekabuddhazata- sahasrAvaropitakuzalamUlAste bodhisattvA mahAsattvA bhaviSyanti, ye imeSvevaMrUpeSu sUtrAntapadeSu bhASyamANeSu ekacittaprasAdamapi pratilapsyante | arthapratipAdakeSvityartha: | arthato’viparyayastastasaMjJaivAtra bhUtasaMjJetyabhidhIyate na tu zabdAbhinivezamAtram ‘ayaM bhUta:’ {1. abhUtavinivRttaye bhUtokti: | bhUtazabdanirdezo’bhUtasya nityasya nivRttyartham | -pra. vA. 1/9 pR. 9, bau. bhA. pra. 1968 |} iti saMjJA | anena tAvadarthasiddhau abhUtasaMjJA nirAkriyate | sarvatrApratihatajJAnena tAn bhAvina: (sattvAn) pratyakSavad dRSTvA bhagavAn subhUtisaMzayaM parihartuM bhaviSyanti ityAha | mahAsattvA: iti teSAM bodhisattvaguNAnAM sampradarzanArthamuktam | te’pi yathA pratipannA:, yAdRzena ca hetunA sampratipannA:, yAdRzena kalyANamitreNa parigRhItA:, yathA vA bhUtasaMjJayA saMjJitAstAn bhagavAn paridIpitavAn | zIlavanta: guNavanta: prajJAvantazca {2. zikSayopAsanAtpUrvaM kuzalasyAvaropaNAt | zIlavanto’nyabuddheSu guNavantazca kIrtitA: || sapudgaleSu dharmeSu saMjJAyA viprahANata: | prajJAvantazca saMjJAyA aSTadhASTArthabhedata: || -tri. pra. kA., ti. saM. pra., 1978 |} ityanena tu kramazo’dhizIlAdhicittAdhiprajJAzceti zikSAtrayapratipattisamanvitA: nirdiSTA: | zIlaprajJayozca pRthaguktatvAd guNastAvadatra dhyAnajo grAhya:, gobalIvardanyAyeneti | klezavati pazcimakAle tu kathaM tathAvidhazIlAdiguNavanto bhaviSyantIti cintayitvA subhUte ityAdyAha | paryupAsitA: iti cIvara-piNDapAtAdibhi: paryupAsitA:, chatradhvajapatAkAdibhizca pUjitA bhaviSyanti | avaropitakuzalamUlA: tAvadavavAdamanuzAsanIM ca zirasAdAya zIlAdiguNasampadbhya: prayatnavanto draSTavyA: | teSAM tato’pi bahutaraM puNyamabhidhAtuM anekabuddhazatasahasra: ityuktam | @133 jJAtAste subhUte, tathAgatena buddhajJAnena, dRSTAste subhUte, tathAgatena buddhacakSuSA, buddhAste subhUte, tathAgatena | sarve te subhUte, aprameyamasaMkhyeyaM puNyaskandhaM prasaviSyanti, pratigrahISyanti | tatkasya heto: ? na hi subhUte, teSAM bodhisattvAnAM mahAsattvAnAmAtmasaMjJA pravartate, na sattvasaMjJA, na jIvasaMjJA, na pudgalasaMjJA pravartate | nApi teSAM subhUte, bodhisattvAnAM mahAsattvAnAM dharmasaMjJA pravartate, evaM nAdharmasaMjJA | nApi teSAM subhUte, saMjJA nAsaMjJA pravartate | anena teSAM hetusiddhi: saMdarzitA | jJAtAste tathAgatena iti nAmAnyAzayAzca | dRSTAste tathAgatena iti kAyA: | anena tAvat kalyANamitraparigRhItA iti darzitam | tacca samprasthitAnAM protsAhanArtham, viprasthitAnAM hrIsaJjananArthamAha | anyathA sarveSAM jJAnAt sarvajJo bhagavAniti dezanayA ko vizeSo bhavet, athavA tatteSAM bhavyatvaM yat tatpramukhaM kRtvA dezanA pravartitetyavagantavyam | bhavyA jJAtA iti vAkyazeSa: | atasteSAmazeSaM puNyaskandhasaGgrahaM darzayituM sarve te sattvA: ityAha | prasaviSyanti iti puNyotpAdakAla:, pratigrahISyanti iti nirodhakAle tadvAsanA: parigrahISyanti | ebhi: sarvairabhUtasaMjJAM nirAkRtya bhUtasaMjJotpAdane chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamityAdarzitaM tathA sthAnasyAsyaudAryamapi paridIpitam | tatkasya heto: ? te anekabuddhazatasahasraparyupAsitA: kathaM jJAsyanta iti jJApakahetau paripRSTe’tra teSAM bodhisattvAnAM mahAsattvAnAm ityAdyAha | anena tAvat yogasamApattau kathaM pratittavyamityetat prakAzitam, gambhIratA cApyabhihitA | ahamityAtmagrahaNam AtmasaMjJA sA | mameti grahaNaM sattvasaMjJA, tasyaivAtmana A sthitiM parigraha: jIvasaMjJA, puna: puna: gatiSu gamanAdAnaM pudgalasaMjJA | yadi nAsti AtmAdisaMjJA tarhi kiM zrAvakAdivad asti rUpAdidharmasaMjJA ? iti cintAyAM na dharmasaMjJA ityuktam | paramArthata: kasyacidapi dharmasyAbhAvAdityabhiprAya: | @134 atha kim ucchedavAdinAmiva abhAvasaMjJA ? iti cintAyAM evaM nAdharmasaMjJA pravartate ityuktam | saMvRtau avicAraramaNIyatayA dharmANA sadbhAvAt saMvRtipathasthitebhyastAvad adharmasaMjJA naiva yuktimatI, na tu paramArthajJAnasthitebhya: | tanniSedhAnna kazcid dharma upalabhyate yatrAdharmasaMjJA pravarteta, dharmAgrahaNe tadabhAvAt | viSayAbhAvaniSedhastu na kutrApi sambhavati, tadyathA satye’pi vijJaptimAtre vijJaptimAtrateyamiti vikalpayan na vijJaptimAtratAyAM sthita:, {1. yAvad vijJaptimAtratve vijJAnaM nAvatiSThati | grAhadvayasyAnuzayastAvanna vinivartate || vijJaptimAtramevedamityapi hyupalambhata: | sthApayannagrata: kiJcit tanmAtre nAvatiSThate | dra^- triM. vi. mA. si., 26,27 kA. | evameva satye’pyadharme’dharmabodhasya tatrAvasthAnAsambhavAt sarva samAnam | yadyAtmAdInAmayasya tadA tatra tatsaMjJAyA apravRttau satyA ‘Atmaiva rUpamidam’ ityAdikaM nAmamAtramiti nAmAbhinivezasaMjJA teSAM bhavediti matvA saMjJA’pi ityuktam | nAmnastAvad rUpaskandhAntarbhUtatvAd rUpAdivad mithyAtvameva, viprayuktamapi {2. saMprayuktaviprayuktacaitasikA: ? viprayuktAstu saMskArA....-abhi. ko., 2/35 |} prajJaptimAtramiti | tasmAt saMjJA’pi mithyAbhiniveza evetyabhiprAya: | yadyevaM tarhi tasyAmavasthAyAM sarvasaMjJAvigamAd mRta-nirodhasamApanna- pudgalavad {3. AyurUSmAtha vijJAnaM yadA kAyaM jahatyamI | apaviddhastadA zete yathA kASThamacetana: || dra^- (uddhRtam) abhi. ko., 2/45, pR. 248 |} yogino’bhAva eva syAditi nApi…nAsaMjJA pravartate ityuktam | yen ate yogino bhavanti, tacca yogijJAnaM tathyasaMvRtisvabhAvamiti | vyutthAne zuddhalaukikajJAnamudbhavatIti, anyathA ahetukameva tad bhavet | yad yogijJAnaM saMvRtisvabhAvaM tat kenAvagamyata iti cet ? tenaiva hetunA | yathA pratyAtmavedyatayA pudgalanairAtmyAvabodhena AtmasthitaM pudgalanairAtmyamadhigamyate, atrApi tattulyam | jJAnaM saMvittizca na saMvRttau nAbhyupagamyete | yoginA svalakSaNapratyabhimukhIkaraNAt tatrasthaM nairAtmyaM nopalabhyate, tadAnImatItAdeSAvadasaMnihitatvAdanantatvAcca | @135 tatkasya heto: ? sacetsubhUte, teSAM bodhisattvAnAM mahAsattvAnAM dharmasaMjJA pravartate, sa eva teSAmAtmagrAho bhavet, sattvagrAho jIvagrAha: pudgalagrAho bhavet | sacedadharmasaMjJA pravartate, sa eva teSAmAtmagrAho bhavet, sattvagrAho jIvagrAha: pudgalagrAha iti | tatkasya heto: ? na khalu puna: subhUte, bodhisattvena mahAsattvena dharma udgrahItavyo nAdharma: | tasmAdiyaM tathAgatena saMdhAya vAgbhASitA- kolopamaM dharmaparyAyamAjAnadbhirdharmA eva prahAtavyA: prAgevAdharmA iti | kathaM tarhi ? ni:svabhAvatAvicAreNa tadgocarIbhUtAnAM sarvadharmANAM sAmAnyena nairAtmyasaGgrahAt yA khalu vyavasthA saiva yugapadupalambhanam | teSAM tajjJAnamapi paramArthato’viSaya eva, (tathApi) satyasvapnajJAnavadavisaMvAdakatvena prAmANyaM vyavasthApyate | sAmAnyena tatra tadAtmabhAvo’pi saMgRhyate, na tatra pRthak tadAlambakatvam | tasmAt sati nairAtmyadvayAvabodhe teSAmanekazatasahasrabuddhAnAM paryupAsanaM pratIyate | buddhAnAmaparyupAsanayA tAvanna sambhavati tadavabodha: tairthikavat | sa tu saMsAre na ucito bhavatItyabhiprAya: | anayA yogasamApattyA kathaM pratipattavyaM kIdRzyA ca bhUtasaMjJayA tat saMjJAtavyamiti saMdarzitaM tadgAmbhIryamityapi ca paridIpitam | AtmAdInAmasattve teSAmAtmAdisaMjJAyA abhAvAt padasamudAyAdibhi: AtmatvaM sUktaM duruktaM ca lakSaNaM dharmAdharmasaMjJaM kiM teSu niyamena na pravartate ? naivam, yadi bodhisattvAnAM na bhavet tatra saMjJA, (tarhi) ayuktyupapannatIrthakaradharmAn parityajya bhagavaddeziteSu dharmeSu tadadhigamAya kathaM chanda utpAdanIya ityAzaGkAyAM tatkasya heto: ? iti tatsamAdhAnAya sacet subhUte ityAha | ayamabhiprAya:- ekAnekasvabhAvavicAreNa yathA rUpAdilakSaNadharmA na saMvidyante, tathA dezanAdharmA api | yatra dharmasaMjJA tatrAtmAdisaMjJA api nizcayena naiva prahINA, dharmanimittagrahaNamUlatvAt tasyA: | dharmanimittagrAhakamanasikArasya @136 tasyA eva manasikArarUpatvAt maitrIprabhRtiSu tattvamanasikArAsadbhAve nAtmadRSTi: parihIyate | ata eva ekameva yAnam, tacca mahAyAnamityuktam | {1. mahAyAnaM mahAyAnamiti bhagavannucyate sadevamAnuSAsuraM lokamabhibhavanniryAsyati AkAzasamatayA atimahattayA tanmahAyAnam | yathA AkAze aprameyAnAmasaMkhyeyAnAM sattvAnAmavakAza:, evameva bhagavan asmin yAne aprameyANAmasaMkhyeyAnAM sattvAnAmavakAza: | anena bhagavan paryAyeNa mahAyAnamidaM bodhisattvAnAM mahAsattvAnAm | naivAsyAgamo dRzyate, naivAsya nirgamo dRzyate, nApyasya sthAnaM saMvidyate | evamasya bhagavan mahAyAnasya naiva pUrvAnta upalabhyate, nApyaparAnta upalabhyate, nApi madhya upalabhyate | atha samaM bhagavaMstadyAnam | tasmAnmahAyAnaM mahAyAnamityucyate | -a. pra., pR. 12 : AlambanamahattvaM ca pratipattyordvayostathA | jJAnasya vIryArambhasya upAyakauzalasya ca || udAgamamahattvaM ca mahattvaM buddhakarmaNa: | etanmahattvayogAddhi mahAyAnaM nirucyate || -sUtrAlaMkAra: 19/59,60 |} api ca, bodhisattvAnAM sA dharmasaMjJA yadyavazyamanutpannadarzanamArga: syAt tathA sati tena kathamAtmAdisaMjJA prahINA syAt ? darzanamArgapraheyatvAttasyA: | ata: sarvametat parIkSya sa eva teSAmAtmagrAho bhavet ityuktam | tasya taddhetutvAt tadanuzayAprahINatvAccetyabhiprAya: | anyathA tayorbhinnAkAratvAt kathaM dharmasaMjaJaiva AtmagrAha: syAditi | dharmAstAvadatra yuktyupapannAgamalakSaNA eveSTA:, tadviparIrA adharmA: | evaM sati tattatsUtreSu kathaM bhagavatA bodhisattvebhya: saddharma: parigrAhayiSyate ? evamanucintya tatkasya heto: ? iti paripapraccha | tadartha subhUte ityAdyAha | nodgrahItavya: vitathamArgeNa viparItAbhinivezalalSaNena nodgrahItavya:, satya iti nAbhiniviSTavyamiti vAkyArtha: | abhipretasiddhyartha kolopamadezitasya lakSaNasya na grahaManiSeSha ityabhiprAya: | tasmAt ityAdinA sa evArtha: padAntarai: prayukta:, yato hi sarvo dharmo’dharmazca satya ityabhinivezasya viparItAbhinivezatvAd, yuktyopapanno ya AgamasamUha: saMsArArNavottaraNAya prokta: kolopama: (yadA) pAraM gatA niSprayojanatvAt parity#jyo bhavati, kimu (tadA) te’yuktyopapannAstairthikAnAmivAdharmA: | aprayojanamapi tadAlambanaM mayA nAnujJAtamityevamuktavAn tathAgata: | anyathA dharmAdharmAdikaM yadi satyasvabhAvaM syAt tadA paramArthaviSayatvAt tadabhinivezasya saMsArapAragateSvapi yuktisahaM @137 punaraparaM bhagavAnAyuSmantaM subhUtimetadavocat- tatkiM manyase subhUte, asti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatenAnuttarA samyaksaMbodhi: ityabhisaMbuddha:, kazcidvA dharmastathAgatena dezita: ? evamukte AyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavantametadavocat- yathAhaM bhagavan, bhagavato bhASitasyArthamAjAnAmi, nAsti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatena anuttarA samyaksaMbodhirityabhisaMbuddha:, nAsti dharmo yastathAgatena dezita: | syAditi, kimiti tathAgata: tanniSedhatIti ? iti tu saMgrahArtha: | tathA AryaratnakaraNDasUtre’pi bhagavatA uktam {1. ##Toh: 117 Sde bka (Mdo Sde, Ja p. 252##) ; dra.- va. sUtra. 6vAM adhyA. ;} – “bhadanta subhUte kolopamaM dharmaparyAyamAjAnadbhirdharmA eva prahAtavyA:, prAgevAdharmA iti | yo hi dharma: prahIyate, so’pi nAdharma: iti |” {2.tu^ - kullUpamaM vo bhikkhave, dhammaM desessAmi nirattharaNatthAya, no gahaNatthAya | taM suNAtha, sAdhukaM manasi karotha, bhAsissAmI ti | - ma. ni., nAgarI saM. bhikSu ja. kA. sampA., bhAga 1, pR. 180, 1958 |} ya: sUtrAdidharmaparyAya: sa kolopama ucyate | dharmA eva ityetad upalakSaNam | tena rUpAdayo mArgalakSaNAzca dharmA: saMgRhyante | adharmA ityapi upalakSaNamAtram, tena prasiddhiviruddhA: adharmalakSaNA: paraparikalpitA AtmAdayazca upadiSTAste’pi saMgRhyante | athavA dharmAdharmAbhidheyAbhidhAnAt na sarvasaMgrahe doSa: | anena tAvad vikSepaM nigRhya kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyamityetad darzitam | (ba) adhigamadharmakAyasthAnam : (1) jJAnahetukadharmakAya: nanu dharmAdaya: sarve paramArthato mithyAsvabhAvA:, tadA abhisambuddho bhUtvA ‘bhagavatA sarve dharmA dezitA:’ iti tadapi mRSaiva syAt, ata eva bodhisattvai: tathAgatajJAnahetumadhigamadharmakAyaM prAptuM chando na janayitavya:, ityetad vicArya jJAnahetudharmakAyAvAptaye chandotpAdanAya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityuktam | anenArthata: paramArthastu anuttarA samyaksaMbodhiriti abhisambuddha ityetayo: @138 tatkasya heto: ? yo’sau tathAgatena dharmo’bhisaMbuddho dezito vA, agrAhya: so’nabhilapya: | na sa dharmo nAdharma: | tatkasya heto: ? asaMskRtaprabhAvitA hyAryapudgalA: | grahaNamapi vipakSatayA paridIpitam, tathyasaMvRtisvabhAvaM tu tathAgatasya jJAnahetuM jJAnadharmakAyaM prAptuM chanda: praNidhAnaM ca pradarzite | anuttarA samyaksaMbodhi: ityupalakSaNamAtraparidIpanena zrAvaka-pratyekabuddhAdInAM pratipattibhedena bhinna: jJAnahetuko’dhigamakAyastAvannirdizyate | zrAvakAdInAmapi guNA bodhisattvenAvagantavyA eva, anyathA kathaM tAvat sarvajJapadalAbha: | saMvRtisvabhAvastvevam- sambodhi: samboddhavyaM dezanA dezitavyamityAdaya: sarve paryAyA: | bhagavatA kaM paramArthAbhiprAyamabhilakSya sarvaM mithyaivetyuktam, taduktAbhiprAyaM saMgRhya AryasubhUtisthavira: yathAhaM bhagavato bhASitasyArthamAjAnAmi ityetadavocat | yathAhamAjAnAmItyabhiprAyavivaraNam | kasmAnnAbhisambuddha:, dharmadezanA ca na sta iti cintAyAM tatkasya heto: ? iti | agrAhya: iti paramArthastAvannirvikalpajJAnagocaro’pi na bhavatIti uktapUrvam | anabhilApya: zabdAviSayatvAditi | sarve zabdagocarAstAvat samAropitasAmAnyamAtrAtmakA:, sAmAnyasya cAbhAvarUpatvAt | imau dvau (zabdau) abhisambuddhAbhAvasya dharmadezanAbhAvasya ca yathAkramaM hetutayA’bhihitau | nanu syu: sarve bhAvA agrAhyA: anabhilApyA:, tathApi svalakSaNadhAraNAt paramArthata: dharmasvabhAvatAsthitA evetyAzaGkAyAM na sa dharma: ityAha | sarvabhAvAnAM paramArthata: svabhAvena parinirvRttatvAnna sambhavati svalakSaNadhArakatvam | yadyevaM tarhi bhagavatA abhAvo’bhisambuddho draSTavya iti vicArya nAdharma: ityuktam | sa tu prasajyapratiSedhasvabhAva: | anena tAvad yogasamApattiM nirdizya adhyAropo’pavAdAntazca nirastau | tatkasya heto: ? ityupapatti: pRcchyate, tadarthaM asaMskRtaprabhAvitA: ityAha | asaMskRtatvaM tAvad dharmANAM paramArthasvabhAva:, tacca yuktyA vicAryamANamanutpattilakSaNameva paryavasyati, yathA pUrva vicAritam | @139 uktaM bhagavatA dharmasaMgItau {1.-##Toh: 238 Sde bka (Mdo Sde, Sha p. 6##) `yo Ananda, dharmo’nutpanna:, aniruddha:, asthita: avikRtastaducyate Aryasatyamiti’ | {2. tu^- AryANAmetAni satyAni tasmAdAryasatyAnIti sUtra evoktam | kimanyeSAmetAni na satyAni ? sarveSAmetAni satyAnyaviparItatvAt | Aryaistu yathaitAni tathAdRSTAni na punaranyaistatheti | ata AryANAmetAni satyAnyucyante | na tvAryANAM viparItadarzanAt | yadAryA: sukhata: prAhustatpare du:khato vidu: | yatpare sukhata: prAhustadAryA du:khato vidu: || -a.vi.sU.ni., pR. 157-158 ; api ca tu^- “aviparItatvAditi | yasmAt tadAryANAmetyeSAM cAviparItam | du:khameva nAnyathA | Aryaistu yathaitAni satyAni tathA dRSTAni | du:khasatyaM du:khata: anityata: zUnyato’nAtmatazca | evaM yAvanmArgo mArgata: nyAyata: pratipattito nairyANikatazca | nAnyairanAryai: evaM dRSTAni | ata AryANAmetAni satyAnyucyante | na tvanAryANAM satyAnyucyante | kasmAt ? viparItadarzanAt | -abhi. ko. (sphu.), pR. 874 |} idamAnanda, abhisandhAya tathAgatena asaMskRtaprabhAvitA AryazrAvakA iti dezitam, yathA pUrvamuktam | ayaJca ‘utpAdAd vA tathAgatAnAm, anutpAdAd vA tathAgatAnAm’ {3. dra^- utpAdvA tathAgatAnAmanutpAdAdvA tathAgatAnAM sthitaivaiSA dharmANAM dharmatA | -ma. zA.vR., 1/3, pR. 15, bau.bhA. pra. 1983 ||}, nityaM tathaiva sattvAnnirvikAratvAccAsaMskRta: {4. …trividhaM cApyasaMskRtam | AkAzaM dvau nirodho ca;….|| katamau dvau ? pratisaMkhyAnirodha:, apratisaMkhyAnirodhazceti | etadAkAzAditrividhamasaMskRtam | dra^ -abhi. ko, 1/5 pR. 18-19 |}, tadadhigamAdAryapudgalA: tatprabhAvitA bhavanti, dharmatattvAdhigamena prabhAvitatvAdAryaNAm | anyeSu tattvasadbhAvo naiva tAvad yujyate, tacca (tattvaM) asaMskRtamapi na (syAt) prasajyapratiSedhasvabhAvAbhAvAt, bhAvasvabhAvatvAttasya | Aryai: nAnyavidho bhAvasvabhAvo’vabudhyate, tadbhinnasvabhAvasyaivAdhigamAt | bhAvagrahaNAbhAvena tadabhAvarUpatve sati bhAvagrAha eva tAvat prasajyate | ata eva AryasandhinirmocanasUtre {5. ##Toh: 106 Sde bstan (Mdo Sde, CA#)} uktam- ‘na tattvasya bhAvAditaro’rtha:’ iti | ata: yathoktadoSa Apadyate | tattu (tattvaM) paramArthato nAsti bhAvasvabhAva:, asiddhaiva bhAvasvabhAvatA kasyApi | bhAvasvabhAvateva tadapi @140 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, ya: kazcitkulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA imaM trisAhasramahAsAhasraM lokadhAtuM saptaratnaparipUrNaM kRtvA tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhrya: samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, api nu sa kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA tatonidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAt ? subhUtirAha- bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata, sa kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA tato nidAnaM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAt | tatkasya heto: ? yo’sau bhagavan puNyaskandhastathAgatena bhASita:, askandha: sa tathAgatena bhASita: | tasmAttathAgato bhASate-puNyaskandha: puNyaskandha iti | saMskRtaM prasajyeta | ata: abhAvarUpatvena dharmeSu sattvAdatattvameva svabhAvena tat | sarveSAmapi tajjJAnaprasaGga:, bhAvasvabhAvavat | saMklezahetuprasaGgo’pi durnirvAra: syAt | ata eva teSu AryasandhinirmocanAdiSu- `na tattvasya bhAvAditaro’rtha:’ ityuktam | ata eva na dharmo nAdharma: ityuvAca | anena bhAvAbhAvasadasadAdInAM niSedharUpaM dezitam | api cAnena vikSepanigraho’pi nirdiSTa: | etatsarvai: sthAnasyAsya gambhIratvamapi saMdarzitam | (2) puNyahetukadharmakAya: yadi bhagavato’bhisambodhirvA dharmadezanA vA nAsti kazcid dharma:, kathaM tarhi bodhisattvena puNyahetudharmakAyaM prAptukAmena saddharmaparigrahe’nupravartitavyamiti vicintya puNyahetudharmakAyakAmatAcchandotpAdanAya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityuktam | tatra saptaratnAni tAvat svarNa-raupya-vaiDUrya-azmagarbha-musAragalva- lohitamuktA-sphaTikA: AryasaddharmapuNDarIke {1. ye yApi dhAtUn karonti pUjAM jinAn teSAM parinirvRtAnAm | ratnamayAn stUpasahasrAnekAn suvarNarUpasya ca sphATikasya || ye cAzmagarbhasya karonti stUpAn karketanA muktamayAzca kecit | vaiDUryazreSThasya tathaindranIlAn te sarvi bodhAya abhUSi lAbhina: || -saddharma.- 2/78-79; musAragalvavaidUryarUpyasphaTikahATakam | sahalohitamuktAbhirazmagarbhaizca varNyate ||} ratnaM saptavidhaM sarva prAdhAnyAdathavApare | tadbhedA maNaya: sarve varNasaMsthAnalezata: || dra^- Aloka:, pR. 364 |} uktAni | ‘caturdvIpAdInAM sahasraM @141 sAhasro lokadhAtu: {1. caturdvIpakacandrArkamerukAmadivaukasAm | brahmalokasahasraM ca sAhasrazcUDiko mata: || - abhi. ko., 3/73 |} | tatsahasraM dvisAhasra:{2. “tatsahasraM dvisAhasro lokadhAtustu madhyama: |” teSAM cUDikAnAM lokadhAtUnAM sahasraM dvisAhasro madhyamo lokadhAtu: | -abhi. ko., 3/74, pR. 528, bau. bhA. saM., 1987 |} | tatsahasraM trisAhasramahAsAhasro lokadhAtu: {3. “tat sahasraM trisAhasra:”; teSAM dvisAhasrANAM lokadhAtUnAM sahasraM trisAhasramahAsAhasro lokadhAtu: | -abhi. ko., 3/74, pR. 528 |} |’ tato nidAnam iti ratnadAnAnAM nidAnAt tata: puNyodbhava:, tadheto: sambhavatItyartha: | sarvANi kuzalacittAni, tadutpannA vAsanA: puNyAni | teSAM rAzi: skandha iti | phalabAhulyAt tadbAhulyam | bahu iti vizeSaNam | bahu bahu iti dviruktyA bAhulyAdhikyam | yadi paramArthata: sarve (dharmA:) anutpannA:, kathaM tato nidAnaM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAt ? ityAzaGkya tatkasya heto: ? ityuktvA svayamabhiprAyaM viditvA askandha: ityabhihitavAn | paramArthata iti zeSa: | prajJaptisattvAt skandhAnAM na puNyaskandho bhAvarUpeNa sambhavati | puNyamapi vAsanAsvarUpamavasthAvizeSe upacaryate | bhAvAnAM sthiratvena abhisaMskAreNa apravRttatvAt cittamapi prajJaptisanmAtrameva | ekAnekasvabhAvena pratisvaM parIkSAyAM mithyaiva tAvat svabhAva: | ata eva na puNyaskandha: paramArthato vidyate | anena yogasamApatti: paridIpitA, adhyAropAntazca niSiddha: | vidyanta eva puNyaskandhA: saMvRtau | ata eva puNyaskandhastathAgatena bhASita: ityuktam | yadyevaM na syAt, paramArthata: sa puNyaskandho bhavet (tadA) paramArthasya zabdAgocaratvAt na bhavet tadabhidhAnam | abhASitamityevaM vacanaM nirarthakamiti cet ? yato bhASitAstasmAt saMvRtAvevetyavagantavyam | anenApavAdAntasya niSedho nirdiSTa: | evamAryasubhUtinA antadvayaparihAra: kRta: | tadanantaraM pArSadA udAradharmazravaNabhavyA:, tena ca bahutaraM puNyamiti AvedituM bhagavatA yazca khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyuktam | anena tathAgatAnAM @142 bhagavAnAha- yazca khalu puna: subhUte, kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA imaM trisAhasramahAsAhasraM lokadhAtuM saptaratnaparipUrNaM kRtvA tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhya: samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, yazca ito dharmaparyAyAdantazazcatuSpAdikAmapi gAthAmudgRhya parebhyo vistareNa dezayet saMprakAzyet, ayameva tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAdaprameyamasaMkhyeyam | puNyahetukAdhigamakAyasya pravacanakAyato nirjAtatvAt tatazcatuSpAdikAyAmapi gAthAyAM dezyamAnAyAM (yadA) tAdRzaM puNyAyatanaM bhavet (tadA) tathAgatAnAM puNyahetukadharmakAyasya tu kathaiva keti nirdizyate | nAyaM padArtha:, (tathApi) sAmarthyalabhyo’yamartha ityadoSa: | etena paramArthata: dharmadezanAyA: abhisambuddhasya cApyasattve saMvRtau tAvat puNyakAyadezanAyA: sattvAt bodhisattvai: puNyamadhigantuM pravartayitavyamevetyabhiprAya: | anena tAvad viziSTapuNyapratipAdanena audAryamasya paridIpitam, tadutpAdAya ca chandapraNidhAne nirdiSTe | SaTpAdikAyA gAthAyA: sattve’pi catuSpAdikA iti vizeSIkRtA | gAthA iti yatra na yati:, ‘pAda’ zabdena catu:pAdaM gAthAparimANaM parigRhyate | udgRhya iti svAdhyAyaM vidhAya | dezayet iti padAni | samprakAzayet {1. tu^- upadizanti bhAvanAmayajJAnotpAdAt | parimocanArthaM yato granthArthanizcayotpAdanata: saMprakAzayanti | -Aloka:, pR. 286} ityartha: | asaMkhyeyam {2. ekatvAdisaMkhyArahitatvena asaMkhyeyAnAm | -Aloka:, pR. 335 |} iti saMbahulam | aprameyam {3. pratyakSAdipramANena pramAtumazakyatvAdaprameyAnAm | -Aloka:, pR. 335 |} iti pramAviSayAtItatvAt | anena cArthata: puNyAnutpattivipakSastAvannirAkRta: | puNyamityupalakSaNamAtrametena tathAgatasya samasta: puNyasambhAro nirdiSTa: | kimiti zraddheyamAtramuta yuktito’vagamyamiti manasi kRtvA tatkasya heto: ? iti pRcchAyAm ato nirjAtA hi subhUte, tathAgatAnAmarhatAM samyaksaMbuddhAnAmanuttarA samyaksaMbodhi: {4. prajJApAramitA nirjAtA hi Ananda buddhAnAM bhagavatAM bodhi: | ye’pi te Ananda abhUvannatIte’dhvani tathAgatA arhanta: samyaksaMbuddhA:, teSAmapyAnanda, buddhAnAM bhagavatAM prajJApAramitAnirjAtaiva anuttarA samyaksaMbodhirabhUt | te'pi te Ananda anAgate'dhvani bhaviSyanti tathAgatA arhanta: samyaksaMbuddhA:, teSAmapyAnanda buddhAnAM bhagavatAM prajJApAramitAnirjAtaiva anuttarA samyaksaMbodhirbhaviSyati | ye'pi te Ananda aprameyeSvasaMkhyeSu lokadhAtuSu tathAgatA arhanta: samyaksaMbuddhA etarhi tiSThanti dhriyante yApayanti, teSAmapyAnanda buddhAnAM bhagavatAM prajJApAramitAnirjAtaiva anuttarA samyaksambodhi: | -a. pra., pR. 229 |} iti yuktivacanamabhihitavAn | evaM @143 tatkasya heto: ? ato nirjAtA hi subhUte, tathAgatAnAmarhatAM samyaksaMbuddhAnAmanuttarA samyaksaMbodhi:, ato nirjAtAzca buddhA: bhagavanta: | tatkasya heto: ? buddhadharmA {1. bhoTasaMskaraNe vaidyasaMskaraNe ca “buddha dharmA buddha dharmA:” ityevaM pATha: | jozIsaMskaraNe tu “buddha dharmA:” ityevaM pATha: | AcAryakamalazIlakRtAyAM TIkAyAmapi “buddha dharmA:” iti pATha: upalabhyate | ata eva ayameva pATha zuddha: pratIyate |} iti subhUte, abuddhadharmAzcaiva te tathAgatena bhASitA: | tenocyante buddhadharmA iti | bahutaraM puNyam iti tacca bRhatphalatvAttat bahutaraM puNyam, na tu svarUpatastasya kAyAbhAvAt | ratnanirjAta tatpuNyaM tu mahAparibhogAdi gauNasAMsArika phala prApayati | prajJAparigRhItatve sati dAnAdInAM mahAbodhiphalamadhigamyate, na tu prAdezikAnAm | dharmadAnena tAvada kSayApratimatathAgatapadaprApte: tanmahattvaM kimiti na prasaktam ? yathA dharmeNAnugraho na tathA ratnai: pareSAmanugraha: | tathA hi parebhya: samprakAzitena kramazo’nena dharmeNa kSiprameva buddhatvapadaM labhyate, na tu ratnai: | ata eva parebhya: parAnugrAhakatvAd ratnadAnAd dharmadAnaM viziSTamityabhisandhi: | ato nirjAtA: iti sasAdhyate | dazacaritAni ni:zritya pAramparyeNa prApyanta ityartha: | tAni tAvad daza caritAni {2. pUjanA lekhanA dAnaM zravaNaM vAcanodgraha: | prakAzanAtha svAdhyAyazcintanA bhAvanA ca tat || ameyapuNyaskandhaM hi caritaM taddazAtmakam | vizeSAda kSayatvAcca parAnugrahato’samAt || -Aloka, pR. 365}- lekhana pUjanaM dAnaM vAcanaM zravaNam udgrahaNam samprakAzanaM svAdhyAya: cintanaM bhAvanA ceti | ato nirjAtAzca buddhA bhagavanta: {3. dharmakAyA: mAyopamAdvayajJAnasvabhAvA: prajJApAramitAtmakA buddhA: bhagavanta: | -Aloka:, pR. 375. darabhaMgA saMskaraNam, 1960 |} iti saMvRtau etAnyAzritya buddhA: prajJaptA iti @144 vAkyazeSa: | paramArthatastu bodhi: buddhazca bhinnau na sta: | {1. yaM ca piNDapAtaM paribhujya tathAgato’nuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha:, yaM ca piNDapAtaM paribhujya nirupadhizeSe nirvANadhAtau parinivRta:, dAvimau piNDapAtAvasamasamaphalau asamasamavipAkau iti | ta,- Aloka:, pR. 384} anena tAvat puNyasya paramavaiziSTyaparidIpanena tadutpAdayitu chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti dezitam | yadi paramArthata: sarvadharmAnutpAda eva tadA sarve buddha dharmA apyanutpannA eva bhaveyu:, tatkatham ato nirjAtA anuttarA samyaksaMbodhiriti ? na buddhAnAM bodherbhinnatvamiti vicArya tatkasya heto: ? iti paripRcchA, etadarthamatra buddhadharmA: ityuktam | buddhaprajJaptihetukA anuttarasamyaksaMbodhilakSaNA dharmA eva hi buddhadharmA: | tasmAnnaiva kevalaM bodhibhinnA: paramArthata: buddhA:, apitu prajJaptihetutvAd ato nirjAtA buddhA: ityuktamityabhiprAya: | te’pi paramArthato’nutpannatvAd abuddhadharmA iti, saMvRtimAzritya tathAgatAnAmanuttarasamyaksaMbodhistu ato nirjAtA ityAdinA tathAgatena bhASitA, na tu paramArthata iti | ata eva tattaditarapakSebhya: buddhadharmA iti paramArthato naiva vaktuM zakyate | pratyAtmavedanIyatvenAnabhilApyAsta ityabhiprAya: | anena yogasamApatti: vikSepanigraha: gAmbhIryaJca dezitAni | atra kecidAhu:- kathaM tridhA bhinno’yaM dharmakAya: | atha dharmakAyaprApti: dharmakAyahetozcAnurUpatayA puNyasvabhAva:, prajJaptyA ca pravacanasvabhAvo dharmakAya iti ced ? tathA sati rUpakAyo’pi tatprApteranurUpahetutvAt tatprApakahetutvAcca dharmakAya: syAditi | (ata:) tanna satyam, bhagavatAM buddhAnAM dharmakAyastu parizuddhajJAnasvabhAvastathA yA ca tasya sAmAnyadharmatA, tasyAM vyavasthApyate | nAstyasyAyaM vipAkabheda:, na cAtra pravacanapuNyayorupacAreNa dharma: iti dezanA’pi | kimiva tarhIti cet ? vastumAtraM dharma iti dezanA | dharmA ityAdi svayamevaM khyAtatvAt | svasAmAnyalakSaNadhAraNAd dharmA iti yat vyAkhyAtaM tat sarvadharmasAdhAraNamiti na rUpakAyastathAgatatvena nirdiSTa:, ajJApakatvAt | prajJaptita ityucyamAne’pi na rUpakAyo dharmakAyatvena prasakto bhavati, puNyahetvanurUpatvAt @145 tatkiM manyase subhUte, api nu srotaApannasyaivaM bhavati- mayA srotaApattiphalaM prAptamiti ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | na tasya | yathoktam {1. ratnA., 3/13, punaruddhAra: (AcAryaGavaGsamatena) ti. saM. saMskaraNam |}- buddhAnAM rUpikAyo hi puNyaM sambhRtya jAyate | dharmakAya: samAsena jJAnasambhArajo nRpa || tasmAjjJAnasambhArasyaiva tatprAptyupAyatvAnna rUpakAyena sa gRhyate, prajJaptihetvabhAvAnnocyate rUpakAyo ‘dharmakAya:’ iti | pravacanakAyastu samyagjJAnasya phalamiti | sambhAralakSaNapuNyanicayasyApi tatprAptihetutvAt prajJaptyA dharmakAya ityucyamAno’pi yujyata eveti alamadhikena | anyat kucodyaM yuktamayuktaM veti vicakSaNairviveciyiSyata iti matvA padabAhulyabhiyA na likhyate | dharmakAyAptichandasthAnamuktam | ita: paraM dvAdazavipakSANAM pratipakSANi dvAdazasthAnAni yathAkramaM veditavyAni | ime tAvad dvAdaza vipakSA:- 1. abhimAna: 2. abhimAnAbhAve’pi alpazrutatvam 3. bAhuzrutye’pihInAlambanamanasikArabhAvanA 4. hInAlambanamanasikArabhAvanAyA abhAve’pi sattvopekSA 5. tadupekSAyA abhAve’pi bAhyazAstreSu sAnurAgA pravRtti: 6. tathA pravRttyabhAve’pi bhAvanimittAbhibhavopAyeSvakauzalam 7. tatra upAyakauzale’pi puNyasambhArAsaJcaya: 8. puNyasambhArasaJcaye’pi lAbhasatkArakausIdyai: piNDAsvAdanam 9. tathAsvAdanAbhAve’pi du:khAkSAnti: 10. du:khAdhivAsanAyAmapi jJAnasambhArAsaJcaya: 11. jJAnasambhArasaJcaye’pi Atmaparigraha: 12. AtmagrahAbhAve’pi avavAdAyoga: @146 srotaApannasyaivaM bhavati- mayA srota ApattiphalaM prAptamiti | tatkasya heto: ? na hi sa bhagavan kaMciddharmamApanna:, tenocyate srotaApanna iti | na rUpamApanno na zabdAn na gandhAn na rasAn na spraSTavyAn dharmAnApanna: | tenocyate srotaApanna iti | saced bhagavan, srota ApannasyaivaM bhavet- mayA srota ApattiphalaM prAptamiti, sa eva tasyAtmagrAho bhavet, sattvagrAho jIvagrAha: pudgalagrAho bhavediti | bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, api nu sakRdAgAmina evaM bhavati- mayA sakRdAgAmiphalaM prAptamiti ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | na sakRdAgAmina evaM bhavati- mayA sakRdAgAmiphalaM prAptamiti | tatkasya heto: ? na hi sa kazciddharmo ya: sakRdAgAmitvamApanna: | tenocyate sakRdAgAmIti | 5. bhAvanAvizeSalAbhe’nabhimAnasthAnam : tatra bhagavatA dharmapudgalayorvistareNa nairAtmye dezite’pi anAdikAlInadRDhAtmAbhinivezasaJcayabalena yadi kazcideva manyeta- yasya sattvAdisaMjJA pravartate, na sa bodhisattva iti{1. sattvasaMjJA ca te nAtha, sarvathA na pravartate | du:khArteSu ca sattveSu tvamatIva kRpAtmaka: || -catustava: 1/9 (niraupamya stava: -uddhRtam bo. ca.; 9/76)} ? eva tarhi yaduktaM bhagavatA ‘tasmin kAle’haM vIradatto nAma nRpo’bhavam,’ yuSamabhya: mayA dharmo dezayiSyate ityAdi kathaM syAt | (ata:) sattvasaMjJAdivirahasya naivamabhiprAya iti vighna- bhUtAbhimAnavisaMyogArthaM paJcamasthAnamadhikRtyAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdi | asyAyamatra sAmAnyato’rtha:- ye: mama mRduzrAvakA: srota ApannatvAdiSu dharmanairAtmyAnadhigamAd aprAptarasAnubhavA, teSAmapi ahantvena mamatvena cAbhinivezo na bhavati, kiM khalu puna: ubhayanairAtmyAdhigamena prahINaniravazeSAvaraNAnAmiti | tasmin kAle’ham… ityAdi | yattallokena saha vyavahAraprajJaptyarthaM parasantAnavyavacchedamAtrajJApanArthaM vA, senAvanAdivyavahAravat, na tvekatva- @147 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, api nu anAgAmina evaM bhavati- mayAnAgAmiphalaM prAptamiti ? subhUtirAha- no hIda bhagavan | na anAgAmina evaM bhavati- mayA anAgAmiphalaM prAptamiti | tatkasya heto: ? na hi sa bhagavan kazciddharmo yo’nAgAmitvamApanna: | tenocyate anAgAmIti | bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, api nu arhat evaM bhavati- mayA arhatvaM prAptamiti ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | nArhat evaM bhavati- mayA arhatvaM prAptamiti | tatkasya heto: ? na hi sa bhagavan kazciddharmo yo’rhannAma | tenocyate- arhanniti | saced bhagavan arhat evaM bhavet- mayA arhatvaM prAptamiti, sa eva tasyAtmagrAho bhavet, sattvagrAho jIvagrAha: pudgalagrAho bhavet | zAzvatatvAbhinivezatayA | tattvajJAnasthitai: na zakyate tAvallokena saha vyavahartum | tasmAdabhimAnasthAnavisaMyogArthaM tvayA’pi nAtmanyabhiniveSTavyamiti samAdApayati | tatra srota: nirvANamahAnagaraprApakadarzanamArgalakSaNam, Apanna: prApta:, darzanapraheyasamastaklezaprahAyaka: srota Apanna iti, tasya ca kartari karmaNi kriyAyAM cAbhinivezaprahANena idampratyayatAdhigamAnnairAtmyAdhigamo darzita: | mayA iti kartaryabhiniveza: | phalam iti, karmaNyabhiniveza: | prApta: iti kriyAyAmabhiniveza: | ityanena tAvadarthata: mayA prAptamiti vipakSatvena paridIpyate | na srotaApannasyaivaM bhavati mayA prAptam ityanena upalakSaNamAtrapradarzanena sarveSAmabhimAnAnAM praheyatva pradarzyate | tatra chanda: praNidhAnaJcApi nirdizyata iti | AryasubhUtirapi bhagavato’bhiprAyaM nirdizan paramArthasthApanArthaM tatra yogasamApattiM ca grahItuM na hi sa bhagavan kaJcid (dharmaM) Apanna: ityAha | kathamiti na rUpamApanna: ityAdyAha | anena tAvat paramArthata: phaladvaividhyasyAprApyatvamapi nirdizyate, tathA hi- phalabhUtaM prApyasvabhAva kiJcit syAt (tarhi) saMskRtamasaMskRtaM vA syAt | tatra tAvadanutpannamevAsaMskRtam, abhAvarUpatvAd zazaviSANamiva tanna, yujyate @148 prAptum, aprAptyavasthA’viziSTatvAt | saMskRtaM tAvat kSaNikam, utpAdasamanantaraM vinAzitvAt, sthiterabhAvAt kenApi kathamapi tanna prAptuM zakyate | yasmin santAne nairAtmyamArgalakSaNahetusannihitatayA klezasamutpAdAtyantaviruddhAzrayalakSaNaM phalamutpadyata iti phalaM prApyata ityevamucyate, na tu paramArthata: | api ca, prApyaprApakabhAva: {1. dra^- niravayavatvanirAkaraNaprasaGge, vi. mA. si., pR. 48,51, sa. saM. vi. vi. saM. 1972 |} khalu bhinnakAlika: samakAliko vA syAt | tatra na tAvat prathama: pakSa: dvayorapi sthitatvAt, bhinnakAlikastu ekasmin pratyAsanne’parasya cAsaMnihite sati (bhavati), tatkathaM dvayo: sthitiriti | na ca samakAlAvasthitayorubhayo: parasparopakArakatvam, asati copakAre prApyaprApakabhAvo naivopayujyate, atiprasaGgatvAt | anyo’nyasaMyogenotpAdalakSaNenApi prApyaprApakabhAvasya samakAlikatvaM na yujyate, tathA hi- ye’mUrtabhAvA:, te naiva saMyujyante, kvacidapyanavasthAnAtteSAm | na syAt prApyaprApakabhAve samakAlatvamAtramapi teSAm, atiprasaGgAt | na cApyekasya hetutvam, ubhayo: sAdhAraNatvAt, idaM prApyamidaJca prApakamiti nizcayo na bhavati | ye tAvanmUrtA:, teSAM sarvAtmanA saMyoge sati ekatvaM prasajyate, ekadezena (saMyoge tu) sAvayavatvaM prasajyate | nairantaryeNAvasthAne’pi na bhavituM zaknoti ubhayo: sAdhAraNatvAt | avizeSAnna nizcaya: | ata: kalpanAsamAropita evAyam | anena tAvat sarva: karmakartrAdivyavahAra: spaSTamavaboddhavya: | dharmA: iti dharmAyatanam, anenAsaMskRtamapi saMgRhyate, dharmAyatanasya saptadravyAtmakatvAt, {2. vedanA, saMjJA, saMskArA:, avijJapti:, AkAzam, pratisaMkhyAnirodha:, apratisaMkhyAnirodhazca | -abhi. ko. TI., pR. 50 (bau. bhA. pra.)} zeSeNa rUpAdinA ca dharmAyatanaikadezena ca saMskRtA nirdizyante | upalakSaNamidam atazcakSurAdikaM grahItavyam | evaM yata: paramArthata: sa kaJcit (dharmaM) nApanna:, mayA prAptamityapi na manyate, tasmAt sanmArgasthitatvAt srota Apanna {3. ya: kAmavItarAga:, sa SoDaze darzanamArgacittakSaNe srota Apanna: | -Aloka:, pR. 290; evaM vyavasthita Arya: srota ApattiphalasAkSAtkriyAyai pratipannaka ityucyate | SoDaze tu mArge'nvayajJAnasthita: sa srota Apanna ityucyate | -ma. zA. vR., 24/4 pR. 212, bau. bhA. saM., 1983 |} ityucyate | @149 tatkasya heto: ? ahamasmi bhagavaMstathAgatenArhatA samyaksaMbuddhena araNAvihAriNAmagryo nirdiSTa: | ahamasmi bhagavan arhat vItarAga: | na ca me bhagavannevaM bhavati- arhannasmyahaM vItarAga iti | yadi mayA prAptamityabhinivezastadA kathaM nocyeta srota Apanna iti vicintya saced bhagavan ityAdyAha | mayA iti yasyAhamityabhiniveza: syAttasya nAstyAtmadRSTiprahANam, yazcAprahINAtmadRSTi: sa anutpannAryamArga:, yazcAnutpannAryamArga:, sa pRthagjana {1. anutpannamArgo bAlapRthagjana: | tannibandhanA rAgAdayo dharmA: pRthagdharmA: | - Aloka:, pR. 325; pRthagjanatvam | ‘pRthagjanatvaM katamat ? AryadharmANAmalAbha:’ iti zAstrapATha: | -abhi. ko., 2/40 pR. 225, bau.bhA. pra. 1987 |} iti kathaM syAt srota-Apanna ityabhisandhi: | evaM hi ‘mayA’ iti yo’yamabhiniveza:, sa AtmadRSTisamudaya: | anena cittapragraho nirdiSTa: | anena tAvat sakalena sthAnasyAsya gAmbhIryamabhihitam | amumevArthaM dRSTAntAntare prapaJcya nirdeSTuM sakRdAgAmina: {2. tata: kAmAvacaraSaTprakAraklezaprahANAt sakRdAgAmI | -Aloka:, pR. 290; tatra darzanamArgAdUrdhva kAmAvacarabhAvanAprahAtavyaSaSThaklezaprakArapratipakSavimuktimArgAkhyajJAna- kSaNAdarvAg jJAnakSaNAvasthita: Arya: sakRdAgAmiphalapratipannaka ityucyate | sakRdimaM lokamAgatya parinirvANAt sakRdAmItyucyate, tatphalArthaM pratipannaka: prayogastha: sakRdAgAmiphalapratipannaka ityucyate | SaSThe tu kSaNe sakRdAgAmItyucyate | -ma. zA. vR., 24/4 pR. 212, bau. bhA. pra. ; nimittadRSTilakSyalakSaNAbhAvAddhyAnagatilakSaNasudRSTatvAt sakRdetaM lokamAgamya du:khasyAntakriyAyai parinirvAsyati | tenocyate sakRdAgAmIti | -laMkA. 2/173, pR. 49, mi, saMskaraNam |} ityAdyAha | atrApi padArthAbhisandhyAdIni pUrvavad yojyAni | prahINabhAvanA- heyaSaDvidhakAmAvacarakleza evAryasakRdAgAmI, sakRdAgAmitvAt kAmadhAtau | prahINabhAvanAheyasakalakAmAvacarakleza evAnAgAmItyucyate, {3. SaSThAt kSaNAdUrdhva navamaklezaprakAraprahANavimuktimArgakSaNAdarvAgjJAnakSaNeSu vartamAna Arya: anAgAmiphalapratipannaka ityucyate | anAgatya imaM lokaM tatraiva parinirvANAdanAgAmItyucyate | tatphalArthaM pratipannaka: prayogastho’nAgAmiphalapratipannaka ityacyate | navame tu kSaNe anAgAmItyucyate | -ma. zA.vR. 24/4, pR. 212, bau. bhA. pra.; yaduta atItAnAgatapratyutpannasya rUpalakSaNabhAvAbhAvapravRtterdRSTidoSAnuzaya-} punaranAgAmitvAt vikalpasya anAgAmitvAdanAgAmIrUpaprahINatvAcca saMyojanAnAmanAgAmItyucyate | -laMkA., 2/173, pR. 49, mi. sa. 1963 |} punaranAgAmitvAt @150 sacenmama bhagavannevaM bhavet- mayA arhatvaM prAptamiti, na mAM tathAgato vyAkariSyat araNAvihAriNAmagrya: subhUti: kulaputro na kvacidviharati, tenocyate- araNAvihArI araNAvihArIti | kAmadhAtau | yadA samastatraidhAtukAvacaraklezamalAnAM prahANa jAyate tadA sa sakalalokapUjyatvAd arhannityucyate {1. sarve evAtra pUjAdakSiNAguNaprakarSAdyarhatayA arhanta: | -Aloka:, pR. 273; kAmAvacaranavamavimuktimArgAdUrdhvaM naivasaMjJAnAsaMjJAtayana bhUmikanavamaklezaprakAraprahANa- vimuktimArgakSaNAdarvAgjJAnakSaNeSu vartamAna Arya arhatphalapratipannaka ityucyate | sadevamAnuSAsurAllokAt pUjArhatvAdarhannityucyate | tatphalArtha pratipannaka: prayogastha: arhatphalapratipannaka ityucyate | bhavAgrikanavamaklezaprakAraprahANAttu navamavimuktimArge vyavasthita: arham bhavati | -ma. zA. vR. 24/4, pR. 213, bau. bhA. gra. | dra^ -laMkA. 2/173, pR. 49 |} | na hi sa kazcid dharmo yo’rhannAma prahINatathAvidhaklezAvaraNajJAnasantatau upacaritatvAt, santatezca prajJaptau sattvanna sa kazcana paramArthata:, samAropita evAsAvityabhiprAya | sAmpratam AryasubhUti ‘ahaM’ padaprayojyamAtmAnamadhikRtya viziSTatvena araNAvihArIti, sAdhAraNaguNatvena, arhanniti ca ‘ahamasmi’ ityanenoktvA cittapragrahamAtra darzayituM aham ityAdyavocat | araNA {2. araNA iti yasya samAdhe pramANAt pareSA santAne svaparavyavadhAnArthena raNayantIti raNA: klezA na jAyante, sa araNAsamAdhi:, tadvihAriNA madhye agratAyAM nirdiSTa: san nirdiSTasya acittatAmiti vibhaktapariNAmena yojyam | -Aloka, pR. 293 ; raNA hi klezA AtmaparavyAbAdhanAditi | ye hyAtmAna parAzca vyAbAdhante te raNA:, yuddhAnItyartha: | tathaiva ca klezA raNA | ucyante | tadanuzayitatvAditi | tairanuzayitA upasevitA ityartha: | atha vA- anuzayina: kRtAstairanuzayitA:, tadbhAvastadanuzayitatvam, tasmAt = tadanuaiyitatvAt | atha vA teSAmanuzayitatvam, tasmAt raNA: sAsravacana: | dra^- abhi. ko. 1/8; pR. 29 bau. bhA. pra. 19/7 |} iti samAdhivizeSa:, atra cobhato bhAgavimuktatvamarhattvamAlambya taditareSu raNA: notpAdyanta iti vicintya yoga: samApadyate | tato vyutthAya tamAlambya taditareSu nopajAyante raNA: | yastayA araNayA: viharaNazIla: sa evamucyate | sugamo'va vibhaGga: | @151 bhagavanAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte- asti sa kazciddharmo yastathagatena dIpaMkarasya tathAgatasyArhata: samyaksaMbuddhasyAntikAd udgRhIta: ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | nAsti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatena dIpaMkarasya tathAgatasyArhata: samyaksaMbuddhasyAntikAd udgRhIta: | na mAM vyAkariSyat iti tadA aprahINatvAdAtmadRSTermayA srota-Apattiphalamapi durlabham, kiM khalu puna: ubhatobhAgavimuktenArhatA prApyamaraNAvihAritvamityabhisandhi: | kathamaraNAyAM vihartavyamiti cintAyAM na kvacid viharati ityavocat | prAptaM mayA kiJcat saMskRtamasaMskRtaM vetyevamabhinivezena yo’sthita:, sa evAraNAvihArIti dvirabhidhAnam, nApara ityartha: | adhunA ahamasmi bhagavaMstathAgatenArhatA samyaksambuddhena araNAvihAriNAmagryo {1. sAdhu sAdhvAyuSmAn subhUte | yathApi nAma tvaM bhagavatA araNAvihAriNAmagratAyAM nirdiSTo nirdizasi | -a. pra., pR. 3; tulanIyam- etaM sattaM etaM paNItaM yadidaM ... | -ma, ni., bhAga- 3, pR. 29 ; dra.- aM ni., bhAga-1. pR. 24-25 |} nirdiSTa: | ahamasmi bhagavan arhan vItarAga: iti nAtmAbhinivezena, atha kathamiti cet ? vyavahAra- mAtrAbhinivezatayA, etacca prAgeva mayA proktam | 6. buddhotpAdArAgatA-sthAnam : nanvasati kasmiMzcidapi prApye prApake vA paramArthata:, bodhisattvabhUtena bhagavatA kathaM tathAgatadIpaGkarasyAntikAd dharma udgRhIta: ? atha nodgRhIta iti ced ? tadA’smAbhirdharmamudgrahItukAmai: kathamArAdhanIyastathAgatotpAda iti ye parikalpayanti teSAmalpazrutatvapratibandhApAkaraNArthaM SaSThaM sthAnamadhikRtyAha- asti sa kazcid dharmo yastathAgatena dIpaGkarasya tathAgatasyArhata: samyaksambuddhasyAntikAdudgRhIta: ? iti | subhUtirapi prAgevAbhiprAyaM viditvA no hIdam ityavocat | nAsti paramArthata: kasyacidapi dharmasya prApyaprApakatvena udgrahaNaM nAma, yathoktaM pUrvam | `sarve dharmA: prakRtyA zAntA:’ @152 bhagavAnAha- ya: kazcitsubhUte bodhisattva evaM vadet- ahaM kSetravyUhAn niSpAdayiSyAmIti, sa vitathaM vadet | tatkasya heto: ? kSetravyUhA: kSetravyUhA iti subhUte, avyUhAste tathAgatena bhASitA: | tenocyante kSetravyUhA iti | tasmAttarhi subhUte, bodhisattvena mahAsattvena evamapratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyaM yanna kvacitpratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyam | na rUpapratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyaM na zabdagandharasaspraSTavyadharmapratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyam | tathApi tathAgatAnubhAvena nAnApadasamudAyAdInAM jJAnAvabhAsotpAdamAtre udgRhIta: ityupacaryate, ata: zrutaparyeSaNaM saphalam | anenArthata: `bodhisattvena zrutaparyeSaNakAle buddhotpAda ArAdhanIyastadanantaraM buddhadharmA udgRhItavyA:’ ityabhinivezo vipakSatvena nirdiSTa: | tatprahANe chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamityapi nirdiSTam | asti sa kazcid dharmo dIpaGkarasyAntikAdudgRhIta: ? iti diGmAtrAbhidhAnena udgRhItadharmasya sarvanimittaM vinivartate | `nAsti sa kazcid dharma udgRhIta:’ ityanena paramArthata: dharmANAmagrAhyatvaM vyavasthApya tatra yogasamApatti: vikSepanigrahazca nirdiSTau | sthAnasyAsya gAmbhIryamapi paridIpitam | 7. kSetravizuddhipraNidhAna-sthAnam : yadi paramArthata: karmakartrAdayo na syustadA kathaM bodhisattvA buddhakSetraparizodhanArthaM praNidadhatIti tarkayatAM teSAM hInAlambana- manasikArabhAvanAvibandhavisaMyogArthaM saptamasthAnamadhikRtyAha- ya: kazcid bodhisattva: iti | vitatham iti mRSA | yadyevaM (tarhi) bhagavAn bodhisattvAnAM tattatkSetraparizuddhisampadaM kathamuktavAniti vicintya tatkasya heto: ? iti pRcchAyAM kSetravyUhA: ityAdi samAdhAnamabhihitam | bahUni kSetrANi tu kSetravyUhA | avyUhAste iti paramANubhirAbdho’vayavibhUto vA nAsti kazcid vyUha: paramArthata ityavyUhA eva te, tathApi svapnopalabdhakSetravyUhavad avicAraramaNIyamAtra saMvRtisattvamuktaM tenocyante kSetravyUhA: iti | anyathA @153 tadyathApi nAma subhUte, puruSo bhavedupetakAyo mahAkAyo yattasyaivaM rUpa AtmabhAva: syAt tadyathApi nAma sumeru: parvatarAja: | tatkiM manyase subhUte, api nu mahAn sa AtmabhAvo bhavet ? subhUtirAha-mahAn sa bhagavan, mahAn sugata sa AtmabhAvo bhavet | tatkasya heto: ? AtmabhAva-AtmabhAva iti bhagavan na bhAva: sa tathAgatena bhASita: | tenocyate AtmabhAva iti | na hi bhagavan sa bhAvo nAbhAva: | tenocyate AtmabhAva iti | paramArthasvabhAvastvanabhilApyatayA’nabhilApya ityabhiprAya: | uktaJcApratiSThitatvaM prAgeva | eSAM muSitasmRtikAnAmupakArAya upasaMhAropAyena smArayituM tasmAd ityAdyAha | evam iti yathoktena vidhinA, kasyacidapi vastuna: siddherabhAvAt tatra `apratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyam’ ityartha: | zeSaM tu pUrvavat | tatra vitathaM vadet ityanenArthata: paramArthata: mayA kSetravyUho niSpAdyata ityabhinivezo vipakSatvena paridIpita: | `kSetravyUhA:’ iti nimittamAtrAbhidhAnena samastahInAlambanabhAvanAvisaMyogo nirdiSTa: | hInAlambanamanasikArabhAvanAM prati chanda: praNidhAnamapi (na karttavyamityapi) nirdiSTam | avyUhAste tathAgatena bhASitA: ityanena paramArthavyavasthApanena yogasamApattau pravRtti: gambhIratA ca nirdizyete | tenocyante kSetravyUhA: ityanenApavAdAntaM parihRtya vikSepanigraho nirdiSTa:, sthAnasyAsya audArya ca paridIpitam | 8. sattvaparipAka-sthAnam : skandhebhya: pRthaktvenAsattve’pi kiM nAbhinnA eva sattvA: ? anyathA sattvaparipAkArtha kathaM bodhisattvA: pravarteran ? iti yo vicAra:, tasmAt sattvopekSAlakSaNavighnabhUtAd visaMyogArtham aSTamasthAnamadhikRtya tadyathApi nAma ityuktam | puruSa: ityasurendro rAhuriti | tasyAtmabhAvastu kAmadhAtau sumeruparimANa: | tasya mahattve’pi vyarthaiva tanmahattA | kimarthaM dezitaM bhagavatetyabhiprAyaM vaktukAmanayA tatkasya heto: ? ityApRSTam | tameva abhiprAyaM vaktumAha-na bhAva: iti | paramArthata: ekAnekasvabhAvena viyogAt @154 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte- yAvatyo gaGgAyAM mahAnadyAM vAlukAstAvatya eva gaGgAnadyo bhaveyu:, tAsu yA vAlukA:, api nu tA bahavyo bhaveyu: ? subhUtirAha- tA eva tAvadbhagavan bahavyo gaGgAnadyo bhaveyu:, prAgeva yAstAsu gaGgAnadISu vAlukA: | ni:svabhAvatA{1. nisvabhAvA amI dharmAstattvata: svaparoditA: | ekAnekasvabhAvena viyogAt pratibimbavat || -ma. ava. 1 kA. (uddhRtam bo. ca. pR. 173)} eva | svapnadRSTa iva sa AtmabhAva savRtita proktastathAgatena, na tu paramArthata: | tenocyate AtmabhAva: ityatropapattimAha | evamaya savRtireva, tasmAttathocyate, anyathA paramArthata kasyacidapi dharmasyAsiddhatvAt tathA nocyetetyabhiprAya: | abhAva tAvad bhAvatvenAbhyupagacchatA teSAM jaiminyAdInAM pratiSedhArtham na sa bhAva: ityAha | abhAvasya tu bhAvavyatirekeNa sthitalakSaNatvAt kathaM tadviparItasvabhAvo na syAt ? `tenocyate AtmabhAva’ | anyathA paramArthata: kasyacidapyAtmabhAvasyAsiddhe kimityAtmabhAva ihocyate, tato’yamabhAvatvena dezita: | sumerumAtraparimANo’pi ya AtmabhAvo yadA ni:svabhAvatvAt paramArthato nAsti, tadA kathaM parAtmabhAva sasvabhAva sAtmako vA bhavet ? atrArthata: sattvaparipAkAyodyamaratAnAM bodhisattvAnAM sattvAbhiniveza: paramArthata: vipakSatvena pradarzita: tatprahANAya chanda: praNidhAna ca nirdiSTe | `puruSa:’ ityupalakSaNamAtrAbhidhAnena aNDajAdInAM sarveSAM pRthagAtmabhAvAnAM parigrahaNamuktam | na bhAva: sa tathAgatena bhASita: ityanena tAvat paramArthaM vyasthApya yogasamApattisthAnaM gambhIratvaM ca paridIpite | na sa bhAva: ityanena tu vikSepanigraho nirdiSTa: | 9. bAhyazAstreSu vyapagatarAgatA-sthAnam : sampratyasya dharmaparyAyasya mahArthatvapratipAdanena bAhyazAstreSvabhiniviSTAnAM tatrAnunayavikSepaparihArArthaM navamasthAnamadhikRtya-tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAha | @155 bhagavAnAha- ArocayAmi te subhUte, prativedayAmi te | yAvatyastAsu gaGgAnadISu vAlukA bhaveyustAvato lokadhAtUn kazcideva strI vA puruSo vA saptaratnaparipUrNaM kRtvA tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhya: samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, tatkiM manyase subhUte- api nu sA strI vA puruSo vA tato nidAnaM bahu puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAt ? subhUtirAha- bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata, strI vA puruSo vA tato nidAnaM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAdaprameyamasaMkhyeyam | bhagavAnAha- yazca khalu puna: subhUte, strI vA puruSo vA tAvato lokadhAtUn saptaratna- paripUrNaM kRtvA tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhya: samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, yazca kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA ito dharmaparyAyAdantazazca- tuSpAdikAmapi gAthAmudgRhya parebhyo dezayet saMprakAzayet, ayameva tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAdaprameyamasaMkhyeyam | anena tAvat caturbhi: prakArairasya dharmaparyAyasya vaiziSTyaM paridIpyate- puNyaparigraha:, devAdibhi: satkAra:, duSkarakRtyavidhAnam, tathAgatAdi- tulyatAkaraNam | tatra puNyaparigrahastu yadAha tato nidAnaM bahupuNyaskandhaM prasunuyAt iti | devAdibhi: satkArastu yadAha sa pRthivIpradeza: caityabhUtyabhUto bhaved {1. dra^- a. pra. pR. 28 ; api ca-caityabhUto vandanAdinA puNyopacayahetutvAt | piteva pitRbhUta ityupamAvAcakabhUtazabdasyopAdAnAdanyacaityasamAnatvena caityabhUta: sa pRthivIpradeza ityeke | yatra hi nAma pudgalanairAtmyadyotikayA “ye dharmA hetuprabhavA” ityAdigAthayA adhiSThito bhUbhAga: stUpo mata:, tatra samastavastunai: svAbhAvyaprakAzikAyA mAturudgrahaNAdinopeta: stUpo nitarAmeva, ityata: sAkSyeva sAkSibhUta iti tatsvabhAvatve caityameva caityabhUta iti candragomI | -Aloka: pR. 361 |} iti | duSkarakRtyavidhAnaM tu yadAha parameNa te AzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti iti | tathAgatAditulyatAkaraNaM tu yadAha tasmiMzca pRthivIpradeze zAstA viharatyanyatarAnyataro vA vijJagurusthAnIya: iti | tatra ratnadAnasya puNyAbhidhAnaM vizeSadvayena viziSTaM paridIpitam- vastuvizeSa: kSetravizeSazca | vastuvizeSo’pi tAvat udAra: praNItazceti |- @156 api nu khalu puna: subhUte, yasmin pRthivI pradeze ito dharmaparyAyAdantazazcatuSpAdikAmapi gAthAmudgRhya bhASyeta vA saMprakAzyeta vA, sa pRthivIpradezazcaityabhUtyabhUto bhavet sadevamAnuSAsurasya lokasya- tatraudAryaM tu vastubhedasaMbAhulyam, yadAha tAvato lokadhAtUn iti | praNItastu loke durlabhatvena khyAta: yadAha saptaratnaparipUrNaM{1. dra^- Aloka:, pR. 364; saddharma., 2/78-79; ma.sU. saM. pR. 335 |} kRtvA iti | kSetraM svaparArthasampadyogena viziSTam | tatra parArthasampattAvat heyopAdeyArthAnAM parebhyo’viparyayeNa samprakAzanam, Aha tathAgatebhya: iti | yathA vastutathatA tathA bhASitatvAt niruktyA tathA ukta iti kathyate | svArthasampattu jJAna-prahANasampadbhedena dvividhA | tatra arhadbhya: ityanena prahANasampad darzitA, hataklezAritvAd niruktyA `arhan’ ityucyate | samyaksambuddhebhya: ityanena tAvajjJAnasampaduktA | tasmAt padatrayasyokte: sAphalyamiti sAmAnyena saGgrahArtha: | ArocayAmi itIcchA dyotitA bhavati | ArocayAmi prativedayAmi avabodhayAmi prajJAmutpAdayAmItyartha: | tatra pUrvaM tAvat parasya phalam athavA aparaM tu pUrvasya vyAkhyAnam | dezayet iti zabdaM samprakAzayet iti chandam adhimuktimutpAdayedityartha: | saMkhyayA paricchettumazakyatvAd asaMkhyeyam iti | pramApayitumazakyatvAd dRSTAntAbhAvAd vA aprameyam iti | bhASyeta iti AtmanA granthasvAdhyAya:, samprakAzyeta iti parebhya: samyak padArthadezanA, athavA `bhASyeta’ iti padama `samprakAzyeta’ ityartham | caityabhUtyabhUta: iti vandanIya:, caitya eva caityabhUta: vazIbhUta itivat, yadaivaM pudgalanairAtmyagAthAmAtropadezenApi caityabhUtyabhUto jAyate kiM khalu puna: nairAtmyadvayopadezena ityabhiprAya: | udgRhya iti padam, dhArayiSyanti ityavismaraNam, vAcayiSyanti iti pustakagatam paryavApsyanti iti artham | @157 ka: punarvAdo ye imaM dharmaparyAyaM sakalasamAptaM dhArayiSyanti vAcayiSyanti paryavApsyanti, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayiSyanti {1. dhArayiSyanti vAcayiSyanti paryavApsyanti, yonizazca manasi kariSyanti | -iti bhoTapATha: |} | parameNa te subhUte, AzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti | tasmiMzca subhUte, pRthivIpradeze zAstA viharatyanyatarAnyataro vA vijJagurusthAnIya: | anena tAvad zrutamayaprajJayA dhAraNaM darzitam, cintAmayyA bhAvanAmayyA prajJayA codgRhItatvAd yonizazca (manasi kariSyanti){2. saMskRtamUle pATho’yaM nopalabhyate kintu bhoTapAThe prastutaTIkAyAM ca “yonizazca manasi kariSyanti” evaM pATho’sti |} ityAha | aviparItatayA’rthamavabodhayiSyantIti vAkyazeSa: | kvacid dhArayiSyanti ityekameva padam, tatra dhAraNaM tu padArthayordraSTavyam | parameNa AzcaryeNa iti tu evaMvidhagambhIrodAradharmasyAdhigatatvAt | zAstA ...sthAnIya: iti dharmabhANaka:, zAstRkRtyakaraNAt, sa eva sAkSAd dharamANabuddha iveti vAkyazeSa:{3. tu^- paramArthazAstrakRtyA kurvANaM zAstRkRtyamiva loke | yaM buddhimatAmagryaM dvitIyamiva buddhamityAhu: || -abhi. ko. sphu., pR. 3. bau. bhA. pra....} | guru: iti maJjughoSAdyanyatara: kazcit tatkAryasAdhanAya dharmabhANaka: sthAnIyarUpeNa draSTavya: | kutracit anyatarAnyataro iti padadvayam | tacca ye kecana gurusadRzA: (teSAM) sarveSAM paryAya: | atastatra sthAnIya: iti nirdiSTa: | ebhi: sarvai: sthAnasyAsyaudAryaM nirUpitam | arthatazca saddharmaparigrahamutsRjya bAhyazAstrAnurAgo vipakSatvena paridIpita:, tasminnanurAgaM parityajya dharmaM pratipattuM chanda: praNidhAnaM ca darzite | ito dharmaparyAyAd ityupalakSaNamAtraparikIrtanena bAhyazAstreSvanurAgaM parivarjya sarvasaddharmAn prati yatna Astheya iti paridIpitam | acintyasAmarthyAnvitatvAdayaM dharmaparyAya: nAmamAtrazravaNenApi parAnupakarotIti sattvAnAM puNyotpAdakathanAya AryasubhUti: ko nAma ayam iti pRSTavAn |- @158 evamukte AyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavantametadavocat- ko nAma ayaM bhagavan dharmaparyAya:, kathaM cainaM dhArayAmi ? evamukte bhagavAnAyuSmantaM subhUtimetadavocat- prajJApAramitA nAmAyaM subhUte, dharmaparyAya: | evaM cainaM dhAraya | tatkasya heto: ? yaiva subhUte, prajJApAramitA tathAgatena bhASitA saiva apAramitA tathAgatena bhASitA | tenocyate prajJApAramiteti | kathaM cainaM dhArayAmi ityanena asyodgrahaNenApyaprameyapuNyaM bhavatIti paridIpyate | prajJApAramitA nAma {1. zrutacintAbhAvanAmayajJAnodayakrameNa sarvAkArajJAnAdhigamAt pAraM prakarSaparyantam eti iti vigRhya kvipi sarvApahArilope anityamAgamazAsanamityaluki tatpuruSe, kRti bahulamiti aluki ca karmavibhakte: kRte pAramistadbhAva: pAramitA | prajJAyA dharmapravicayalakSaNAyA: pAramitA prajJApAramitA mukhyA | buddho bhagavAn mAyopamaM jJAnamadvayam | -Aloka:, pR. 282|} iti yasyA tannAma tattathA ucyate | iyaM prajJA’pi, pAramadhigamya paricchedayatItyapi pAramiteti, prajJA ca sA pAramitA ceti samAsa: | athavA prajJAyA: pAraM prajJApAram, anayA tadadhigamya paricchidyate’tastathocyate | sA cArthata: sarvavidhaprajJAsu uttamA tAthAgatI prajJA, nAnyadA prajJayA pAraM parimApayituM zakyam | athavA prajJApAram itA gatA ityevArtha: | sA ca yathoktA prajJaiva, na tvanyat tatpAragamanAsambhavAt | anena dAnapAramitAdayo’pyuktA bhavantIti | tadabhidhAnenAyaM dharmaparyAyo’pi tathokta:, yathA sItAharaNAdikAvyayojanA | tasyAzca bhagavata: pratyAtmavedyatvenAsAdhAraNatvAt paramArthatazcAnutpannatvAt sA zabdenAbhidhAtuM na zakyata ityAzayena vitarkya tatkasya heto: ? iti pRSTavAn | yaiva subhUte, prajJApAramitA tathAgatena bhASitA sA ityudatarat | paramArthata: pratyAtmavedyatvenAsAdhAraNatvAt paramArthatazca sarvadharmANAm atyantAnutpannatvAt ca sA na zabdenAbhidheyA, tathApi vikalpapratibimba:- @159 tatkiM manyase subhUte- api nu asti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatena bhASita: ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | nAsti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatena bhASita: | svasvarUpabahirbhUta ivAropyate {1. tam AtmAdinirbhAsaM rUpAdinirbhAsaM ca tasmAd vikalpAd bahirbhUtamivopAdAya AtmAdyupacAro rUpAdidharmopacArazca anAdikAlika: pravartate, vinApi bAhyenAtmanA dharmaizca, tadyathA taimirikasya kezoNDukAdyupacAra iti | -vi. mA. si., pR. 98. sa. saM. vi. vi. saMskaraNam, 1972 |} | sa vikalpo’pi prakRtyA bhrAnta:, atastena samAropita AkAro’pi mithyaiva | tasmAt vikalpapratibimbabhUtA yA prajJApAramitA tathAgatena dezitA, sA zabdena vyutpAdyamAnA apAramitaiva, na tu tathAgatasya prajJA, satyasaMvRtyA jJeyasya pAraGgatatvAttasyA:, anyathA kathaM bhagavan sarvajJa: syAditi | tato bhrAntapratIte: sa vikalpapratibimbo naiva bhedenAvagamyate, ato jJAnasvabhAvatvena saiva paramArthaprajJA tathAgatena bhASitA ityucyate | tasmAt tathAvidhadezanAyAM naiva virodha ityabhiprAya: | athavA yA tathAgatI prajJA pratItirUpatvena tathAgatena bhASitA saiva paramArthato na vidyate, paramArthato’pAraGgatatvAttasyA: | eva iti zabdastu apAramitA ityetadanantaraM draSTavya: | anena paramArthatvaM pratipAdya tatra yogasamApattyA kathaM pratipattavyamiti nirdiSTam | yathA prajJApAramitA vikalpapratibimbAtmikaiva bAhyatvena samAropya bhagavatA bhASitA, tathaiva sarve dharmA api nAnyathA tathAgatena kathitA iti dezanArthamAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte iti | paramArthata: sarvadharmANAmasiddhatvAt, siddheSvapi svalakSaNasyAsAdhAraNatvena saGketena prajJapayitumazakyatvAt, sAmAnyalakSaNameva tAvat prajJapyamAnatvAt, svasAmAnyalakSaNe vyatiricya aparasyAbhidheyasyAbhAvAt parasparaparihArasthitalakSaNatvAttayo:, ata eva ca paramArthata: `nAsti kazcid dharmo yastathAgatena bhASita:' iti vijJAya sthavira:{2. sadevake loke pUjAdibhi: sthAviryaprAptatvAtsthavira: | -Aloka:, pR. 281 |} subhUti: no hIdaM bhagavan, nAsti sa kazcid dharmo yastathAgatena bhASita: ityavocat | anena vikSepanigraha: gAmbhIrya ca nirdiSTe bhavata: | @160 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte- yAvat trisAhasramahAsAhasre lokadhAtau pRthivIraja: kaccit tadbahu bhavet ? subhUtirAha- bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata, pRthivIrajo bhavet | tatkasya heto: ? yattadbhagavan pRthivIrajastathAgatena bhASitam, arajastad bhagavaMstathAgatena bhASitam | tenocyate pRthivIraja iti | yo’pyasau lokadhAtustathAgatena bhASita:, adhAtu: sa tathAgatena bhASita: | tenocyate lokadhAturiti | 10. sattvabhAjanalokayo: piNDagrAhavizIrNatAyoga-sthAnam evaM sarvadharmeSu nairAtmyaM vistareNa darzitam, tathApi ye tAvad AdikarmikA: kathaM sarvadharmeSu nairAtmyaM bhAvayitavyamiti cintayanti, bhAvanimittamabhibhavitumanupAyakauzalavisaMyogArthaM dazamasthAnadhikRtyAha-tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdi | atra dvividhena upAyena ekAnekasvabhAvaviyogAdhigamAt sarvadharmanairAtmyaM bhAvayitavyamiti darzyate | tatra dvividha upAyastAvat tanUkaraNopAya: nirAbhAsakaraNopAyazca | tatra yAvat pRthivIrajo bhavet ityanena ekasvabhAvaviyogAdhigamAt tanUkaraNopAyo nirdizyate | na yujyate hyasya lokadhAtorekatvam, AvRttAnAvRttAdivispaSTalakSaNayuktatvAd{1. `chAyAvRtI kathaM vA’ | yadyekaikasya paramANordigbhAgabhedo na syAt, Adityodaye kathamanyatra chAyA bhavati, anyatra Atapa: | na hi tasyAnya: pradezo’sti yatrAtapo na syAt | -vi. mA. si., pR. 52, sa. saM. vi. vi. saM. 1972 |} | anekatva- nirAkaraNAya tAvat paramANornirAkaraNamabhyupetavyam | ata eva paramANuvibhAvanAyAM satyAmekatvaM prahIyata eveti | bodhisattvaistAvat prAyeNa parIttAlambana- manasikArAbhAvAt trisAhasramahAsAhasralokadhAtvAlambanArthaM trisAhasramahAsAhasre{2. dra^- abhi. ko. 3/73-74} ityAha | anena tAvadaudArya paridIpitam | te ca paramANavo’pi yadi digbhAgabhedena bhinnatvAdasiddhA eva syu:, (tarhi) kathaM tad bahu raja:{3. digbhAgabhedo yasyAsti tasyaikatvaM na yujyate |-viM. vi. mA. si., 14 kA. : api ca, draSTavyam- bo. ca. paM., 9vAM+ pari. pR. 235 |} ? iti pravAdinAmAzayamabhilakSya kasya @161 heto: ? ityapRcchat | yattad pRthivIraja: iti tadudatarat | `bahu tat pRthivIrajo’pi ya: paramANusvabhAva uktastadekatvagrahaNaniSedhAt tadaraja eva | mAyAnirmitasvabhAvatvAnnAsti paramANu: paramArthata:, buddhyopacaritarUpatvAt | idaM tAvadekatvagrahaNopAyamAtram, na tu paramArtham, tenocyate pRthivIraja iti | tad yuktaM saMvRtau sattvAt, anyathA paramArthatastasyAsattvAd anabhilApyatvAcca svalakSaNaM nAbhilapyata ityevamabhiprAya: | udbhAvanAsaMvRtyA’pi{1. prajJaptipratipattita: | tathodbhAvanayodAraM...| trividhA hi saMvRti:- prajJaptisaMvRti:, pratipattisaMvRtirudbhAvanAsaMvRtizca | -ma. vi. bhA., 10kA. pR. 21. ke. pI. jA. saM. paTanA. 1967 : dra.- Aloka:, pR. 288 |} tasya dezanaM na yujyate, tadIyAnyatarAtmasvabhAvasya apratibhAsamAnatvAt | anena tAvad anekasvabhAvaviyogAdhigamopAyo nirAbhAsakaraNatvenopadarzyate | evaJcAntaza: paramANUnAmapi yuktyA pratyekaM parIkSyamANAnAM pratItAveva sattvAt pratIyate lokadhAtUnAM cAnekasvabhAvaviyuktatvam, tatazca (teSAM) ni:svabhAvatvamavagamyate | evaM khalu bhAjanalokasya ekAnekasvabhAvaviyogena ni:svabhAvatvam evamabhidhAya sattvalokasyApyabhidhAnArthaM yo’sau lokadhAtu: ityAha | atra lokadhAtunA sattvaloko’bhipreta:, itarasya pUrvamevoktatvAt | adhAtu: sa: iti ekAnekasvabhAvarahita: sa ityabhiprAya: | evaM yo hi rUpaskandha: sa bhAjanalokatvenAbhihita:, zeSAzcatvAra: skandhAstu yathaikAnekasvabhAvena viyuktAstathA pUrvaM vivecitA eva | evaM sati paramArthato ni:svabhAvatvAt sarve dharmA mAyopamA dRzyante yogibhi: | anena gAmbhIryamapi tAvaduktam | arthata: paramArthe sattvabhAjanalokIyabhAvAbhinivezo vipakSatvena paridIpita: | tatprahANArthaM ca chanda: praNidhAnaM ca nirdiSTe | trisAhasramahAsAhasre lokadhAtau iti nimittamAtrAbhidhAnena sarvabhAvanAM ni:svabhAvatvabhAvanA sandarzitA | arajastat iti adhAtu: ityAbhyAM paramArthavyavasthApanayA yogasamApattyA kathaM pratipattavyamiti tat paridIpitam | tenocyate lokadhAtu: ityanenApavAdAntaM parihRtya vikSepanigraho nirdiSTa: | @162 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, dvAtriMzanmahApuruSa- lakSaNaistathAgato’rhan samyaksaMbuddho draSTavya: ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | na dvAtriMzanmahApuruSalakSaNaistathAgato’rhan samyaksaMbuddho draSTavya: | tatkasya heto: ? yAni hi tAni bhagavan dvAtriMzanmahApuruSalakSaNAni tathAgatena bhASitAni, alakSaNAni tAni bhagavaMstathAgatena bhASitAni | tenocyante dvAtriMzanmahApuruSalakSaNAnIti | 11. tathAgatapUjAsatkAra-sthAnam : samprati ye bodhisattvA puNyasambhArapratipattaye’tyantamupakAritvAd bhagavantaM pUjayeyusteSAM tasya (bhagavata) avinAzikAyo na pUrayati puNyasambhAram, samyaGmanasikArApravRttatvAt | tasmAt teSAM sambhArAsaJcayato viyogArthaM ekAdazasthAnamadhikRtyAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdi | sAmAnyato’trAyaM saGgrahArtha:, tathAgatapUjAsatkAreSu lakSaNasampadA tathAgato na draSTavya, atha kathamiti cet ? paramArthadharmatAyAmityucyate | iha avaziSTavyAkhyAna tu rUpakAyAptikAmatAsthAnAnurUpam | na cAtra punaruktirapyAzaGkanIyA | pUrvaM rUpakAyAptikAmatAprasaGge tu tadvyudAso darzita:, {1. dra^- upari TIkAyAm, pR. 129} adhunA tathAgatapUjAsatkAraprasaGge darzitatvAd bhinna eva (rUpakAya) | atrArthata: rUpakAye tathAgatAbhinivezaM vipakSatvena nirdizya tatprahANArthaM chandaM praNidhAna cApi pradarzite | lakSaNAni ityupalakSaNamAtroktyA sakalo rUpakAya paridIpita: | alakSaNAni iti paramArthavyavasthAnam | tena ityAdinA vikSepanigraho nirdiSTa: | 12. kAyacittaparizrAntau vIryavaimukhyAnArambhalAbha-satkAravirahitatA : evaM sarvadharmANAM nairAtmyAvagamopAye nirdiSTe’pi kAyajIviteSvAsajya ye lAbhasatkArAdhyavasitA: kausIdyalAbhasatkArapiNDapAtAnuraktA teSAM tatrAnurakti- visaMyogArthaM dvAdazasthAnamadhikRtyAha- yazca khalu puna: subhUte, strI vA puruSo vA ityAdi | @163 bhagavAnAha- yazca khalu puna: subhUte, strI vA puruSo vA dine dine gaGgAnadIvAlukAsamAnAtmabhAvAn parityajet, evaM parityajan gaGgAnadIvAlukAsamAn kalpAMstAnAtmabhAvAn parityajet, yazca ito dharmaparyAyAdantazazcatuSpAdikAmapi gAthAmudgRhya parebhyo dezayet saMprakAzayet, ayameva tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAda prameyamasaMkhyeyam | atha khalvAyuSmAn subhUtirdharmavegenAzrUNi prAmuJcat | so’zrUNi pramRjya bhagavantametadavocat- AzcaryaM bhagavan, paramAzcaryaM sugata, yAvadayaM dharmaparyAyastathAgatena bhASito’grayAnasaMprasthitAnAM sattvA- nAmarthAya, zreSThayAnasaMprasthitAnAmarthAya, yato me bhagavan, jJAnam utpannam | na mayA bhagavan, jAtvevaMrUpo dharmaparyAya: zrutapUrva: | anena cAsAre’nekazatasahasradu:khaikasthAnatucchAtmabhAve tasmin snihyan etAvaccharIraparityAgenApi yatpuNyaM na prAptam, tadantarAyakaratvAttasmin kAyajIvite nirapekSacittatayA sarvAtmanA’smin (dharmaparyAye) yoga: karaNIya iti paridIpitam | anenArthata: kausIdyAdayo vipakSatvena darzitA: | tatprahANAya saddharmasamAdAnAya ca chanda: praNidhAnaJcApi nirdiSTe | ito dharmaparyAyAt ityupalakSaNamAtroktyA samastamahAyAnazravaNAdIni Abadhyante | bahutaraM puNyam ityanena audAryamuktam | dharmavegena iti dharmazraddhAbalenetyartha: | AryasubhUti: azruNi prAmuJcat tadapi bhagavato’dhiSThAnenAnyeSu kusIdeSu janeSu adbhutamahAyAnadharmasyAbhidhAnena paramazraddhotpAdArthe draSTavyam | tasmAd hastena azrUNi pramRjya bhagavantametadavocat AzcaryaM bhagavan, yAvadayaM dharmaparyAyastathAgatena bhASita: ityAha | yAvad iti kAritravizeSa:{1. ayaM pATha: pekiMga-narathaG saMskaraNAnusAram, de. ge. saMskaraNe tu “akAritravizeSa:” |} | yAvatA prakAreNa dezanArhAstAn bodhisattvAnupadizantviti vAkyArtha: | kasmAdityAkAGkSAyAM yato me jJAnamutpannam ityakathayat | yata: ityAryasatyagocarajJAnotpAdamArabhya etatparyantaM dharmaparyAyasya paramapuNyaphalasya yathoktA dezanA zrAvaka-pratyekabuddhAnAmagocarA naivaM zrutapUrvetyartha: | etena- @164 parameNa te bhagavan, AzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bodhisattvA bhaviSyanti, ye iha sUtre bhASyamANe zrutvA bhUtasaMjJAmutpAdayiSyanti | tatkasya heto: ? yA caiSA bhagavan bhUtasaMjJA, saiva abhUtasaMjJA | tasmAt tathAgato bhASate bhUtasaMjJA bhUtasaMjJeti | daurlabhyaM proktam | evaM viziSTa puNya zrutvA yeSAM vIryamArabhya pravRttAnAmasmin dharme yathArutasaMjJA bhavati teSAM taddoSaparijihIrSayA parameNAzcaryeNa ityavocat | vipulapuNyAnyutpAdayato’dharmapuruSasya tAdRgduSkarazraddhAdhimuktito’nyantagambhIra- pudgala-dharmanairAtmyAdhimuktitazca mameva{1. subhUti iva ayamartha: |} pudgalanairAtmyabhAvazuddhajJAnena, parameNa te AzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti | bhUtasaMjJAm ityaviparItArthasaMjJAma, na tu zabdAbhinivezenedaM bhUtatvamiti saMjJA | evamatra paramArthamabhipretya sarvadharmani:svabhAvatva nirdiSTam, na tu saMvRtim, ni:svabhAvatAyA abhAvAttatra | tasmAnna darzanAdinA virodha ityabhiprAya | nanuM bhUtasaMjJAyo satyAM, saMjJAyAM api sattva paramArthata: syAt, asatsu ca saMjJeyeSu saMjJAyA apyabhAva prasajyeta, tasmAt kathaM paramArthata: sarvadharmani:svabhAvatvaM sidhyedityupAlambha vicintya tatkasya heto: ? ityavocat | yA caiSA bhagavan, bhUtasaMjJA ityudatarat | saMjJAnAma na kAcana, ekAnekasvabhAvena viyogAt, paramArthata: sA asaMjJaiva | ata eva nocyate bhUtasaMjJeyaM bhUtasaMjJAtveneti darzitam, yato hyavicAraramaNIyamAtrata vidyate tasmAt tAM tathAgato bhASate bhUtasaMjJA, anyathA sarvathA’bhAvAnna bhASeta | tata: paramArthavyavasthAyAM kathaM yogasamApattyAM pratipattavyam, kathaM ca vikSepo nigrahItavya ityubhayaM darzitaM gAmbhIryaJcApi nigaditam, adhyAropApavAdAntAvapi parihRtau | teSu, kusIdeSvevAzcaryotpAdanArtham na mama bhagavan, AzcaryaM yadahamimaM dharmaparyAyaM bhASyamANamavakalpayAmi, adhimucye, ye’pi te bhagavan, sattvA bhaviSyantyanAgate’dhvani pazcime kAle pazcime- @165 na mama bhagavan, AzcaryaM {1. jozIsaMskaraNe “duSkaram” iti pATha: kiJca vaidyabhoTasaMskaraNayozca “Azcaryam” pATha: | atra TIkAmusAraM “Azcaryam” pATha eva samIcIno’sti |} yadahamimaM dharmaparyAyaM bhASyamANamavakalpayAmi adhimucye | ye’pi te bhagavan, sattvA bhaviSyantyanAgate’dhvani pazcime kAle pazcime samaye pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAM saddharmavipralope vartamAne, ye imaM bhagavan, dharmaparyAyamudgrahISyanti dhArayiSyanti vAcayiSyanti paryavApsyanti, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayiSyanti, te paramAzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti | samaye pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAM ye imaM bhagavan, dharmaparyAyam udgrahISyanti, dhArayiSyanti, paryavApsyanti, te paramAzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti ityAha | atrAyaM sAmAnyena samAsArtha: - anAgate saddharmavipralopakAle ye bodhisattvA imaM dharmaparyAyaM dhArayiSyanti, na te pudgalAdibhirgRhItA bhaviSyanti, mayyapyevaM{2. mayi iti subhUti: |} sambhAvanAyAM saddharmotthAnakAle’pi yuSmAkametAdRzapratipattyabhAve idamatyantaM lajjAsthAnaM tat syAdityucyate | tatra `aham’ iti pudgalanairAtmyaM bodhyate, imaM ityanena pudgaladharmanairAtmyaM prakAzyate, bhASyamANam iti tu sAkSAt prakAzyamAnaM bhagavatA, avakalpayAmi iti prasAdAkAra: prasannatA saMdarzyate, adhimucye iti sampratyayazca, te sattvA: ityanena bhagavan, anAgate kalpe bhAvina: | atrodgrahISyantItyAdIni yAni padAni tAni pUrvamevoktAni | taccaivaM nirucyate- pudgalanairAtmyamAtramavaganturmama bhagavata: sakAzAt sAkSAt zravaNabalena yaddhi nairAtmyadvayapratipAdake’smin dharme prasAdasampratyayamAtraM jAtaM tannaivAzcaryam | ye bhagavan (teSu) kalpeSu asmin (dharme) dhAraNAdikrameNa IdRzaM dharmaparyAyamadhigamya paryavApsyanti te paramAzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti | bhagavan, (teSu) kalpeSu bahulatayA mahAyAnaviprakRSTA bhavanti, teSu @166 api tu khalu punarbhagavan na teSAmAtmasaMjJA pravartiSyate, na sattvasaMjJA, na jIvasaMjJA, na pudgalasaMjJA pravartiSyate, nApi teSAM kAcitsaMjJA nAsaMjJA pravartate | tatkasya heto: ? yA sA bhagavan, cAtmasaMjJA, saivAsaMjJA | yA sattvasaMjJA jIvasaMjJA pudgalasaMjJA, saivAsaMjJA | tatkasya heto: ? sarvasaMjJApagatA hi buddhA bhagavanta: | zraddhotpAdastvatidurlabha ityabhiprAya: | etena kausIdyaM prahAya saddharmagrahaNAdau chandena praNidhAnena ca sthAtavyamityAdarzitam | na kevala teSu Agamayoga evApitu (teSu) pratipattisampadamapi darzayitum api tu khalu punarbhagavan ityavocat | AtmA ityAdivacanam tUpalakSaNam, atasteSAM dharmasaMjJA (api) na pravartiSyate, dvayornairAtmyayoryugapadadhigamAt | yadyanAtmAdikaM sat tadA saMjJApi tatra niyamena pravartyediti vicintya tatkasya heto: ? iti pRSTvA AtmasaMjJA ityudatArIt | yathAtmetyAdyuktastathA ayamahamityapyAtmasaMjJA yA sarvajanaprasiddhA, tasyA api parIkSA’kSamatvAdakiJcanatve sati AtmAdyanubhavAbhAvAdasatyA: kA kathA | anena tAvad yogasamApatti: nirdiSTA | nanu cAsattve satyAtmAdestadviparyayeNa nAtmasaMjJA pravartiSyata iti kuta ityAbhyantarotthitaM praznaM vicArya tatkasya heto: ? ityavocat | sarvasaMjJApagatA hi buddhA bhagavanta:{1. sarvakalpavikalpaprahINo hi tathAgata: | -a. pra. pR. 177 ; prajJApAramitAjJAnamadvayaM sA tathAgata: | -pra. pi. 1kA. ; vidhUtakalpanAjAlagambhIrodAramUrttaye | -pra. vA. 1/1 |} ityudarata | atrAyamartha:- samastabhAvAnAM yathAvattattvAdhigamena `buddhA bhagavanta:’ ityucyate | paramArthata: kasyApi saMjJeyasyAbhAvAt, na kutrApi te saMjJA pravartate, anyathA viparyAsa: syAt | bodhisattvAstu buddhAnuzikSAmanuvartante, anyathA kathaM tatpadaM prApnuyu:, tasmAt buddhairbhagavadbhiryathA sarvasaMjJApagatatvaM zikSitaM tathA bodhisattvairapi zikSitavyam | tasmAd ye bodhisattvAstasyAmanuzikSante teSAmAtmAdisaMjJA niyamato na pravartate | @167 evamukte bhagavAnAyuSmantaM subhUtimetadavocat- evametat subhUte, evametat | paramAzcaryasamanvAgatAste sattvA bhaviSyanti, ye iha subhUte, sUtre bhASyamANe no trasiSyanti na saMtrasiSyanti na saMtrAsamApatsyante | tatkasya heto: ? paramapAramiteyaM subhUte, tathAgatena bhASitA yadutApAramitA | yAM ca subhUte, tathAgata: paramapAramitAM bhASate, tAmaparimANA api buddhA bhagavanto bhASante | tenocyate paramapAramiteti | evametat iti vineyAnAM vineyAnAM nizcayApAdanArthaM svayamabhyupagamya bhagavatA dviruktam | ita: pUrvamanArabdhavIryAnadhikRtyAbhihitam | samprati pudgalA dharmagAmbhIryaM zrutvA trasyanti | ata: prathamataramanArabdhavIryANAM teSAm anArabdhavIryatvApanayanArthaM ye sattvA: ityAdyAha | santrAse sati nArabhante vIryam, zrAvakayAne’smin bhagavatA dharmamAtramidaM pudgalAsattvamityuktam, mahAyAne tu tadapi dharmamAtraM mithyeti dezitam, tasmAd anAdikAlIna- sahajAtmadRSTisamprayuktAnta:karaNA abhAvitAtmAna: pudgalanairAtmyaM zrutvA nAstyahamiti trasiSyanti | tanniSedhArthaM no trasiSyanti iti dezitam | ye dharmamAtre’bhiniviSTAste dharmanairAtmyadezanAzravaNakAle santrasiSyanti, yad dharmamAtraM tasyApyasattve `aho ! na mayA bhAvyam’ iti matvA dazadigavalokanenApi zaraNAbhAvAt santrAse tadapAkaraNAya na santrasiSyanti ityuddiSTam | cintAkAle ubhayAbhAvayogasyAzakyatvAt santrasiSyanti `kathamasmAbhirnairAtmyadvayamadhigantavyam’ ityAdimasantrAsApasAraNArthaM na santrAsamApatsyante ityuktam | anye tAvannairAtmyadvayAnavabodhAd yo hi trAso mRdu-madhyAdhimAtrAtmaka: sa ebhistribhi: padai: yathAkramamudIrita ityevaM manyante, apare tu trividhastrAsa: zravaNa-manana-bhAvanAkAle bhavatItyabhyupagacchanti | samprati lAbhasatkAreSu vItarAgatvAt `te paramAzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyantIti |’ zrotukAmAnAM hitAya svayaM pUrvaM praznamuthApya tatkasya heto: ? ityavocat | paramapAramiteyaM ityuktam | prajJApAramiteyaM bodherAsAnnahetu: | asyA abhAvena dAnAdi- pAramitAnAmabhAvAt sarvapAramitAsu zreSThA | na kevalaM mayaiveyaM paramA proktA, @168 api tu khalu puna: subhUte, yA tathAgatasya kSAntipAramitA, saiva apAramitA | tatkasya heto: ? yadA me subhUte, kaliMgarAjA aGgapratyaGgamAMsAnyacchetsIt, nAsInme tasmin samaye AtmasaMjJA vA sattvasaMjJA vA jIvasaMjJA vA pudgalasaMjJA vA, nApi me kAcitsaMjJA vA asaMjJA vA babhUva | tatkasya heto: ? sacenme subhUte, tasmin samaye AtmasaMjJA abhaviSyat, vyApAdasaMjJApi me tasmin samaye’bhaviSyat | sacetsattvasaMjJA jAvasaMjJA pudgalasaMjJAbhaviSyat, api tu sarvabuddhairapIyaM parametyukteti darzanArthaM yAM ca paramapAramitAM iti nigaditam | anena `ekabuddhena dezitamapi aviparItArthatvena gRhyate sarvabuddhaikAbhipretatve khalu kimucyatAm’ ityevaM dIpitam | (yadi) asmAbhi: sarvai: paramA saMsAdhitA syAt, kathaM na (vayaM) parameNAzcaryeNa samanvAgatA bhaviSyAma: ? anena paramatvadarzanena hriya: dvitIyaM sthAnaM nirdizyate, tathA hi-dharmo’yaM (etAvAn) zreSThastathApi tvaM yallAbhasatkArAdhyavasita: pramAdena sthitastadatIva lajjAjanakamityucyate | anena cittapragraha: sandarzita: | 13. du:khAdhivAsana-sthAnam : evaM hrIsthAne dezite’pi ye du:khe’kSAntyA vIryAtizayamArabdhuM notsahante, teSAM du:khAkSAntervyapagamArthaM trayodazasthAnamadhikRtyAha api tu khalu puna: subhUte ityAdi | kimatra kSAnti: ? kena lakSaNena sA kSAntirjJAyate ? tasyA: ya AkAra:, yathA vA’’kAra:, yazcAkSAnte: pratipakSa: so’nena sthAnena darzyate | kIdRzI kSAntiriti cet ? sarvadharmAnupalambhasvabhAva:, ata: yA tathAgatasya kSAntipAramitA saiva apAramitA ityuktam | paramArthata: kA kSAnti:,{1. na ca dveSasamaM pApaM na ca kSAntisamaM tapa: | tasmAtkSAntiM prayatnena bhAvayedvividhairnayai: || - bo. ca. 6/2 |} kSAnti:, yatra kSAnti:, yazca kSamya:, yA ca kSAnti:, teSAM sarveSAmanupalambhAt @169 vyApAdasaMjJApi me tasmin samaye’bhaviSyat | tatkasya heto: ? abhijAnAmyahaM subhUte, atIte’dhvani paJcajAtizatAni yadahaM kSAntivAdI RSirabhUvam | tatrApi me nAtmasaMjJA babhUva na sattvasaMjJA, na jIvasaMjJA, na pudgalasaMjJA babhUva | saiva apAramitA | evaM paramArthato’nutpannatvAt nAsti tatra pAraM gatetyabhisandhi: | anena tasyA: kSAnte: svabhAvenAnutpannatvaM gAmbhIryaM cApi darzitam | evaM sarvadharmAnupalambhamanasikAreNa kuta: bodhisattvAnAM kSAntiriti vicintya tatkasya heto: ? iti jJApakahetau pRSTe yadA subhUte ityAdyuttaramAha | aGgAni hastapAdAdIni, pratyaGgAni aGgulyAdIni | nApi me kAcitsaMjJA iti paradehasaMjJA, zastrasaMjJA, chedasaMjJA, parasaMjJA, kSAntisaMjJAdayazca | anena sarvadharmAnupalambho’bhihita: | nanu asatyAJca kasyAJcit saMjJAyAM mUrcchAvasthAvad cittAbhAvo bhaviSyatIti cet ? tatra nApi asaMjJA vA babhUva ityAha | tasmin kAle sarvadharmanairAtmyAvabodhakaM yogijJAnaM tathyasaMvRtisvabhAvamabhipretam | tacca kathamiti cittagataM praznaM vikalpya svayaM tatkasya heto: ? ityuktvA sacet subhUte ityudatarat | vyApAdasaMjJApi asyAyamabhiprAya:- yatra AtmasaMjJA, tatra nUnaM tanmAtreNAtmasneho jAyate | evamAtmasnehasamprayoge’vazyaM sva-paravikalpau jAyete | tenaivaM ya AtmopakAritvenopAdattAsteSvAtmIyatvaM parikalpyate, itareSu ca paratvaM kalpyate | ata evAtmAnurUpA pravRtti: | tatrAtmani AtmIyeSu ca pravRttau anurAga:, tadviparIteSu ca dveSa: | tAbhyAM sambaddha: samasto doSarAzi: sambhavati | ata evoktam{1. pra. vA. 1/221} : Atmani sati parasaMjJA sva-paravibhAgAt parigrahadveSau | anayo: sampratibaddhA: sarve doSA: prajAyante ||iti|| yatra vyApAdAdidoSaughastatra kathaM kSAntivAdIti prasetsyati, yena kSAntibalena kaliGgarAjA eva sattva: narakaM gamiSyatItyabhipretam | anena kRtApakAre’pi @170 tasmAttarhi subhUte, bodhisattvena mahAsattvena sarvasaMjJA vivarjayitvA anuttarAyAM samyaksaMbodhau cittamutpAdayitavyam | na rUpapratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyam, na zabdagandharasaspraSTavya- dharmapratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyam, na dharmapratiSThitaM cittam utpAdayitavyam, nAdharmapratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyam, na kvacit pratiSThitaM cittamutpAdayitavyam | sati nirvikAratayA niyataM vyApAdAdisambhavAbhAvatayA AtmAdisaMjJAvyapagamahetutayA ca IdRzyA: kSAnterjJAnamAdarzitam | anenaiva ca trividhA: kSAntayo’pi tAvannirdizyante{1. dharmanidhyAnakSAnti:, du:khAdhivAsanAkSAnti:, parApakAradharmakSAnti: | -dha. saM. (ma. sU. saM. pR. 337) ti. saM. saMskaraNam 1988 ; dra^- bo. ca. paM., 6/8 pR. 83, 1960 mi. saM. |} | atra kaliGgarAjA ityanena apakAramarSaNakSAnti: paridIpitA, aGga-pratyaGga ityanena du:khAdhivAsanakSAnti: me tasmin samaye ityAdinA ca dharmanidhyAnakSAnti: | anena dharmapudgalavikalpayorvipakSatayA nirdezena vineyAstatprahANe yathoktakSAntyutpAde samyaggrahaNe cAvataranti | tadevam, vineyajanA: `yadA bhagavAneva bodhyarthamevaMvidhAM parAM kSAntiM bhAvitavAn, tatkathamasmAbhirna bhAvanIyA, duSkarakarmaNyananuSThite durlabhapadaM nAdhigamyate' iti vicArayanti | tataste vineyAstasyAM protsAhyante | aGga-pratyaGgeti nimittamAtrAbhidhAnena sarvadu:khAdhivAsanakSAnti: samudIritA | samprati yadAkArA sA kSAnti:, tathA darzayitum- abhijAnAmyahaM subhUte ityAha | tadapi kaliGgarAjA me aGgapratyaGgamAMsAnyacchetsIt ityetatprasaGgaprAptam, sAkSAnnoktam | sA ca kSAnti: dvividhA dIpitA- nirantaraparApakAradu:khaviSayikA parApakArAsahyadu:khaviSayikA ca | tatra nirantaradu:khaviSayayastu yat paJcajAtizatAni iti | etena asyaudAryam abhihitam | asahyadu:khaviSayastu yat aGga-pratyaGgAnIti kathitam | trividhaM (hi) du:khaM tAvad asahyaM vastu, tadyathA- saMsAradu:khaM sattvapratikUlapravRttidu:khaM paribhogavaikalyadu:khaM ca | tatra prathamasyAsahyavastuna: pratipakSatvena tasmAttarhi ityuktam | samastenAnena asahyaprahANAt bodhau chandena @171 tatkasya heto: ? yatpratiSThitaM tadevApratiSThitam | tasmAdeva tathAgato bhASate-apratiSThitena bodhisattvena dAnaM dAtavyam | na rUpazabdagandharasasparzadharmapratiSThitena dAnaM dAtavyam | praNidhAnena ca sthAtavyamiti darzitam | bodhicittotpAde sati na kenApi saMsAradu:khena spRSTo bhaviSyatItyabhiprAya: | bodhicittotpAde’pi AtmAbhiniviSTatayA trividhadu:khasaMjJAbhi: santrasya kadAcit punarnotpAda: syAdata: sarvasaMjJA vivarjayitvA ityAha | sarvasaMjJAzcAtra AtmAdisaMjJA: trividhadu:khasaMjJAzca | rUpAdyabhinivezena zrAvakAdivat saMsAraM parikalpya taddu:khasantaptA: na kadAcidapi bodhicittamutpAdayanti, ata: na rUpapratiSThitam ityAdyuktam | rUpAdiSu sattAbhinivezo hi tatra pratiSThita iti pUrvavadatrApyukta:, na cAtra punaruktirapi | anena asahyavastuna: pratipakSo’bhihita: | pUrveNa tu pAramitAyAM yoga: karaNIya: | atra vineyai: nAdharmapratiSThitam iti zeSa: | anena tAvadabhAve’bhiniveza: pratiSidhyate | na kvacit pratiSThitam ityanena rUpAdiSu nAmamAtrasattAbhiniveza: pratiSidhyate, yogasamApattizcodIritA bhavati | kiM rUpAdInAM satAM tatsattvasya prahANArtham, yaduta asatAM vitathAbhinivezasya prahANArthaM pratiSedha: kriyate ? iti cittotthitaM praznaM vitarkya tatkasya heto: ? ityapRcchat | uttarArthamAha-yatpratiSThitaM tadevApratiSThitam iti | atrAyamartha:- anAdikAlatastaccittaM rUpAdiSu bhAvAbhinivezabalena rUpAdau pratiSThitam, ya: khalu satyAbhiniveza:, sa tasya rUpAdivastuno’bhAvAt paramArthato na pratiSThita: | tasmAdeva ityanenopasaMhAreNAtra dvitIye pakSe pratiSThitatvameva darzitaM bhavati | dAnazabdenAtrApi pUrvavat SaT pAramitA evAbhipretA: | dvitIyAsahyavastuna: pratipakSatvena api tu khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | samastenAnena bodhisattvA yeSAmarthAyAtiduSkarapAramitA- yogamArabdhumutsahante, te’pi sattvA yadi paramArthato na syu:, sattvasaMjJA’pi paramArthato na syAt, kathaM te tathAvidheSu mithyApravRtteSu sattveSu khinnA bhaveyu: @172 api tu khalu puna: subhUte, bodhisattvena evaMrUpo dAnaparityAga: karttavya: sarvasattvAnAmarthAya | tatkasya heto: ? yA caiSA subhUte, sattvasaMjJA, saiva asaMjJA | ya evaM te sarvasattvA: tathAgatena bhASitAsta eva asattvA: | ityAdarzitam | tatra sattvaM saMjJAM ca pratiSidhya nairAtmyadvayamudIritam | sarvasattvAnAmarthAya ityanenAtraudAryaM darzitam | avaziSTena sakalena gAmbhIryaM sandarzitam | evaM tAvad yuktyA kSAntiryujyata iti nirdizya sAmprata tathAgate sampratyayo’pi yujyata iti nirUpayan bhUtavAdI ityAdyAha | prathamam uddeza:, zeSaM vidheyam | athavA satyacatuSTayamuddeza:, kramaza: abhisambadhyate | athavA bhUtavAdI iti sAdhyam, tathAgata: iti jJApakanirdeza: {1. tathAgato kAlavAdI, bhUtavAdI, atthavAdI, dhammavAdI, vinayavAdI, tasmA tathAgato ti vuccati | -dIghanikAya, jilda 3. pR. 104; dra. -a. pra., 31 adhyA, pR. 253} | yathA’nye buddhA bhagavanta: klezajJeyAvaraNAni prahINavantastathaiva tathAgato’pyayaM gata: prApta:, tena tathAgata: {2. dra^- prastutA TIkA, upodghAta-prasaGge |} | tasmAdaviparyastatvena bhUtavAdIti, viparItadezanAyAzca hetorAvaraNasyAbhAva: sidhyati hetvanupalabdhe: | tathAgata evAyamiti kathaM sidhyatItyAha-satyavAdI iti | `satyam’ caturAryasatyalakSaNam, tasya yo vAdI, sa tathAgata iti nirdhAryate |{3. AryasatyAnAM ca abhAvAt saddharmo’pi na sambhavati | satAmAryANAM dharma: saddharma: | tatra nirodhasatyaM phaladharma:, mArgasatyaM tu phalAvatAradharma: | eSa tAvadadhigamadharma: | tatsaMprakAzikA dezanA Agamadharma: | sarva eSa AryasatyAnAmabhAve sati nAstIti | abhAvAccAryasatyAnAM saddharmo’pi na vidyate | dharme cAsati saMghe ca kathaM buddho bhaviSyati || -ma. zA. vR. 24/4, pR. 213, bau. bhA. saM. 1983 } atyantaparokSArthastu sarvathA samyak kathayituM na zakyate, yathoktam-{4. pra. vA. 1/134 |} parokSopeyataddhetostadAkhyAnaM hi duSkaram | @173 tatkasya heto: ? bhUtavAdI subhUte, tathAgata:, satyavAdI tathAvAdI ananyathAvAdI tathAgata:, na vitathavAdI tathAgata: | ayaM satyavAdI satyaM kena rUpeNa jAnAtItyAha- tathAvAdI iti | sa vastutattvamaviparItatayA yathAvad vadatIti tathAvAdI | sa heyopAdeyatattvaM sopAyaM yathAsthitaM tathaiva bhASate'ta: sa kathaM na satyavAdI syAditi | evaMbhUte'pi taddezirAni catvAri satyAni kiM tathaiva pratiSThitAnIti ? ityata Aha- na vitathavAdI iti | yato’viparItapramANopapannAni, na pramANabAdhitAni uktAnyata: satyAnItyartha: | etena samagreNa kAryakAraNena bhagavata: prAmANyaM sAdhitam | ata evoktam-{1. pra. vA. 1/282 |} tAyAt tattvasthirAzeSavizeSajJAnasAdhanam | ekasyApi bhAvasvabhAvasya paramArthato’siddhatvAd ekamapi satyaM tAvad du:sAdhyam, kimiti satyacatuSTayamiti catu:satyAbhidhAnAcca bhUtavAdIti | evaM bhagavatA `mAyopamA: paJcaskandhA:’{2. tulanIyam- "yadapIdamupAdAnaM tat svAbhAvAnna vidyate |” yadyapi idamupAdAnaM rUpavedanAsaMjJAsaMskAravijJAnAkhyaM skandhapaJcakam, tadapi svabhAvena na vidyate, pratItyasamutpannatvAt | ma. zA. vR. 22/9 bau. bhA. pra.; api ca- mAyopamAste devaputrA: sattvA:, svapnopamAste devaputrA: sattvA: |... sarvadharmA api devaputrA mAyopamA | -dra^. ma. zA. vR. 22 adhyA. pR. 195, bau. bhA. pra., 1983 |} ityukte sati kathaM teSAM du:khasatyasvabhAvatvam, du:khasyApi paramArthato’nRtatvAt tatsamudayanirodhayorapyasattvameva, atyantAbhAvabhUte zazazRGgAdau tAvattau (samudaya-nirodhau) na sambhavata: | nirodhasya tvabhAvAt tatprApako mArgo’pi naiva paramArthata:, gamyAbhAve naiva gamako’pi | tathoktam-`bodhiM pratiSThAya ekasyApi satyasya siddhirna dRSTA, kimiti caturNAm ?’ iti dezanAvat | etat pravicintya ye bhUtavAdini zabdazo’bhiniviSTAsteSAmadhyAropAnta- parihArArtham api tu khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | na tatra satyam iti paramArthata: kasyacidapi svabhAvasyAsiddhe: | na mRSA ityatra satyavyavacchedena @174 api tu khalu puna: subhUte, yastathAgatena dharmo’bhisaMbuddho dezito nidhyAto, na tatra satyaM na mRSA | tadyathApi nAma subhUte, puruSo’ndhakArapraviSTo na kiJcidapi pazyet, evaM vastupatito bodhisattvo draSTavyo yo vastupatito dAnaM parityajati | tadyathApi nAma subhUte, cakSuSmAn puruSa: prabhAtAyAM rAtrau sUrye’bhyudgate nAnAvidhAni rUpANi pazyet, evamavastupatito bodhisattvo draSTavyo yo’vastupatito dAnaM parityajati | sthitatvAt tadvyavacchedyatvAbhAvAd yena mRSAtvaM bhavet tanmRSA | atha vA na satyam iti yathA mAyopamA mRSA jJAnarUpA: | avicAraramaNIyamAtratayA sthitatvAd na mRSA iti | anena tAvad antadvayapratiSedhena madhyamA pratipad eva nirdizyate | zrAvakANAmAtmAbhinivezasya prahANArthaM pudgalanairAtmyAMzamAtreNa catvAryAryasatyAni dezitAni, na tu sarvebhya ityavirodha: | kAyAdikamupalabhya tadarthako dAnaM dadAti, anupalabhya atadarthako vA, tayo: ko vizeSa iti yaccintanaM tat tRtIyasyAsahyavastuna: pratipakSatvenAha tadyathApi nAma ityAdi | ya: kAya-bhava-bhogAtmakavastuSu sukhamAtratvenAbhinivizya (satyatvenaivAbhinivizya) tadarthikastatra patitvA dAnaM dadAti, sa andhakArapraviSTapuruSasadRza:, satorapi cakSuSo: vastvarthAnupalambhena heyopAdeyArthAnabhijJatayA viparyastArtheSu samastadu:khasthAneSu patito bhavati | tata: bodhisattvA mahAsukhabhogAt pracyutA bhaviSyanti | tadviyogena zrAvakAdivat du:khasantaptatayA bodhervyAvRtA bhaviSyanti | yo vastvapatito dAnaM dadAti, kAyAdivastvanupalabhya tadanarthI bhUtvA dAnaM dadAti tattu yathApi nAma cakSuSmAn puruSa: nAnAvidhAni rUpANi pazyet dRSTvA ca heyasya hAnam upAdeyasya copAdAnamiva | (atha) tadapi asatyaruNodaye{1. pekiMga narathaG ca saMskaraNayo: “asatyaruNodaye” pATha: prApyate ya: zuddha: pratIyate de. ge. saMskaraNe tu “tadapi aruNodaye” iti pATha: |} kadAcinna dRzyata iti ? sUrye’bhyudgate ityAha | sUrye’bhyudgate’pi andhakArapUrNeSu gRhAdiSu na pazyatIti matvA’’ha prabhAtAyAm @175 api tu khalu puna: subhUte, ye kulaputrA vA kaliduhitaro vA imaM dharmaparyAyamudgrahISyanti dhArayiSyanti vAcayiSyanti paryavApsyanti, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayiSyanti, jJAtAste subhUte, tathAgatena buddhajJAnena, dRSTAste subhUte, tathAgatena buddhacakSuSA, buddhAste tathAgatena | sarve te subhUte, sattvA aprameyamasaMkhyeyaM puNyaskandhaM prasaviSyanti pratigrahISyanti | iti | prabhAteti zabda: andhakAradyotanArthamukta: tasmAnnirandhakArAyAM dizAyAmityartha: | tatsAmagrye’pi yo’ndha:, sa kadAcidapi na pazyatItyAzaGkAyAM cakSuSmAn ityAha | evamavastupatito bodhisattvo draSTavya:, sa: avidyAtAmisraprabodhena jJAnasUryAbhyudgamena ca nAnAvidhAni jJeyAni yathAvat sampazyati, viparyastavastUni samastadu:khasthAnAni heyadu:khAni cApi mRSAtvAt parivarjayati, samastasukhasthAnasyAnuttarasamyaksambodhilakSaNasyopAdeyasyottamapadasyApi kAmanayA tatra pravartate | tasmAd bodhisattvA mahAbhogasampadanuprApya anuttarasukhena kAyaM sthirIkRtya bodheravinivRttA bhavantItyabhiprAya:, ata eva avinivRttA iti | pUrvaM tvAlambanamAtreNa tasmin sthitirAdarzitA, atra tu AlambanapUrvakaM tasminnanurAgalakSaNe patanam | tasmAdatra patita ityuktam, pUrvaM tu pratiSThita ityuktam | anena sakalena cittapragraha: paridIpita: | 14. dhyAnarasAsvAdavirati-sthAnam : anena prakAreNa kSAntipravRttA api ye dhyAnarasamAsvAdayantastatraivAsaktA jJAnasambhArapAripUraye hetubhUtaM mahAyAnadharmanArabdhAsteSAM jJAnasambhAraviyogaparihArArthaM caturdazasthAnamadhikRtya api tu khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | sthAnenAnena dhyAnarasAsvAdApagamAya paJcabhi: prakArai: saddharmaM prati vIryArthaM guNavizeSa: paridIpita:, (yathA)- 1. tathAgatAnubhAva:, 2. viziSTapuNyasaJcaya:, 3. dharmatatsAdhanayo: prazaMsanam, 4. devAdibhi: satkAra:, 5. pApaparizodhanaM ca | @176 yazca khalu puna: subhUte, strI vA puruSo vA pUrvAhNakAlasamaye gaGgAnadIvAlukAsamAnAtmabhAvAn parityajet, evaM madhyAhNa- kAlasamaye gaGgAnadIvAlukAsamAnAtmabhAvAn parityajet, sAyaMkAlasamaye gaGgAnadIvAlukAsamAnAtmabhAvAn parityajet, anena paryAyeNa bahUni kalpakoTiniyutazatasahasrANyAtmabhAvAn parityajet, yazcemaM dharmaparyAyaM zrutvA na pratikSipet, ayameva tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAdaprameyamasaMkhyeyam, ka: punarvAdo yo likhitvA udgrahaNIyAddhArayedvAcayetparyavApnuyAt, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayet | tatra tathAgatAnubhAvastu jJAtAste tathAgatena ityAdi yadAha | udgrahISyanti ityAdipadAnAM vyAkhyAnaM pUrvavadeva | bhagavAn hi sarvaM vijAnAtIti sarvajJa: draSTA ca | tatra kiM mahad AzcaryaM teSvityanveSaNAyAM puNyasaJcayavaiziSTyamAdarzayitumAha sarve te sattvA: iti | aprameyapuNyaskandhAnAM prasavanAd jJAtAste bhAgyavanta iti vAkyazeSa: | kiM ca tAvat puNyaskandhasya vaiziSTyam, yena (sa: puNyaskandha:) aparimito bhavatIti vicintya viziSTapuNyasaMgrahaM darzayan yazca khalu puna: subhUte ! strI vA puruSo vA ityAdyAha | sUrya-prabhA-pRthvIjalAdyavasthAvizeSa: pUrvAhNa: | evambhUteSvavasthA- vizeSeSveva kAla: iti prajJapyate, na tu viziSTatvena parikalpita iveti darzayituM kAlazabdastatsAmAnyAdhikaraNyena vizeSyate | anyathaikAtmyAd ayaM pUrvAhNa ityAdibhedA na syu: | vizeSaNAntarairbhede’bhyupagate sa eva vizeSa: sUryAdyavasthAnAM vizeSa: pUrvAhNAdivyavahAraprajJaptInAM ca hetu: syAt, akiJcitkaratve kimadRSTasAmarthyena kAlena prajJaptenetyabhiprAya: | na ca sa mandatIvrabuddhyAdiliGgavAnapi yujyate, mandAdibuddhInAM taddhetuta: samudbhave krameNotpattivirodhAd, etacca pUrvaM darzitameva | bAdhakapramANasyApi prAgevAtmadUSaNaprasaGge darzitatvAt kimadhikena | @177 api tu khalu puna: subhUte, acintyo’tulyo’yaM dharmaparyAya: | ayaM ca subhUte, dharmaparyAyastathAgatena bhASito’grayAnasaMprasthitAnAM sattvAnAmarthAya, zreSThayAnasaMprasthitAnAM sattvAnAmarthAya | ye imaM dharmaparyAyamudgrahISyanti dhArayiSyanti vAcayiSyanti paryavApsyanti, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayiSyanti, jJAtAste subhUte, tathAgatena buddhajJAnena, dRSTAste subhUte, tathAgatena buddhacakSuSA, buddhAste tathAgatena | sarve te subhUte, sattvA aprameyeNa puNyaskandhena samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti | sAmAnyajanai: saGketavazenotpannastathAvidha: prANinAmavasthAvizeSa: kAla: iti vyavahAre prajJapyate, na tu zabdArthasambandhaprajJaptivazezeneti darzayituM samaye{1. tu^- samayA zapathAcArakAlasiddhAntasaMvida: | -a. ko., 3/3/149 zapathAcArasiddhAnteSu tathA dhiyi | kriyAkAre ca nirdeze saMkete kAlabhASayo: || -iti medinI, 120/111 |} iti zabdena vizeSyate | kasyacidekasyApyakathanena yathoktadezanA’bhiprAyasya pratipAdanAbhAvAt padatrayamuktam | saGketaviSayatvena prajJApakaM zabdamAropya samAnAdhikaraNyaM kRtam | dhyAnarasAsvAdavirAgAyAtredamuktam | pUrvaM deyasya evaMvidhasya ca kAlasyAnirdezAnnaiva tAvat punaruktidoSa: | ayameva tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAd aprameyamasaMkhyeyam{2. pratyakSAdipramANena pramAtumazakyatvAdaprameyANAm | ekatvAdisaMkhyArahitatvena asaMkhyeyAnAm | -Aloka:, pR. 335, 351 |} ityanena audAryaM paridIpyate | saMkhyA-dravyakAla- vizeSairviziSTaM dAnodbhUtaM puNyamabhibhUyate | evaM tAvat gaGgAnadIbAlukAsamAna iti saMkhyAvizeSaM darzayati | AtmabhAva: iti duravagAho dravyavizeSa: | kalpakoTiniyutazatasahasrANi iti kAlavizeSa: | sA ca kalpakoTi: niyutA, sA’pi zatasahasreti padena yuktA | etat kathaM jJAtavyam ? iti dharmastutivaiziSTyaM darzayitum api tu khalu subhUte ityAdyAha | acintyo’yaM dharmaparyAya: atyantagambhIra: sarvadharmANAM nisvabhAvatAlakSaNa: tathAgatai: pratyAtmavedanIya:, zrAvakAdibhiraparaizcApi @178 acintyenAtulyenAmApyenAparimANena puNyaskandhena samanvAgatA bhaviSyanti | sarve te subhUte, sattvA: samAMzena bodhiM dhArayiSyanti | cintayitumazakyo hyatra nirdiSTa: | atulya: iti anyatra evaMvidhasya adarzanAt, etattulyasya viziSTasya vA’bhAvAt, tulyasya adhikasya vA’bhAvena acintyahetuto’cintyameva phalaM sambhavatItyuktam | kathaM atulya iti cintAyAmAha zreSThayAnasamprasthitAnAm iti | atizayena pAraM gatastu zreSTha iti | zrAvakAdInAm ayaM dharmaparyAya: ityuktam | agrayAnam ityagrANAM yAnaM vA agraM cedaM yAnamiti vA padavigraha: | ye tatra samprasthitAste tathocyante | evameva zreSThayAnasamprasthitAnAmityapi tatsamAnameva | tau tAvat paryAyau | {1. paryAyavacanaM kimarthamiti cet ucyate | tadA ca AyatyAM ca kasyacitkathaMcidarthAvabodhArtham | -Aloka:, pR. 359 |} paryAyadezanAbhiprAyastu vineyajanopakAra:, yena katipaye bhavyA bhavanti | itarayAnAnyapekSya zreSTha iti kecit | samastaklezajJeyAvaraNavizuddhyA vA zreSTha: athavA agramiti paramam | pratyekabuddhyAnamapi zrAvakayAnApekSayA paramiti vicAraNAyAmAha- zreSThayAnasamprasthitAnAm iti | atyantaM prazastagamanAt zreSTha ityuktam | zrAvakAdyanekayAnebhyo’tizayena prazasyatvAdatra zreSTha: iti zabda prayukta: | tacca mahAyAnamityeva | {2.dra^- a. pra., pR. 3. 12 |} zrAvakAdinAmabhavyatvAd dharmadezaneyaM bodhisattvebhya evoktA | tena siddho’yaM dharmaparyAyo’tulya iti | tathAgatena bhASita: ityanyeSAmagocaratvAt | dharmaparyAyo’yam ityAdibhi: yathoktAnarthAn prasAdhya upasaMhRtya ca tatpratipattuM vizeSastuti: sandarzitA | yato hi dharmaparyAyo’yamacintyo’prameyazca tasmAd vipAko’pyasyAcintya eva | tata: ye imaM dharmaparyAyaM dhArayiSyanti ityAdi tu siddhamevetyartha: | aprameyam ityuddeza:, zeSastAnnirdeza: | tatra acintyam iti cintAviSayAtikrAntatvena ananumeyatvAt | atulyam ityapratisamam | amApyam iti sarvasattvaprayoge’pi mApayitumazakyatvAt | aparimANam iti @179 tatkasya heto: ? na hi zakyaM subhUte, ayaM dharmaparyAyo hInAdhimuktikai: sattvai: zrotum, nAtmadRSTikairna sattvadRSTikairna jIvadRSTikairna pudgaladRSTikai: | nAbodhisattvapratijJai: sattvai: zakyamayaM dharmaparyAya: zrotuM vA udgrahItuM vA dhArayituM vA vAcayituM vA paryavAptuM vA | nedaM sthAnaM vidyate | api tu khalu puna: subhUte, yatra pRthvIpradeze idaM sUtraM - mahadbhirdezAdibhirapyaparimApyatvAd AkAzato’pyadhikam | athavA sarvANyapImAni paryAyAntargatAni | sarve te subhUte, sattvA: samAMzena bodhiM dhArayiSyanti iti bodhibhArodvahanam aMzodvahanasadRzam | anena tAvat sakalena dhyAnasukhAsvAdaM parityajya jJAnasambhArapAripUrihetau dharmaparigrahaNAdau chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti darzitam | kasmAt khalu zreSThayAnasamprasthitebhyo bhagavatA bhASito na tvanyebhya:, kiM khalu bhagavatyapi rAgo dveSazca iti vicintya tatkasya heto: ? ityAha, ata: subhUte hInAdhimuktikai: ityudatarat | anena khalu bhagavati sarvasattveSu ekasutavad vAtsalyamiti nAsti rAgo dveSo vA | tathApi ye yadA bhavyA bhavanti tadA tebhyo dezayanti, na tvanyebhya: | anyathA upAyAnabhijJatvAnnaiva bhaved bhagavAn sarvajJa: ityevaM darzyate | hInAdhimuktikairiti zrAvaka- pratyekabuddhai: | AtmAdidRSTikai: iti tairthikai: | nedaM sthAnaM vidyate iti nAsti tadarthamavakAza iti | yacchrAvakai: pratyekabuddhaizcApi zrotuM na zakyate tatkathaM zakyate pRthagjanai: zrotum ? yattairna zrotuM zakyaM tat kathaM zakyata udgrahItuM vA paryavAptuM vA | atastadasambhavamityartha: | anena tAvad yogasamApattAvavatAryate | yadyeva kathaM tAvadAryasubhUtinA dharmaparyAyo’yaM zrotuM zakyata iti ced ? bhagavato’dhiSThAneneti nAsti doSa: | sarvapradezeSu yasmin pRthivIpradeze sUtramidaM bhASyate sa evaika: pRthivIpradezo’nuzaMsanIya iti pratipAdayan devAdisatkAravaiziSTyaM darzayitum api tu khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyavocat | @180 prakAzayiSyate, pUjanIya: sa pRthivIpradezo bhaviSyati sadeva- mAnuSAsurasya lokasya vandanIya: pradakSiNIyazca sa pRthivIpradezo bhaviSyati, caityabhUta: sa pRthivIpradezo bhaviSyati | api tu ye te subhUte, kulaputrA vA kuladuhitaro vA imAnevaMrUpAn sUtrAntAnudgrahISyanti dhArayiSyanti vAcayiSyanti paryavApsyanti, yonizazca manasi kariSyanti, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayiSyanti, te paribhUtA bhaviSyanti, suparibhUtAzca bhaviSyanti | tatkasya heto: ? yAni ca teSAM subhUte, satvAnAM paurvajanmikAnyazubhAni karmANi kRtAnyapAyasaMvartanIyAni, dRSTa eva dharme tayA paribhUtatayA tAni paurvajanmikAnyazubhAni karmANi kSapayiSyanti, buddhabodhiM cAnuprApsyanti | pUrvaM tAvad bAhyazAstrAbhiSvaGgaparivarjanArthamuktam, samprati dhyAnarasAsvAdavarjanArthamiti nAsti punaruktatA, samastasaMgRhItArthAbhidhAne’pi bhinnaprasaGgAbhidhAnAnnAsti punaruktateti jJAtavyam | pUjanIya: iti chatradhvajapatAkAdibhi:, vandanIya: iti namaskaraNIya:, pradakSiNIya: pradakSiNAyogya:, ata eva pUjanIyatvAdidharmairyuktatvAd caitya: |{1. caityabhUto vandanAdinA puNyopacayahetutvAt | piteva pitRbhUta ityupamAvAcakabhUtazabdasyopAdAnAdanyacaityasamAnatvena caityabhUta: sa pRthivIpradeza: | -Aloka:, pR. 361; yatra hi nAma ...iti candragomI | -Aloka:, pR. 361 ; anyatrApi draSTavyam- a. pra., pR. 28 |} nanu IdRzeSu dharmaparyAyeSu abhyudyatAnAmapi kathaM kecit paribhUtA dRzyanta iti cintAyAM pApaparizodhanavizeSadezanAya ye subhUte, kulaputrA vA kuladuhitaro vA ityAdyAha | paribhUtA bhaviSyanti iti paribhASaNabhaNDanAdibhirvyApannA bhaviSyanti, suparibhUtAzca bhaviSyanti iti vadhabandhanAdibhi: pIDitA bhaviSyanti | evamete mahAtmAna: kathaM paribhUtA bhaviSyantIti vicintyAha tatkasya heto: ? iti | teSAM sattvAnAm ityAdyudatarat | paurvajanmikAni iti pUrvajanmani kRtAni | dRSTa eva dharme iti pratyutpannajIvite | buddhabodhiM @181 tatkasya heto: ? abhijAnAmyahaM subhUte, atIte’dhvanyasaMkhyeyai: kalpairasaMkhyeyatarai: dIpaMkarasya tathAgatasyArhata: samyaksaMbuddhasya pareNa paratareNa caturazItibuddhakoTiniyutazatasahasrANyabhUvan ye mayArAgitA:, ArAgyA na virAgitA: | yacca mayA subhUte, te buddhA bhagavanta ArAgitA:, ArAgyA na virAgitA:, yacca pazcime kAle pazcime samaye pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAM saddharmavipralopakAle vartamAne imAnevaMrUpAn sUtrAntAnudgrahISyanti dhArayiSyanti vAcayiSyanti paryavApsyanti, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayiSyanti, asya khalu puna: subhUte, puNyaskandhasyAntikAdasau paurvaka: puNyaskandha: zatatamImapi kalAM nopaiti, sahasratamImapi zatasahasratamImapi- cAnuprApsyanti iti pApAni parizodhya kAlAntare bhAvanAniratA na ciraM anuttarasamyaksabodhimabhisambuddhya buddhA bhaviSyantIti vAkyArtha: | tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAdaprameyamasaMkhyeyam iti yadAha tatra kena prakAreNa aprameyAkhyeyAvabodha: syAt ? ityatra abhijAnAmyahaM subhUte ityAdyAha | atra prabhAveNa bahutareNa cAprameyamasaMkhyeyaM ca paridIpitam | tatrAbhijAnAmi subhUte atIte’dhvanyasaMkhyeyai: kalpai: asaMkhyeyatarai: ityAdinA prabhAva: paridIpita: | ayaM tAvat puNyaskandhasyaiva prabhAva: | etAvatA prazastaro viziSTatara: (pUrvaka:) puNyaskandho’pyabhibhUyate | dIpaGkarata: yAvat asaMkhyeyakalpam | asaMkhyeyakalpastAvad gaNanAtItatvAt, dIpaGkarasya pareNa paratareNa caturazItibuddhakoTiniyutazatasahasrANyabhUvan, ye mayArAgitA: iti pratipattyarcayA {1. pUjAvizeSa: | (pUjAbheda:)} ArAdhitA: | na virAgitA: {2. ta^- a. pra., pR. 106 |} ityantarAle’pi tadabhinirhArasya anutsRSTatvAt | yacca iti kartRvizeSa: | tato’yamartha: yazca ArAgaNAdika: (puNyaskandha:), yazca udgrahaNAdizraddhAdipuNyaskandhastadutpAditazca vAsanAtmaka: skandha:, anayo: (puNyaskandhayo:) pUrvapuNyaskandha: uttarapuNyaskandhasyAsya zatatamImapi kalAM @182 koTitamImapi koTizatatamImapi koTizatasahasratamImapi koTiniyuta- zatasahasratamImapi | saMkhyAmapi kalAmapi gaNanAmapi upamAmapi upaniSadamapi yAvadaupamyamapi na kSamate | sacetpuna: subhUte, teSAM kulaputrANAM kuladuhitR#NAM vA ahaM puNyaskandhaM bhASayem, yAvatte kulaputrA vA kuladuhitaro vA tasmin samaye puNyaskandhaM prasaviSyanti, pratigrahISyanti, unmAdaM sattvA anuprApnuyuzcittavikSepaM vA gaccheyu: | api tu khalu puna: subhUte, acintyo’yaM dharmaparyAyastathAgatena bhASita: | asya acintya eva vipAka: pratikAMkSitavya: | nopaiti iti | {1. da^- Aloka: pa, 367 |} etAvato’lpIyastvaM darzayituM sahasratamImapi ityAha | saMkhyA iti tulyeSveva yujyate, yathA himavatA (tulya:) vindhya ityucyate, na tu sarSapa: | kalAm ityaMza:, sa ca samAnajAtIya eva, yathA sumero kalA parvatazikharameva, na tu tRNazikhara: | gaNanAm ityapi tulyeSveva, yathA sumerurapi giri:, himavAnapi giri:, na tu sarSapa: | upamAm ityapi sadRzeSveva, yathA gosadRzo gavaya ityucyate, na tu makSikA | laghurapi parikarmavazena tasya (mahata:) kRtyaM karoti, yathA nizite kRte sati dAtramapyasikRtyaM karotIti matvA upaniSadam ityAha | tADana- pIDanAdivistAropAyena tIkSNIkRte’pyatilaghutayA na kSamata ityartha: | ata eva aupamyamapi ityAha | tasyopamAbhAvamapi na kSamate | sarvajJavacanAdevaitajjJAtavyam, evaMvidheSu indriyaviSayAtIteSu viSayeSu sarvajJavacanasyaiva prAmANyAt | api ca parizuddhe kAle sarvasattvAnAmapi parizuddhatvAnnAzcaryam, aparizuddhe tAvat kAle ye sattvA kSaNamAtramAzayaparizuddhA bhavanti, tadAzcaryam | evaM prabhAvamukhena tAvadaprameyatvaM pradarzitam | kathamasaMkhyeyaM saMkhayeti vicAraNAyAM sacetpuna: subhUte...tasmin samaye ityAdyAha | tena bahulaM paridIpitam | tatpuNyagaNanayApi viSAdamanuprApya @183 atha khalvAyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavantametadavocat- kathaM bhagavan, bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitena sthAtavyam, kathaM pratipattavyam, kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyam ? bhagavAnAha- iha subhUte, bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitena evaM cittamutpAdayitavyam- sarve sattvA mayA anupadhizeSe nirvANadhAtau parinirvApayitavyA: | evaM ca sattvAn parinirvApya na kazcitsattva: parinirvApito bhavati | tatkasya heto: ? sacetsubhUte, bodhisattvasya sattvasaMjJA pravarteta, na sa bodhisattva iti vaktavya: | tatkasya heto: ? nAsti subhUte, sa kazciddharmo yo bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthito nAma | vyAmugdhacittAntarvizeSe unmAdamanuprApnuyu: | tata: udbhUtenonmAdena cittavikSepaM vA gaccheyu: | anena gAmbhIryamaudArya copadiSTam | evamasmAd dharmaparyAyAt saMkhyAprabhAvapratisaMyuktamevaMvidhaM phalaM kathaM jJAyata iti ? api tu khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | phalaM puna: hetvanurUpameva bhavati | laghiSThe’pi nyagrodhavRkSabIje’tizayasArasampannatvAd bRhacchAkhApallava- vRkSabhUtaM phalaM nopadRzyate | dharmaparyAyo’pyayam alpaparivarto’pyatyantagambhIra:, acintyadharmadezanAd acintya: | ato’smAdacintyAd hetupratyayAnurUpamacintyaM phalaM bhavati, hetupratyayaprabhAvastAvat sarvajJagocaratvAd acintya: | vipAkazabdo’tra phalArtha:, tena niSyandAdiphalAni saMgRhyante | etena sarveNa cittapragraho darzita: | 15. abhisamayakAle’hamitivikalpaviyoga-sthAnam : evaM nirAkRte’pi dhyAnarasAsvAde pratyAsanne’bhisamayakAle yai: bodhisattvai: AtmavaiziSTyamavalokya `ahaM samyaksambodhimArgapratipanna:, sarve mayA sattvA: parinirvApayitavyA:’ iti manyamAnaistaistasmin AtmagrAhavikale’bhisamayakAle kathaM sthAtavyam, kathaM pratipattavyam, kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyam ? ityetad darzayituM paJcadazasthAmadhikRtyAha- subhUti... avocat- kathaM bhagavan, bodhisattvayAnasamprasthitena sthAtavyam iti | sthAtavyamityAdidezanAtrayaM tu @184 tatkiM manyase subhUte, asti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatena dIpaMkarasya tathAgatasyAntikAdanuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha: ? evamukte AyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavantametadavocat- yathAhaM bhagavan, prAgevoktaM bhagavatA | nAsti subhUte, sa kazcid dharmo yo bodhisattvayAnasamprasthito nAma ityavaziSTenAtra AtmagrAhavisaMyoga: kriyate | zeSANAM (padAnAM) vyAkhyA tu pUrvavat | yathedaM pudgaladharmanairAtmyaM prAgeva bhagavatA prakAzitaM tathokte sati bodhisattveSu puna: abhisamayakAle kathamAtmagrAha: sambhaved ? tannirAkaraNAyoktamapi kiM punarucyate ? athaivamapi dezanAyAM saMmuhyet prAguktasyAnavasthAnaM ca syAditi ? tathA dezite’pi anAdikAlAtyanta- dRDhIbhUtAtmAbhinivezavazatayA keSAJcit sammohasyAnivRtte: dezito’pyartha: punarupadizyate | punardezanAkAle pAriSadyAnAM sammohanivRtternAnavasthA syAt | bhagavatA kRtasyopadezasya phalaM tAvat sammohavinivRttireva vineyajanAnAmiti na niSphalam | ata eva sammohanivRttau satyAM phalAbhAvena puna: pravRttyabhAvAt prakRtamevedam | 16. avavAdaparyeSaNasthAnam : yadi bodhisattvayAnasamprasthito nAma na syAt sa kazcid dharma: (tarhi) kathaM bhagavAn dIpaGkarasya zAsturantikAdavavAdaM prApya anuttarAM samyaksambodhimabhisambuddha: ? atha na syAd (sa:) abhisambuddha: (tarhi) abhisamayakAGkSiNA’vavAdo na paryeSTavya iti ye manyante, teSAmavavAda- viyogavisaMyogAya SoDazasthAnamadhikRtya tatkiM manse subhUte ityAdyAha | pUrvaM dharmakAyAptikAmatAvasare dharmagrAhaniSedha ukta:, {1. dra^- vajra. sU. 7 adhyA. ; dra^- prastutA TIkA, 4 sthAnam,|} idAnImabhisamayakAle abhisambuddhasya tasya niSedha: kriyate’to na punaruktatA | nAsti paramArthata: sa kazcidapi jJAnajJeyAtmako dharma:, yathA pUrvaM vicAritam | tadbalena avicAraramaNIyamAtratayA zrutamayyAdiprajJotpAdakrameNa bhagavata:- @185 bhagavato bhASitasyArthamAjAnAmi, nAsti sa bhagavan, kazciddharmo yastathAgatena dIpaMkarasya tathAgatasyArhata: samyaksaMbuddhasyAntikAd anuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha: | evamukte bhagavAnAyuSmantaM subhUtimetadavocat-evametatsubhUte, evametat | nAsti subhUte sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatena dIpaMkarasya tathAgatasyArhata: samyaksaMbuddhasya antikAdanuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha: | sacetpuna: subhUte, kazciddharmastathAgatenAbhisaMbuddho’bhaviSyat, na mAM dIpaMkarastathAgato vyAkariSyat-bhaviSyasi tvaM mANava – svayambhUsarvajJajJAnaM{1. sarvajJeyAvabodhenAtizayabuddhisadbhAvAt buddhA:, paropadezamantareNa svayaMbodhAt svayaMbhuva: | -Aloka:, pR. 368 |} tathyasaMvRtyA grAhyAtmakaM samudbhavati | nanu tadapi bhagavato dIpaGkarasyAnubhAvamAtramiti ced ? evaM satyapi anurUpameva, tathApi tasmin sarvabuddhAnAM sAdhAraNAnubhAvA:, na kevalaM bhagavato dIpaGkarasyaiva | yadi na syAdabhisambuddha: (kazcit tarhi) kathaM tena samyaksaMbodhau bhagavAn vyAkRta iti vicArya sacet puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | ayamabhiprAya:- yadi bhagavata: pratyAtmavedyo dharma: paramArthato tathAbhUto bhavet tadA syAdabhisambuddha:, athavA `mayA puna: dharmo’bhisambuddha:’ ityahaGkAra: samudbhavet tadA syAd `abhisambuddha:’ ityevaM viparItAbhinivezAt tathAgatasya vyAkaraNaM na bhavet | yato hi tadA `mayA’bhisambuddha:’ iti na bhavati, na ca dharmAdiSvapyabhiniveza: bhavati | tata evAham aviparItasamyagjJAnamArgasthitau vyAkRta: | nAsti sa kazcid dharmo’bhisambuddha: ityanena arthato dIpaGkarasyAntikAd avavAdagrAhavikalpaM vipakSatvena darzayitvA tadvikalpaprahANAya chanda: praNidhAnaM cApi dezitam | dIpaGkaretyupalakSaNamAtreNAbhihitena sarve dharmodgrahaNavikalpA nivartante | nAsti ityanena tasya gambhIratvamuktam, samyaksambodhaye avavAdaparyeSaNavidhAnena tAvadasyodAratvaM coktam, zrAvakapratyekabuddhAvavAdAd atyantaviziSTatvAt | @186 anAgate’dhvani zAkyamunirnAma tathAgato’rhan samyaksaMbuddha iti | yasmAttarhi subhUte, tathAgatenArhatA samyaksaMbuddhena nAsti sa kazcid dharmo yo’nuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha: | tasmAdahaM dIpaMkareNa tathAgatena vyAkRta:- bhaviSyasi tvaM mANava anAgate’dhvani zAkyamunirnAma tathAgato’rhan samyaksaMbuddha: | tatkasya heto: ? tathAgata iti subhUte bhUtatathatAyA etadadhivacanam | yadi tathAgatena samyaksambuddhena na syAt sa kazcid dharmo yo’nuttarAyAM samyaksambodhau abhisambuddha:, tadA kathaM tathAgatatvaM bhavet ? tadyathA pUrvabuddhA abhisambodhiM gatA:, tathaivAtrApi gatatvAdabhisambuddhastathAgata ucyata iti cet ? abhisambuddha ityAkyasya kasyacid dharmasyAbhAvAt tatkathaM bhavediti vicintya tatkasya heto: iti pRSThavAn | tathAgata iti subhUte ityAdi codatarat | tathatA iti dharmANAmaviparItasvabhAva ucyate, sa cAdizAntAdisvabhAva:, sarvadharmasAdhAraNatvAt sA bhUta: iti vacanena vizeSitA, bhUtastu {1. bhUtArthabhAvanAprakarSaparyantajaM yogijJAnaM ceti | -nyA. bi., 1/11|} yathArthatvena tathAgatajJAnamabhidhIyate | tasyAstathatAyA yA paramArthato’nutpannadharmatA sa tathAgata ityucyate | yathoktam-{2. ma. zA. vR., 22/16, pR. 195 (uddhRtam ha. kA. sU.), ##Toh: 207 Sde bka (Mdo Sde, Tsha p. 95.##} anutpAdadharma: satataM tathAgata: | iti | paramArthato dharmatA’pi dharmiNo netarA, ata: paramArthata: sarvadharmANAmanutpAdo dharmatA | sarvadharmAdhigamasvabhAvo’vicAraramaNIya: paramArthato’nutpanna: tathyasaMvRtau parikalpyamAna: sajjJAnaviziSTa: `tathAgata:’ {3. sa evamadhigatasarvajJajJAno bhagavAn yathA dharmANAM tattvaM vyavasthitaM tathaiva azeSato gatatvAd buddhatvAt tathAgata ityucyate | -ma. zA. vR., 22 adhyA., pR. 187 |} ucyata iti vAkyArtha: | tasya ca paramArthato’nutpannatvAnnAsti kazcid grAhyo grAhako vA | tasmAnnAsti kazcid dharmo’pyabhisambuddha: (nAma) paramArthata: | tathyasaMvRtimAzritya tena viziSTajJAnena yathA abhisambuddha: tathA gata ityevamabhiprAya: | @187 ya: kazcitsubhUte, evaM vadet- tathAgatenArhatA samyaksaMbuddhena anuttarA samyaksaMbodhirabhisaMbuddheti, sa vitathaM vadet | abhyAcakSIta mAM sa subhUte, asatodgRhItena | {1. idaM vAkyaM bhoTapAThe dege saMskaraNe nopalabhyate |} tatkasya heto: ? nAsti subhUte, sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatena anuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha: | yazca subhUte, tathAgatena dharmo’bhisambuddho dezito vA tatra na satyaM na mRSA | tasmAttathAgato bhASate sarvadharmA buddhadharmA iti | tatkasya heto: ? sarvadharmA iti subhUte, adharmAstathAgatena bhASitA: | tasmAducyante sarvadharmA buddhadharmA iti | paramArthAzrayeNAbhisambuddha iti kasmAttathA nocyate ? iti cintAyAM ya: kazcit subhUte ityAdyAha | tatkasya heto: ? iti na satyam ityanena yojyam | zeSastu sugamAnna vyAkhyAyate | evaM tarhi `saMvRtita: tathAgatena abhisambuddha:’ iti vyavasthaiva kathaM vyavasthApyata iti vicArya yazca dharma: ityuktam | ya: iti rUpAdilakSaNadharma:, tatra na satyam iti mAyAvatpratibhAsamAnAnAM vicAryamANAnAmatyantazUnyatvenAnutpannatvAt zazazRGgavad atyantAbhAva: | na mRSA avicAraramaNIyasvabhAvena mAyAvatpratibhAsamAnAt | athavA nApi satyam, na kasyApi dharmasya paramArthata: siddhe: | na mRSA, na ca vicAragocara: kazcit satya: siddha:, sarvadharmANAmanutpAdAt | anenAdhyAropApavAdAntau nirAkRtya madhyamamArgaM ca vyavasthApya yogasamApattau pravarttyate | tasmAt ityevaM paramArthata: sarvadharmANAmanutpAdAt na satyaM na ca mRSA | tathAgato’pi parizuddhyA’nutpAdadharmatayA prabhAvita:, anutpAdadharmatAyA: sAdhAraNatvAt, (tathA hi) {2. anutpAdadharma: satataM tathAgata: sarve ca dharmA: sugatena sAdRzA: | nimittagrAheNa tu bAlabuddhaya: asatsu dharmeSu caranti loke || tathAgato hi pratibimbabhUta: kuzalasya dharmasya anAsnavasya | naivAtra tathatA na tathAgato’sti bimbaM ca saMdRzyati sarvaloke || -ma. zA. vR., 22/16 (hasti. sU., prasannapadAyAmuddhRtam) pR. 195 darabhaMgA saMskaraNam 1983, ##See- Toh: 207 Sde bka (Mdo Sde. Tsha p. 95.##} anutpAdadharma: satataM tathAgata: @188 tadyathApi nAma subhUte, puruSo bhavedupetakAyo mahAkAya: ? AyuSmAn subhUtirAha yo’sau bhagavaMstathAgatena puruSo bhASita upetakAyo mahAkAya iti, akAya: sa bhagavaMstathAgatena bhASita: | tenocyate upetakAyo mahAkAya iti | sarve ca dharmA: sugatena sAdRzA: | nimittagrAheNa tu bAlabuddhaya: asatsu dharmeSu caranti loke || ityAdi | sarvadharmA buddhadharmA: iti tathAgato bhASate | yadyanutpannA evAmI dharmAstat kathaM sarvadharmA: ityucyanta iti pravicintya sarvadharmA iti subhUte ityAdyAha | ayamatrArtha:- paramArthatastathA vidyante, na tu vyavahAraprajJaptita: | asantastAvat paramArthato rUpAdidharmA:, kintvaparamArthaM khalvavicAritamAzritya yasmAt svasAmAnyalakSaNagrahaNaM tasmAt sarvadharmA: ityucyante, na tu paramArthata:, tatra sthitAnAM sarveSAM dRzyamAnatve’pyabhAvAt | anena tAvad vikSepanigraha: sandarzita: | 17. abhisamaya-sthAnam : yadi na syAt sa kazcid dharmo bhagavatA’bhisambuddha: kathaM (tarhi) bodhisattvA upAdattamavavAdaM sammukhIkRtya dharmapudgalanairAtmyadhigaccheyu: ? iti vicintyAbhisamayapratipAdanArthaM tadyathApi nAma ityAdyAha | ayamabhisamayastAvat jJAnaprAptinirabhimAnitAbhyAM saMdarzyate | kathaM jJAnaprAptyeti cet ? dvividhaM jJAnamAzritya, gotrasamparigrahajJAnaM samatAjJAnaJca | tatra yajjJAnaprAptyA tathAgatagotre samutpadya buddhagotre niyato jAyate tad gotrasamparigrahajJAnam | tadutpAdena upetakAyo bhavati | upeta ityAtmanA parigRhIta:, kAyastu tathAgatakAya: | yena so’dhigata:, sa upetakAya: | kathaM jJAyate tajjJAnaprAptirityAha–mahAkAya: iti | anena pudgaladharmanairAtmyasamatAjJAnaM samavApya abhisamaya: sampradarzyata ityato gotrajJAnamabhidhIyate | tena samatAjJAnena pudgaladharmanairAtmyamadhigamya sarve @189 bhagavAnAha-evametatsubhUte, yo bodhisattva evaM vadet-ahaM sattvAn parinirvApayiSyAmIti, na sa bodhisattva iti vaktavya: | tatkasya heto: ? asti subhUte, sa kazciddharmo yo bodhisattvo nAma ? subhUtirAha-no hIdaM bhagavan | nAsti sa kazciddharmo yo bodhisattvo nAma | bhagavAnAha- sattvA: sattvA iti subhUte, asattvAste tathAgatena bhASitA:, tenocyante sattvA iti | tasmAttathAgato bhASate-nirAtmAna: sarvadharmA ni:sattvA: nirjIvA niSpudgalA: sarvadharmA iti | sattvA Atmani (Atmavat) saGgRhItA bhavanti | tasmAt samastasattvakAyAnAmAtmani saGgraheNa sa mahAkAya iti | nApyapArthako’yaM zabda:, evaM sarvasattvAnAmAtma-saGgraheNa sa kAya ityucyate | teSAM saMbahulatve’pi na mahAkAyazabdArthatvam | anena sthAnasyAsya audAryaM samudIritam | ayamabhiprAya:- bodhisattvAnAmabhisamayo’pyayaM tathyasaMvRtimAzritya viziSTajJAnotpAdamAtreNa prabhAvito bhavati | paramArthato na kiJcinnirUpakaM nirUpyaM veti darzayitum, AryasubhUti:- bhagavaMstathAgatena puruSo bhavedupetakAya: ityAdyAha | anenArthatastAvadupetakAya-mahAkAyAbhinivezastu vipakSatvena nirdiSTa: | (ata:) tatprahANAya chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti darzitam | upetakAyo mahAkAya iti nimittamAtrAbhidhAnena bodhisattvAnAM sarvadharmeSvabhinivezo nivartate | paramArthe’pi tAvad vyavasthApya yogasamApattau cAvatAryate | gAmbhIryamapyuktam, samAropAnto’pi nirAkRta: | pUrveNa tAvadapavAdAnta: pratiSiddha: | yadi tathAgatena sa eva kAyo nokta: syAt tadA prAptAbhisamayo bodhisattva: `evaM mayA bodhisattvAbhisamaya: samprApta: sAmpratamahaM sattvAn parinirvApayiSyAmi’ ityetat kathaM saJcintyayedityanyadIyaM sadvikalpaM samudIkSya nirabhimAnitayA’bhisamayaM darzayituM yo bodhisattva: ityAdyAha | anena ya evaM vadet- ahaM sattvAn parinirvApayiSyAmIti `ahaM bodhisattvo’smi @190 ya: subhUte, bodhisattva evaM vadet- ahaM kSetravyUhAn niSpAdayiSyAmIti, so’pi tathaiva vaktavya: | tatkasya heto: ? kSetravyUhA: kSetravyUhA iti subhUte, avyUhAste tathAgatena bhASitA: | tenocyante kSetravyUhA iti | ya: subhUte, bodhisattvo nirAtmAno dharmA nirAtmAno dharmA- ityabhimAnI sa tathyato na bodhisattva: iti darzyate | tatkasya heto: ? ityatra jJApakahetu: paripRSTa: | dharma: iti tu rUpAdisvabhAvo vA pudgalAdisvabhAvo vA | yuktito vicAraNAyAM tasya dharmasyAdRSTatvAd AryasubhUtirapyAha no hIdam iti | tasyA yukte: sarvatra sAdhAraNatvAd bhagavAn nairAtmyadvayAvatAraNArthaM tasmAd ityAha | nisattvA: ityAdi tAvadupalakSaNam, ni:svabhAvA api draSTavyA: | anena vikSepanigraho nirdiSTa: | ukto’bhisamaya: | ata UrdhvaM buddhabhUme: paryeSaNam | tadapi buddhasya saptabhi: sampadbhi: saMgRhyate | sapta sampadazca- 1. kSetraparizuddhisampad 2. anuttaradRSTiparizuddhisampad 3. anuttarajJAnaparizuddhisampad 4. prAptapuNyaskandhAdhipatyasampad 5. kAyasampad 6. vAk-sampad 7. cittasampacca | 1. kSetraparizuddhisampad : tatra yadi na syAt kazcid bodhisattvo nAma dharma:, (tarhi) kastAvad buddhakSetraM pariniSpAdayituM yatnaM kuryAt ? ityAzaGkAM nirAkartuM buddhakSetraparizuddhisampadamadhikRtya- ya: subhUte bodhisattva: ityAdyAha | so’pi tathaiva vaktavya: ityabhimAnitvAnnocyate sa bodhisattva ityartha: | @191 ityadhimucyate sa tathAgatenArhatA samyaksaMbuddhena bodhisattvo bodhisattva{1. pro. jozImahodayena sampAdite saMskaraNe "bodhisattvo mahAsattva:” iti pATha:, kintu bhoTapAThe de. ge. saMskaraNe tu “bodhisattvo bodhisattva:” iti pATha upalabhyate yazca AcAryakamalazIlasya TIkAmanusarati | ataevAtra bhoTapATha eva gRhIta: |} ityAkhyAta: | pudgaladharmanairAtmyayoranadhigame’pyadhigatamityabhimAnAt | evamahamasmItyabhimAnAnna tasya pudgalanairAtmyAvagama:, na ca dharmanairAtmyAvabodha:, asatsu kSetravyUheSvapi tatrAbhimAnAt | anena kSetravyUheSu mAyopamatvAdhimuktyA bodhisattvena kathaM sthAtavyamityetad darzitam | yadi paramArthato na syuste kSetravyUhA: (tadA) bhagavatA kathamuktA iti vicintya tatkasya heto: ? ityAha | pUrvavadasya vyAkhyAnam | na ceyaM punarukti: | pUrvaM tAvadadhimukticaryAbhUmisthitAnAM bodhisattvAnAM bodhisattva- kSetraparizuddhau praNidhAnAvasthAyAM bodhisattvavikalpasya niSedhArtham (uktA:), samprati buddhakSetraparizuddhipariniSpattaye ye bodhisattvA evaMvidhenAbhinivezena pravartante, yeSAM caivaMvidho vikalpa:, tannirAkaraNArthamuktam | na cAnavasthAprasaGga:, tadaivaMvidhasya kasyaciditaravikalpasyAsambhavAt | aneneha bodhisattvena kathaM pratipattavyaM tad vyapadiSTam | kIdRzo bodhisattvo nAmetyatra ya: subhUte bodhisattva: ityAdyAha | nirAtmAno dharmA: iti dviruktayA dvividhena nairAtmyena sarvadharmANAM nairAtmyaM darzyate | bodhisattvo bodhisattva: iti dviruktyA tadeva dvividhaM nairAtmyajJAnaM darzyate | athavA ekastAvad bodhisattva: AvRtta:, bodhisattva ityAkhyAta: ityuttarastu (kathanasya) prakAra: | tena kiM darzayiSyata iti ced ? kena niSpAdyante yadi pudgalAdigrAhakAbhAva:, kSetravyUhA: iti dharmagrAhakasyApyabhAva:, ubhayAbhAvAdhigamena bodhisattva ityAkhyAta iti nirdiSTam | anena cittapragraho dezita: | ebhi: sarvai: sthAnai: gAmbhIryaM darzitam | tatra mAyAvadbuddhakSetrapariniSpAdanAdhimuktyA bodhisattvAnAM pravRttipradarzanenaudAryamuktam | @192 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte-saMvidyate tathAgatasya mAMsacakSu: ? subhUtirAha- evametadbhagavan, saMvidyate tathAgatasya mAMsacakSu: | bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, saMvidyate tathAgatasya divyaM cakSu: ? subhUtirAha- evametadbhagavan, saMvidyate tathAgatasya divyaM cakSu: | bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, saMvidyate tathAgatasya prajJAcakSu: ? subhUtirAha-evametadbhagavan, saMvidyate tathAgatasya prajJAcakSu: | bhagavAnAha-tatkiM manyase subhUte, saMvidyate tathAgatasya dharmacakSu: ? subhUtirAha- evametadbhagavan, saMvidyate tathAgatasya dharmacakSu: | bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, saMvidyate tathAgatasya buddhacakSu: ? subhUtirAha-evametadbhagavan, saMvidyate tathAgatasya buddhacakSu: | 2. anuttaradRSTiparizuddhisampad : yadi nAsti bodhisattvo nAma kazcid dharma:, tadA tathAgata: parizuddhadarzanena parizuddhajJAnena ca yukta eva na bhavet, tasya bodhisattvAdutpannatvAt, tasyAbhAve sa kathaM bhavatumarhati, ahetukatve nityasattvAdidoSA:,{1. de. ge. saMskaraNe tu. “nityasattvAdyarthadoSA:” iti pATha: |} tasmAd yasyAM saMnipatitatAyAM pariSadyevaM vikalpo bhavet, tasyA: kRte parizuddhaM darzanaM jJAnaJcetyanuttaradvayamadhikRtya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | pUrvata: bhagavato’bhiprAyaM gRhItvA AryasubhUtirapyAha- saMvidyate iti | anena paramArthata: bodhisattvo nAma sa kazcid dharmo na bhavati, tathApi saMvRtau puNyajJAnasambhAraM paripUrya parizuddhaMjJAnadarzanAbhyAM yastathAgato bhavati, (tena) avicAraramaNIyaskandhamAtrasya bodhisattvasyAstitvaM bhavatyeva | anyathA saMvRtAvapi yadi sa na bhavet tadA kastathAgato bhavedityevaM tAvat darzitam | tatra saMvidyate tathAgatasya prajJAcakSu: ityeva tAvannocyate, (api tu) viziSTaM vizuddhadarzanamabhidhAtuM cakSuSo vidyamAnatvaM darzitam | @193 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, yAvantyo gaMgAyAM mahAnadyAM vAlukA:, api nu tA vAlukAstathAgatena bhASitA: ? subhUtirAha- evametadbhagavan evametat sugata | bhASitAstathAgatena vAlukA: | bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, yAvatyo gaMgAyAM mahAnadyAM vAlukA:, tAvatya eva gaMgAnadyo bhaveyu:, tAsu yA vAlukA:, tAvantazca lokadhAtavo bhaveyu:, kaccidbahavaste lokadhAtavo bhaveyu: ? subhUtirAha-evametadbhagavan, evametat sugata, bahavaste lokadhAtavo bhaveyu: | bhagavAnAha- yAvanta: subhUte, teSu lokadhAtuSu samAsatazcaturvidhaM bhavati cakSu:- rUpagrAhakam, paramArthasatyagrAhakam, saMvRtisatyagrAhakam, sarvAkArajJeyagrAhakaM ca | rUpagrAhakamapi dvividham- karmaphalaM bhAvanAphalaJceti | paJcavidhaM cakSu: kramaza: - tatra sthUlaviSayatvAt prathamaM rUpagrAhakaM kathitam, paramArthavazena saMvRttijJAnaM parizuddhadhyatItyata: pUrvaM paramArthasatyagrAhakaM pazcAcca saMvRtisatyagrAhakamabhitamiti saGgacchate kramanirdeza: | pudgaladharmanairAtmyayo: saMvidyate prajJAcakSu:, saMvRtau dharmamAtrameva tAvadavabhAsate, na tu pudgala iti pudgalazUnye dharmamAtre dharmacakSu:, sarvajJeyAnAM sarvAkArajJAnaM tAvad buddhacakSurityucyate, anenedAnIM sAkSAtkRtya viharaNAt | tathyasaMvRtau paJcacakSuSAM dezanayoktaM vizuddhadarzanam | 3. anuttarajJAnaparizuddhisampad : vizuddhajJAnAbhidhAnArtham- tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | traikAlikA: cittacaitasAstAvaccittasantati: | tata: traikAlyaviSayatvena tadviSayAvabodho jJAnamityucyate, na tu darzanam | tadapi sarAgacittavItarAgacittetyAdinAnAvidha- saMklezavyavadAnabhAvena veditavyam | tAvanto lokadhAtava: ityupalakSaNam, anantalokadhAtvantarnihitasattvAnAM cittadhArAyA: parijJAnAt | tathAhi-saMvRtau tathAgatasya mAMsacakSurAdIni bhavanti, atastanniSpAdanArthaM bodhisattvena chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyam | anena tAvad vacanena sampaddvayaM paridIpitam | @194 sattvA:, teSAmahaM nAnAbhAvAM cittadhArAM prajAnAmi | tatkasya heto: ? cittadhArA cittadhAreti subhUte, adhAraiSA tathAgatena bhASitA, tenocyate cittadhAreti | tatkasya heto: ? atItaM subhUte, cittaM nopalabhyate | anAgataM cittaM nopalabhyate | pratyutpannaM cittaM nopalabhyate | tatkiM manyase subhUte, ya: kazcitkulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA imaM trisAhasramahAsAhasraM lokadhAtuM saptaratnaparipUrNaM kRtvA tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhya: samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, mAMsacakSurAdInyapi ekAnekasvabhAvAbhyAM vicAraNAyAmanupalabdhAnyeva | na hyarthAntarajJAnena grahaNaM yujyate, yathA pUrvaM vicAritam, evaM sati kathaM prajJAsyete tathAgatasya mAMsacakSurAdividyamAnatA cittadhArA ceti cittAzayaM viditvA tatkasya heto: ? ityAha | bodhisattvena kathamanayordvayorvizuddhayoryogasamApattyA pratipattavyam ? ityetadabhidhAtuM cittadhArA cittadhArA ityAdyAha | {1. tu^- ma. zA. vR., pR. 23-24, bau. bhA. pra. 1983 |} paramArthata: adhArA iti | svabhAvato’sattve’pi saMvRtimadhikRtyAha- tenocyate cittadhAreti iti | anyathA paramArthata: sarvavAggocarAtItatvAnna vaktuM zakSyata ityabhiprAya: | cittadhAretyupalakSaNam | mAMsacakSurAdInyapi cakSu:vabhAvarahitAnyeva uktAnIti kathanaM prakRtaM sAkSAnnoktam | atra kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyamiti tadabhidhAtumAha tatkasya heto: ? iti | adhAretyanena saha yojanIyam | atItAdInAM cittAnAM paramArthato’nutpannatvAd anupalambha: | sattve’pi grahaNAnupapattyA nAnupalambha: | tathA sati acittadhArAdezanamapi na bhavet, na cAnupalambhamAtreNa bhAvAnAM ni:svabhAvatvaM syAt | yathA traikAlikacittasya paramArthato’bhAvastathA pUrvamuktaM vakSyate ca | {2. tu^ cittaM hi subhUte, tathAgatena na atItaM upalabdhaM, na anAgataM na pratyupannaM upalabdhaM asattvAccittasya | -a. pra., pR. 132 |} cittoktirupalakSaNam, tato’tItAdimAMsacakSurAdInyapyanupalabdhAnyeva | atra adhArA ityAdibhi: padairgAmbhIryamuktam, zeSairaudAryam | @195 api tu sa kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA tato nidAnaM bahu puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAt ? subhUtirAha- bahu bhagavan, bahu sugata | bhagavAnAha- evametat subhUte, evametat | bahu sa kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA tato nidAnaM puNyaskandhaM{1. jozI saMskaraNe “puNyaskandham” iti pATha: nopalabhyate |} prasunuyAdaprameyamasaMkhyeyam | tatkasya heto: ? puNyaskandha: puNyaskandha iti subhUte, askandha: sa tathAgatena bhASita:, tenocyate puNyaskandha iti | {2. idaM vAkyaM bhoTapAThe de. ge. saMskaraNe ca nopalabhyate |} sacet subhUte, puNyaskandho’bhaviSyat, na tathagato’bhASiSyat puNyaskandha: | puNyaskandha iti | 4. prAptapuNyaskandhAdhipatyasampad : yadi nAsti traikAlikaM cittaM tadA puNyaskandho’pi na syAt, cittAzritatvAttasya | tata: tathAgatasya puNyaskandhAdhipatyasampadaM sampAdayituM kathaM bodhisattvo yatnaM kuryAditi vicintya puNyaskandhAdhipatyasampadamadhikRtya-tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | anena kulaputrovA kuladuhitA vA yo’ntazo ratnAdikaM bAhyavastu tyajati, so’pi (yadi) mahApuNyaskandhena yukto bhavati (tadA) kathaM na tathAgatasya asaMkhyeyAprameyakalpeSu duSkarAnekazatAnyabhyasyata: puNyaskandhAdhipatyaM syAdityevaM dezitam | ata eva paramArthato’satyapi puNyaskandhe saMvRtau sattvAd bodhisattvena tatra vazIbhAvaM niSpAdayituM chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamityAdarzitam | anenaudAryamapyuktam | kathaM na paramArthata: puNyaskandhasattvaM vyavasthApyata iti vicintya `bodhisattvenAtra kathaM pratipattavyam, kathaJca cittaM pragrahItavyam,’ ityubhayaM sandarziyituM sacet subhUte ityAdyAha | sacet iti `yadi’ ityartha: | na tathAgato’bhASiSyat iti paramArthato’bhidhAnaM nAcariSyat | anirdeze’pi tathA khyAyata ityabhiprAya: | yathA paramArthata: puNyaskandhasyAbhAvastathA prAgvarNita: | anena tathAgatasya puNyaskandhAdhipatyasampadaM pariniSpAdayituM prasthitena bodhisattvena paramArthatastadanupalambhena yogasamApattyA pratipattavyam | paramArthatastadAlambanAbhi- @196 tatkiM manyase subhUte, rUpakAyapariniSpattyA tathAgato draSTavya: ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | na rUpakAyapariniSpattyA tathAgato draSTavya: | tatkasya heto: ? rUpakAyapariniSpatti: rUpakAya- pariniSpattiriti bhagavan apariniSpattireSA tathAgatena bhASitA | tenocyate rUpakAyapariniSpattiriti | nivezaparihAreNa cittaM pragrahItavyam ityubhayaM dezitam, gAmbhIryamapyuktam | 5. kAyasampad: (a) rUpakAyasampad yadi puNyaskandho naiva syAt tadA tathAgatAnAM dvividhA kAyalakSaNasampad- anuvyaJjanakAyasampad, lakSaNakAyasampacca yA’nuttarapuNyenAbhinirvartayitumiSyate, sA naiva syAt, kAraNAbhAvAt | tasmAt tathAgatasya dvividhAM kAyasampadaM pariniSpAdayitaM kathaM bodhisattvairyatno’nuSTheya iti vicintayadbhyastathAgatasya rUpakAyasampadamadhikRtya- tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | rUpakAya: | ityanuvyajJjanakAyarUpeNa draSTavya: | lakSaNakAya: pazcAd vakSyate gobalivardanyAyena | tato’yamatrAryasubhUterAzaya:-yathA paramArthato’raskandha eva puNyaskandhastathA rUpakAyo’pyanutpanna eva | ata: paramArthata: na rUpakAyapariniSpattyA tathAgato draSTavya: ityucyate | {1 dra. –Aloka:, pR. 253 |} saMvRtau mAyAnirmitabuddhavad vidyata eva rUpakAya:, tata upapanna eva (tasya) puNyaskandhAdudbhava: | tasmAd bodhisattvena mAyAnirmitabuddhasya tathAvidharUpAdhimuktyA tatpratipattaye chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti dezitam | nApyatra punaruktitA | pUrvamadhimukticaryAbhUmau rUpakAyAptikAmatAkAle{2. dra^- prastutA TIkA, 3 sthAnam,} tathAgatapUjAsatkArakAle{3. dra^-prastutA TIkA, 11 sthAnam,} ca tathAvidho’bhiniveza: parivarjita:, samprati zuddhAdhyAzayabhUmau tathAgatarUpakAya- @197 bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase.. subhUte, lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: ? subhUtirAha-no hIdaM bhagavan | na lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: | tatkasya heto: ? yaiSA bhagavan lakSaNasaMpattathAgatena bhASitA, alakSaNasaMpadeSA tathAgatena bhASitA | tenocyate lakSaNasaMpaditi | bhagavAnAha- tatkiM manyase subhUte, api nu tathAgatasyaivaM bhavati- mayA dharmo dezita iti ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | sampadaM pariniSpAdayituM samprasthitasya bodhisattvasya rUpe’bhinivezo bhavatIti yAsAM prasiddhistAsAM pariSadAM durvikalpo nirAkRta ityuktatvAt | evaM tarhi tathAgatAnAM rUpakAya: kasmAd dezita iti vicintya tatkasya heto: ? ityapRcchat | na rUpakAyapariniSpattyA tathAgato draSTavya: ityanena yojanIyam | {1. dra^- Aloka:, pR. 253-54; samAdhi. sU. (tathAgatakAyanirdezaparivarta:)} nAsau tAvat sidhyati, avayavirUpeNa paramANusaJcayarUpeNa vA rUpasyAsiddhatvAd, yathA vicAritaM prAk | anena bodhisattvena kathaM pratipattavyam, tannirdiSTam | tena iti itthaM saMvRtau bhAva:, na tu zaviSANavat sarvathA’bhAva: | anena cApavAdAntaM parihRtya kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyam, (iti) etannirdiSTam | anena sarvasthAnena gAmbhIryaM pradarzitam | saMvRtau tathAgatasya rUpakAyasampadaM niSpAdayituM bodhisattvai: karaNIyAnAM yatnAnAM nidarzanena audAryamapi dIpitam | (ba) lakSaNakAyasampad : lakSaNakAyasampadamadhikRtya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | atra pUrvavat sarvamabhihitam | 6. vAksampad : yadi rUpakAyapariniSpattyA na tathAgato draSTavya iti cet, tadA dezanA’pi bhagavatA naiva bhavet, rUpakAyena saMgRhItatvAt tasyA: ? ato @198 na tathAgatasyaivaM bhavati- mayA dharmo dezita iti | bhagavAnAha- ya: subhUte evaM vadet- tathAgatena dharmo dezita iti, sa vitathaM vadet | abhyAcakSIta mAM sa subhUte, asatodgRhItena | tatkasya heto: ? dharmadezanA dharmadezaneti subhUte, nAsti sa kazciddharmo yo dharmadezanA nAmopalabhyate | bodhisattvaistathAgatasya vAksampadaM niSpAdayituM kathaM yatna: karttavya iti vicintayadbhyo vAksampadamadhikRtya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | paramArthato vAcya-vAcaka-vacanAnAmabhAvAt na tathAgatasyaivaM bhavati mayA dharmo dezita iti | anyathA viparyayAnna bhavet sarvajJa: | yathA vAcakA: AtmAdaya:, vAcyA bAhyAdhyAtmikA bhAvA:, vacanAni karaNarUpANi zabdasvabhAvAbhAvAtmakAni vA tathA vistareNa prAgevoktAni | sarve bhAvA: zUnyatvavyAptA: prAgeva pratipAditA: | saMvRtau vAcya-vAcaka-vacanAnAm avicAraramaNIyatvena vyavahAramAtra eva (te) bhavanti, na tu paramArthe | yadi vastutattvasyaivamabhidhAne’pi vyAmohena kecit paramArthatastrayANAM (teSAM) paramArthasattvaM kalpayeyustadA `kiM nu syAt’ iti vicintya ya: subhUte ityAdyAha | abhyAcakSIta ityabhyAlapet | kathaM tadabhUtamAlapituM zakyata iti vicAraNAyAmAha asatodgRhItena iti | viparItAbhinivezato vitathagrahaNAt tadabhUtamityartha: | anena tathAgatasya vAksampadi pravRttena bodhisattvena pratizrutkAdivajjJAtvA pravartitavyamiti, bodhisattvena kathaM sthAtavyamiti dezitam | yadi vacanAditrayamasat (tadA) pudgaladharmanairAtmyadezakena bhagavatA nAnApadavAkyAtmikeyaM dharmadezanA kathaM prasidhyati ? tasyAM satyAM tadabhidheyo vAcyo’pi syAdeva, yazca taddezako vAcaka:, so’pi bhavedeva | tadbalena trINyapi (vAcya-vAcaka-vacanAni) bhaveyuriti cintAyAM tatkasya heto: ? iti pRSTam | atra dharmadezanA ityudatarat | ayamabhiprAya:- paramArthata: dharmadezanAyAM satyAM (sA) svalakSaNasvabhAvA vA syAt sAmAnyalakSaNasvabhAvA vA | tatra na tAvat prathama: pakSa:, sarvaM pAramArthikaM svalakSaNaM tAvat pUrvameva vistareNa nirAkRtam | na ca dvitIyo’pi- @199 asati svalakSaNe AdhArasyAbhAvena kasyacidapyasattvAt | sAmAnyadravyatvAbhyupagame svalakSaNa eva saGgRhItaM syAditi tanniSedhena tasyApi niSedha eva | anyavyAvRttyA sAmAnyalakSaNamadhyAropitasvabhAvamiti parikalpite sati dharmadezanAyA nairarthakyatvena siddhasAdhanam | tasyA: (zabdAtmikAyA dezanAyA:) paramArthata: svalakSaNasattve’pi na yujyate tayA dharmadezanA | sphoTAdizabdasya nityasvabhAvasya parai: padatvena parikalpitasya kramAkramAbhyAmarthakriyAkAritvaM tAvad virudhyate, sarvasAmarthyApagatatvAccaitanyAdiSu kutrApi khalu naiva yujyate, akiMJcitkaratvena kathaM tad bhavet padam ? anityasyApi tAvat svalakSaNasya na yujyate padatvam, saGketakAle dRSTasya vyavahArakAle’nanvayAt | na hi yujyate anyasya saGketo’nyasya ca vyavahAra:, atiprasaGgAt | ata eva svalakSaNamapyabhidhAtuM na yujyate, ananvayAt | sAmAnyapadArthe’bhidheyatvenAbhyupagate sati abhidheyasvabhAvatvena tasya svalakSaNasvarUpatvAnna hi pradezAntaragamanam | ekatvaM tu dezakAlAdibhinnAsvanekavyaktiSvanugatamapi na yujyate {1. nityamekamanekAnugatam sAmAnyam | tarka saMgra., pR. (sAmAnyalakSaNam)} tathA hi- (atha) ekasyAM vyakttau sarvAtmanA vyAptaM syAt tadA yena ekatvena parikalpita: sa svabhAvastena anyatrAdhigatetaravyaktibhi: sambaddha: taditarasvabhAvastatra na bhavediti, ekatvahAniprasaGgAt | (atha) ekadezena vyAptaM syAt tadA sAvayatvAgrahaNadoSa: | evaM yAvatyo bhinnavyaktayastAsAmekadezena vyAptivyavasthayA tAvatInAM grahaNaM syAttadA ekavyaktigrahaNaM tAvadekadezagrahaNena yuktaM bhavet, bhinnavyaktiSu dezakAlaparimANAdibhinnAsu tAsvekavyaktigrahaNaM tAvadekadezagrahaNAd yugapadgrahaNAbhAva eva | tasmAd vAcya-vAcakatvaM tAvadadhyAropeNaiva yujyate, na tattvata: | ata evoktaM bhagavatA’nyatra{2. ta. saM. paM. pR. 339. (uddhRtaM bhavasaMkrAntisUtram) ; api ca tulanIyam- yasya yasya hi zabdasya yo yo viSaya ucyate | sa sa saMghaTate naiva vastUnAM sA hi dharmatA || -ta. saM. 869 kA. |} yena yena hi nAmnA vai yo yo dharmo’bhilapyate | @200 evamukte AyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavantametadavocat- asti bhagavan kecitsattvA bhaviSyantyanAgate’dhvani pazcime kAle pazcime samaye pazcimAyAM paJcazatyAM saddharmavipralope vartamAne, ya imAnevaMrUpAn na sa saMvidyate tatra dharmANAM sA hi dharmatA || vacanaM mithyA, vAcya-vAcyakAnAM yA dezanA taddvArA{1. taddvArA iti vaktRdvArA ityartha: | tenocyate- vaktRJcAparavaktRJca sAzvAsattvaJca bhedakam | cinhamAkhyAyikAyAzcetprasaGgena kathAsvapi || -kAvyAdarza:, 13 zloka |} AgatA, sA’pi spaSTaiva | ubhayorabhAvo bhagavatA pRthakatvena nokta: | anena bodhisattvena kathaM pratipattavyam, kathaJca cittaM pragrahItavyamityetad darzitam | etena sarveNa gAmbhIrya darzitam | 7. saptadhA cittasampada: - 1. smRtyupasthAnam 2. abhisambodhi: 3. mahAdharmArthaprajJapti: 4. mahAvavAdArthaprajJapti: 5. dharmakAyaparigrahaNam 6. saMsAre nirvANe cApratiSThAnam 7. prasthiti-pArizuddhi: | 1. smRtyupasthAnam : tatredAnImevaM gambhIradharmo’yamanAgate kAle ghanIbhUte kudRSTijAle kathaM saphalo bhaviSyatIti nAbhizraddhadhanti parivArA: | ya evaM cintayanti teSAmavizrambhaM nivArayitum AryasubhUtizcittasampatsu smRtyupasthAnamadhikRtya bhagavan ityAdyAha | bhagavatA’pyanAgate’dhvani zIlavanto guNavantazca bhaviSyantIti kiM noktapUrvam | samprati teSAM sattve’sattve vA ekAntenAnabhinivezaM dezayitum asti iti noktam, antadvayaniSedhArthaM te subhUte ityAdyAha | @201 dharmAn zrutvA abhizraddhAsyanti ? bhagavAnAha- na te subhUte, sattvA nAsattvA: | tatkasya heto: ? sattvA: sattvA iti subhUte, asattvAste{1. pro. jozI saMskaraNe “asattvAstathAgatena” iti pATha: | bhoTapAThe de. ge. saMskaraNe tu “asattvAste tathAgatena” iti pATha upalabhyate | TIkAnusAraM bhoTapATha evaM zuddhastena atrApi bhoTapATha eva udgRhIta: |} tathAgatena bhASitA: | tenocyante sattvA iti | tatkiM manyase subhUte- api nu asti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatenAnuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha: ? AyuSmAn subhUtirAha- paramArthata: skandhapudgalAdInAM satsvabhAvAnupalambhAt na sattvA: ityanenAdhyAropAntaniSedha:, avicAraikaramaNIyatvena sadaiva vidyamAnatvena nAsattvA: ityanenApavAdAntaniSedha: | bhaviSyanti ityanayA dezanayA bhagavata: kIdRgaviparItasmRtyupasthAnamiti sattvebhyo darzayitvA bhagavatastasyAM smRtyupasthAnasampadi bodhisattvena chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti nirdiSTam | na te sattvA: nAsattvA: {2. ayaM pATha: pekiMgasaMskaraNamanuvartate, de. ge. saMskaraNe tu ‘na te sattvA:’ ityevaM pATha: |} ityanena yogasamApattinirdiSTA | yadi na te sattvA: syustadA kathaM bhagavatA `bhaviSyantyanAgate’dhvani zIlavanto guNavantazca te’{3. dra.- vajra. sU. 6 adhyA.|} ityAdyuktamityevaM parivitarka vicAryaM tatkasya heto: ? ityapRcchat | asattvAste bhASitA: iti paramArthato’sattvA eva, saMvRtisatskandhasadbhAvamAzritya bhASitAste | saMvRtau sattvAt tenocyante sattvA iti | anyathA saMvRtAvapyasattve na (te) bhASitA: syurityanena cittapragraho darzita: | sarveNa tAvadanena gAmbhIryamuktam | sarvasattvebhyo bhagavatA’pratihatasmRtyupasthAnadezanAt tAvadaudAryaM nirdiSTam | 2. abhisambodhi: yadi na syAd bhagavata: kAcidapi dharmadezanA, tadA na syAt (sa:) samyaksambuddho’pi, tatastathAgatAbhisambodhisiddhaye vyartha: syAd bodhisattvAnAM yatna: | yato’bhisambuddharmA iSyante, ato dezanA’pi bhavatIti manvAnebhya:- @202 no hIdaM bhagavan | nAsti sa kazciddharmo yastathAgatenAnuttarAM samyaksaMbodhimabhisaMbuddha: | bhagavAnAha- evametatsubhUte, evametat | aNurapi tatra dharmo na saMvidyate nopalabhyate | tenocyate anuttarA samyaksaMbodhiriti | api tu khalu puna: subhUte, sama: sa dharmo na tatra kiMcidviSamam | tenocyate anuttarA samyaksaMbodhiriti | tebhyo’bhisambodhim adhikRtya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | AryasubhUti: pUrvAbhiprAyaM gRhItvA nAsti sa: ityudatarat | tadevaM manyate- paramArthAbhiprAyeNa bhagavatA dharmadezanA pratiSiddheti | yathA paramArthata: kasyAzcidapi dharmadezanAyA abhAva: (tathA) abhisambuddhasyApyabhAva:, etat pUrvaM nirdiSTam | saMvRtita: bhagavato dharmadezanA, sambodhi:, taddhetupratipattizcApi vidyanta eva, tasmAd bodhisattvenAnuttarasamyaksambodhestathyasaMvRtisvabhAvAyA: sAdhanArthaM yatna: karaNIya: | anena bodhisattvena kathaM sthAtavyamiti darzitam | pUrvamavavAdaparyeSaNakAle{1. dra.- vajra.sU. 17 adhyA. ; prastutA TIkA, 16 sthAnam |} bodhisattvAnAM `abhisambodhi: paramArtha:’ iti yo vikalpa:, sa apanodita:, idAnIM buddhabhUmiparyeSaNakAle pareSAM tAdRgvikalpanirAkaraNAnna bhavati punaruktidoSa: | bhagavatA anuttarA samyaksambodhistathyasaMvRtau vyavasthApitA, sA kIdRzIti atra aNurapi ityAdyAha | yatra jJAnaM pracarati (tatra) bhagavatA grAhyasvarUpasya svalakSaNasya sUkSmo’pi dharmasvabhAvo nopalabdha:, sa tAvat samastadharmanairAtmyAvabodhasvarUpA anuttarA samyaksambodhi: | tairthika-zaikSAzaikSajJAnAcchreSThatvena ‘anuttarA’ | sarvabhAvAnAM tathatAyA yathAvadadhigamasvabhAvatvena ucyate samyaksambodhirityartha: | tatra sarvadharmANAmanupalabdhiheto: “na” ityuktam | yato hyasattvaM tato’nupalambha: | vidyamAnatve nAnupalabdhi:, satsu sarvadharmeSu tathAgatasya AlambanajJAnasyaiva jJApakatvAt | anena dharmanairAtmyAvabodhasvabhAvo nirdiSTa: | @203 nirAtmatvena ni:sattvatvena nirjIvatvena niSpudgalatvena samA sA anuttarA samyaksaMbodhi: sarvai: kuzalairdharmairabhisaMbudhyate | tatkasya heto: ? kuzalA dharmA: kuzalA dharmA iti subhUte, adharmAzcaiva te tathAgatena bhASitA: | tenocyante kuzalA dharmA iti | yazca khalu puna: subhUte, strI vA puruSo vA yavantastrisAhasramahAsAhasre lokadhAtau sumerava: parvatarAjAna:, tAvato rAzIn saptAnAM ratnAnAmabhisaMhRtya tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhya:- sAmprataM pudgalanairAtmyAvabodhasvabhAvaM pratipAdayituM api tu khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | sama: sa dharma: iti tadavabodhiteSu sarvadharmeSu pudgalanairAtmyasAmyAt | na tatra kiJcidviSamam iti sarvatra tadaviparyayAt, AtmagrAhahetorbhAvAbhinivezasya prahINatvAt | bhagavatA tAvadAtmagrAha: savAsana: prahINa: | tena saiva pudgalanairAtmyajJAnasvabhAvA sambodhi:, anuttarA samyaksambodhirityucyate, nAnyA | kena rUpeNa sama: sa dharma ityatra ni:sattvatvena ityAdyAha | anena sarveNa kathaM yogasamApattyA pratipattavyamiti tannirdiSTam | sA kathamabhisambuddhyata ityAha kuzalairdharmai: iti | sA puNyajJAnasambhArAtmakai: kuzalairdharmairabhisambuddhyata ityartha: | yadyasattvAd aNurapi dharmo nopalabhyeta, kathaM nAma bhaveyu: kuzalA dharmA: ? yatastairabhisambuddhyate’ta: kuzalA dharmA: ityAdyAha | paramArthAstu adharmA eva | saMvRttau sattvAt kuzalA dharmA: ityuktam | tasmAt kuzalerdharmairabhisambudhyata ityatra nAsti doSa: | anena adhyAropApavAdAntagrAha- vikSepanirAkaraNena cittapragraho nirdiSTa: | etai: sarvai: sthAnai: gAmbhIryamapi sandarzitam | azeSapudgaladharmanairAtmyAvabodharUpasya samyaksambodhisvabhAvasya paridIpanena audAryamapi darzitam | 3. mahAdharmArthaprajJapti: bhagavata: sA samyaksambodhi: kathaM veditavyA ? iti vicAryamANe mahArthadharmatayA prajJApitatvena tatsattAM darzayituM yazca khalu puna: subhUte- @204 samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, yazca kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA ita: prajJApAramitAyA dharmaparyAyAdantazazcatuSpAdikAmapi gAthAmudgRhya parebhyo dezayet, asya subhUte puNyaskandhasya asau paurvaka: puNyaskandha: zatatamImapi kalAM nopaiti, yAvadupaniSadamapi na kSamate | tatkiM manyase subhUte- api nu tathAgatasyaivaM bhavati- mayA sattvA: parimocitA iti ? na khalu puna: subhUte, evaM draSTavyam | tatkasya heto: ? nAsti subhUte, kazcitsattvo yastathAgatena parimocita: | ityAdyAha | sumerava: parvatarAjAna: ityupalakSaNam | anantalokadhAtUn ratnai: paripUrya dAnena yat puNyaM tadapi upamAM naiva kSamate | ita: prajJApAramitAyA: ityupalakSaNamAtraparidIpanena sakalo mahAyAnadharma: parilakSito bhavati | yAvad iti vacanena sahasratamI kalA- `zatasahasratamI kalA ... upamA- aupamyamityetAni, saMgRhyante | {1. dra.- vajra. sU. 16 adhyA.; tu.- a. pra., pR. 36,80, evaM Aloka:, pR. 367 |}evaM mahArthadharmaprajJapanena hetunA bhagavatazcittasampada: samyaksaMbodhe: Anuttaryamavagamyate, tathAvidhasamyaksaMbodhim antarA tathAvidhadharmadezanAyA azakyatvAt | tasmAdetAdRkcittasampatsampAdane chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyam | sakalenAnena kathaM sthAtavyaM bodhisattveneti nirdizyate, anenaivaudAryamapyabhihitam | sA ca sambodhi: tathyasaMvRtisvabhAvA draSTavyA, na tu paramArthata:, prAgevoktatvAt, sAkSAdanuktamapi sAmarthyata: yogasamApatti:, cittapragraha: gAmbhIryaM ca nirdiSTam | 4. mahAvavAdArthaprajJapti: bhagavato lokottarajJAnAvasthAyAM sattvasaMjJA sarvathA na pravartate, {2. sattvasaMjJA ca te nAtha sarvathA na pravartate | -catu:stava: 1/9, (niraupamya stava:)} atyantasamAhitatvAt, ado nAzcaryam | sattvebhyo vimuktyupadeza- kAle’samAhitAvasthAyAM vizuddhalaukikajJAnAvasthAyAmapi sattvAdisaMjJA na pravartata iti tannirdizya avavAdamahArthatvena prajJaptihetunA bhagavato’nuttaracittasampadaM @205 yadi puna: subhUte, kazcitsattvo’bhaviSyadyastathAgatena parimocita: syAt, sa eva tathAgatasyAtmagrAho’bhaviSyat sattvagrAho jIvagrAha: pudgalagrAho’bhaviSyat | AtmagrAha iti subhUte, agrAha eSa tathAgatena bhASita: | sa ca bAlapRthagjanairudgRhIta: | bAlapRthagjanA iti subhUte ajanA eva te tathAgatena bhASitA: | tenocyante bAlapRthagjanA iti | pratipatsyamAnAM darzayituM mahArthAvavAdamadhikRtya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | praznasyottaramapratIkSamANa: sapadi svata: na khalu puna: subhUte, evaM draSTavyam ityAdyAha | tasmAd bhagavatazcittasampadastAdRze mahArthAvavAdahetau bodhisattvena chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti nirdiSTam | kiM sattvAnAM sattve’pi saMklezahetubhUtatayA tathA nAbhipreyate tathAgatena ? Ahosvit sattvAbhAvAditi cintayatAmAzayaM vijJAya tatkasya heto: ? iti papraccha | skandhAtmakasya pudgalAtmakasya ca kasyacit sattvasya paramArthato’bhAvAd evaM nopalabhyata iti darzayitumAha- nAsti kazcit sattvo yastathAgatena parimocita: iti | anena bodhisattvai: kathamatra yogasamApattyA pratipattavyamiti tannirdiSTam | abhAva: kathaM jJAtavya ityatra yadi puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | ayamatrAbhiprAya: - yathAjJeyaM tathAgatasya jJAnaM pravartate, anyathA aprahINAvaraNatvena kathaM syAt tathAgatatvam | tasmAd yadi sattva: syAt tadA sandRzyeta sa tathAgatena, Atmana: pratyakSopalabdhatayA vicikitsA’bhAvAt | sa eva tAvattasya pragADh+a AtmagrAha: syAt | tatazca AtmagrAhahetuta: samutpannaM nikhilaklezajAlabandhanamapyatidRDh+aM syAt tadA rAgAdyatipragADhabaddhasya AvaraNAprahANena bhagavata: tathAgatapadaprAptirna syAt | bhagavatA ca tatpadaM prAptam, ata: prahINasakalAvaraNa: sa: | prahINAvaraNayA azeSa AtmagrAhazikharI vizIryate, tasmAt sattvAbhAvo na jJAyate | Atmanyasati kimAtmadRSTilakSaNa AtmagrAho na bhavati ? kimarthaM bhagavatA AtmAdisaMjJA nocyate ? ityatra AtmagrAha iti subhUte ityAdyAha | yadi (bhagavatA) AtmAdivastuna eva grahaNaM syAttadA prahINAvaraNasya tasya bhagavata @206 tatkiM manyase subhUte- lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: ? subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan | yathAhaM bhagavato bhASitasyArtham AjAnAmi, na lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: | AtmagrAha: samudbhavet, kasyApyAtmagrAhasyAbhAvAt agrAha eSa tathAgatena bhASita: | atha kIdRza AtmagrAha iti ? sa ca ityAdyAha | zravaNAdivirahAd heyopAdeyayoranabhijJatvAd bAlA:, {1. sAMklezikadharmayogAd bAlA: | -Aloka:, pR. 325; dra. – Aloka:, pR. 302 |} prekSAvattvaviyogAd Aryebhya: pRthaktvAcca pRthagjanA: |{2. vaiyavadAnikadharmavirahAt pRthagjanA: | -Aloka:, pR. 325; dra.- Aloka:, pR. 302} pRthagjanA api kecit sacchAstraM zrutvA yonizomanaskArasthitA: dharmanairAtmyAdhimuktA: satyamabhinivizante, tadanAtmagrAhavyavacchedato bAlA ityAha | bAlamAtrakathanAt skandhAdyabhijJA api tAdRzA: pRthagjanA anupajAtAryamArgatayA bAlA eva | bAlAnAM vaiziSTyamabhidhAtuM vyAvRtte’pyAtmagrAhe bAlatvena teSvAtmagrAha ityavabhAsate, tasmAttadAzayavazAd AtmagrAha ityevaM nirdiSTam | na tanmAtreNa satyam, atiprasaGgAt | anAtmazabdaprayogeNApi kathaM nAtmAdInAM satyagrahaNam, yadyAtmA na syAttadA ke tAvat pRthagjanA abhidhIyeran ? iti vicintya bAlapRthagjanA: ityAdyuktam | paramArthatastu ajanA eva, saMvRtimAzrityoktatvAnna doSa: | ebhi: sarvairadhyAropApavAdAntanirAkaraNena cittapragRhItatvaM darzitam | anena sarveNa tAvat sAkSAd gAmbhIryaM proktam | azeSasattvadhAtubhyo mahArthAvavAdaprajJapterhetutvadarzanena cittasampada audAryamapi nirdiSTam | 5. dharmakAyaparigrahaNam : yadi bAlapRthagjanA: na syu:, kathaM tathAgatasya lakSaNAnuvyaJjanairalaGkRtA: kAyasampada: sambhaveyu: ? pRthagjanA: svakaruNAmUlakabodhicittamutpAdya pAramitAsu prayatante(tatazca) lakSaNAdibhiralaGkRtAstathAgatakAyasampattivanto bhavanti, tadabhAve mUlAbhAvAt kathaM bhaveyu: tAdRzyastathAgatakAyasampada iti ? ye pAriSadyA: - @207 bhagavAnAha- sAdhu sAdhu subhUte, evametatsubhUte, evametadyathA vadasi | na lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: | tatkasya heto: ? sacetpuna: subhUte, lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavyo’bhaviSyat, rAjApi cakravartI tathAgato’bhaviSyat | tasmAnna lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: | AyuSmAn subhUtirbhagavantametadavocat-yathAhaM bhagavato bhASitasyArthamAjAnAmi, na lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgato draSTavya: | kRtAnalpavikalpA: rUpAdiSu bhAvAbhinivezenaivaM cintayanti, tebhyo dharmakAyaparigrahamadhikRtya tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | pUrvaM{1. dra.- vajra. sU., 5 adhyA. |} dharmakAyatayA na vyavasthApitam, idAnIM dharmakAyaM vyavasthApayitumuktatvAnna punaruktidoSa: | lakSaNasampadA tAvat paramArthavicAraNAyAmavayavina: paramANusaMghAtasya vA svabhAvenAnupapattiM viditvA pUrvakamevAbhiprAyaM gRhNan subhUtirAha no hIdam | evameva upapattyantaraM bhagavatA sacet puna: subhUte ityAdinoktam | yadi tathAgato lakSaNasampanmAtreNa prabhAvita: syAt tadA vakSyamANahetunA tulyatvAd rAjApi cakravartI kathaM na bhavet tathAgata: ?{2. na caiva rUpakAyena so’numeyastathAgata: | dharmakAyo yatazcakravartI mAbhUttathAgata: || -tri. pra. kA. 62 kA. |} nanu sthAnasthottaptapUrNatvena viziSTA bhagavato lakSaNasampad, {3. “dezasthottaptapUrNatvairlakSaNAtizayo mune: |” dezasthatarANi buddhAnAM lakSaNAni, uttaptatarANi, sampUrNatarANi ca – ityeSa teSAM vizeSa: | - abhi. ko. 3/96, pR. 553, bau. bhA. pra. 1987 ; dra. – Aloka:, pR. 299 |} na tu cakravartina:, tata: sa nocyate tathAgata ityapi na yujyate, sthAnasthAdivizeSasyApi jaDasvabhAvatve nAsti kazcid vizeSa: | tena yadi tathAgato jaDasvabhAvairlakSaNAdidharmai: prabhAvito’bhaviSyat tadA cakravartI api tathAgato’bhaviSyat iti cet ? na, tasmAttathAgatastAvad azeSavastusvabhAvasya yathAvadadhigamamAtreNa prabhAvita ityabhiprAya: | anena tathAvidhaM jJAnahetukaM tathAgatakAyaM prati bodhisattvena chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti nirdiSTam | adhunA paramArthatastattathAgatajJAne’pi nAbhiniveSTavyamiti darzayituM dharmakAyo @208 atha khalu bhagavAMstasyAM velAyAmime gAthe abhASata- ye mAM rUpeNa cAdrAkSurye mAM ghoSeNa cAnvayu: | mithyAprahANaprasRtA na mAM drakSyanti te janA: ||1|| dharmato buddhA draSTavyA dharmakAyA hi nAyakA: | dharmatA ca na vijJeyA na sA zakyA vijAnitum ||2|| vyavasthApyate | bodhisattvena kathaM yogasamApattyA pratipattavyamiti dvAbhyAM gAthAbhyAM pradarzyate | tatra pUrvagAthayA kathaM tathAgato na draSTavya:, kaizca na dRzyata etannirdiSTam | kathaM na draSTavya iti cet ? darzanAdivyavahAraprajJaptyA | ke na pazyantIti cet ? mithyAprahANaprasRtA: | rUpeNa cAdrAkSu: ityanena rUpe’bhiniviSTA: pudgalA pAramArthikalakSaNAdibhiralaGkRtaM dharmarUpaM pudgalarUpaM ca pazyantIti vyavahAraprajJaptirnidiSTA | ghoSeNa cAnvayu: iti mAM zabdena evameva sa tathAgata iti jJAtavanta ityartha: | anena zravaNavyavahAraprajJaptirnidiSTA | upalakSaNamAtramimau vyavahArau | tena vizeSabhedo vijJAnaM cApi saMgRhItam | mithyAprahANaprasRtAste janA: tAvad vitathamArgasthitatvAnna mAM samyag rUpeNa drakSyanti |{1. rUpAnuzravamAtreNa na buddhajJa: pRthagjana: | tathatAdharmakAyo hi yato’vijJAnagocara: || -tri. pra. kA., 64 kA. |} prahIyate’neneti prahANaM mArga ityucyate, tacca viparItatvAnmithyA | tadapyadarzanahetu: | atha kathaM buddhA draSTavyA ityatra dharmata: ityAdyAha | dharmANAM yo hyakRtrima: svabhAva:, sa `dharmatA’ ityucyate | sA ca yuktyAgamAbhyAM siddhatvAdAdita: zAntAdisvabhAvA | saiva tathatA, dharmadhAtu:, bhUtakoTi:, animittaM paramArthazcetyAdiparyAyairucyate | {2. dra.-Aloka:, pR. 253 ; bo. ca., 9/2, pR. 171. mi. saM. |} sarvatra tathAbhAvAt `tathatA’, tadAlambanena sarve buddhadharmA: sambhavanti taddhetubhUtatvAd `dharmadhAtu:’ | aviparItatvAd bhUta:, tatparyantatvAd bhUtakoTi: @209 tatkiM manyase subhUte, lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgatena anuttarA samyaksaMbodhirabhisaMbuddhA ? na khalu punaste subhUte, evaM draSTavyam | tatkasya heto: ? na hi subhUte, lakSaNasaMpadA tathAgatena anuttarA samyaksaMbodhirabhisaMbuddhA syAt | tatra nIlAdisarvavastunimittAnAmabhAvAd animittaM | paramasya jJAnasya gocaratvAt paramArtha: | kimiti sA dharmatayA draSTavyetyatrAha- dharmakAyA: iti | {1. dharmakAyA buddhA bhagavanta: | mA khalu punarimaM bhikSava: satkAyaM kAyaM manyadhvam | dharmakAyapariniSpattato mAM bhikSavo drakSyatha, eSa ca tathAgatakAyo bhUtakoTiprabhAvito draSTavyo yaduta prajJApAramitA | -a. pra., 4 adhyA., pR. 48 ; na tathAgato rUpakAyato draSTavya: | dharmakAyAstathAgatA: | -a. pra., 31 adhyA., pR. 253 |} svabhAvArtha: kAyazabda ucyate | tenAyamartha: - samyagjJAnanibandhanA ye tathAgateSu vyavasthApitAste paramArthato dharmasvabhAvA: | yo yatsvabhAva:, sa tatsvabhAvena draSTavya:, na tvanyasvabhAvena | yadyevaM tarhi dharmatA prakAzasvabhAvA bhavet, anyathA kathaM tallakSitAste draSTuM zakyanta iti vicArya dharmatA ityAdyAha | kimazakyatvAd aparijJeyA athavA parijJAne doSasadbhAvAditi vicintya na zakyA ityAdyAha | dharmisvabhAve siddhe taddharmatA vijJAtuM zakyate, yadA dharmisvabhAva eva kazcit paramArthato na siddhastadA kathaM sA dharmatA’pi vijJAtuM zakyate kevalayA svasantatyA | nAsti sA kevaletyabhiprAya: | yadyevaM samyagjJAnasvabhAvAnAM buddhAnAmapi dharmiNAM paramArthato’siddhatvAnna syAd darzanam, tatkathaM dharmatA draSTavyeti cet ? naiSa doSa: | ye paramArthata: sarvadharmiNo na pazyanti ta eva dharmatAM pazyanti | dharmatA tAvadanutpannasvabhAvA, sA kathaM tadviparItotpAdagrahaNena grAhyA, na hi ghaTagrahaNena tadanutpAdagrahaNam | anena tathAgato na rUpakAyena draSTavya:, api tu dharmakAyena draSTavya ityetannirdizyate | asatyapi tathAgatasya lakSaNasampatsvabhAvatve yujyata eva lakSaNasampaddhetukaM tathAgatasyAnuttarasamyaksambodhilakSaNam, gaNakai: (lakSaNajJai:) bodhisattvasya lakSaNasampadaM draSTvA bhagavAn anuttarasamyaksambodhau vyAkRta iti @210 na khalu punaste subhUte, kazcidevaM vadet- bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitai: kasyaciddharmasya vinAza: prajJapta ucchedo veti | na khalu punaste subhUte, evaM draSTavyam | tatkasya heto: ? na bodhisattvayAna- saMprasthitai: kasyaciddharmasya vinAza: prajJapto noccheda: | yeSAM saMzaya:, tatparihArArthaM tatkiM manyase subhUte ityAdyAha | yadi lakSaNasampad anuttarasamyaksambodherhetu: syAt tadA cakravartino’pi syAdityabhiprAya: | gaNakaistAvat tathAvidhaM lakSaNamAtraM draSTvA vyAkRtam, na tu hetumityadoSa: | anena cittapragrahItatvaM nirdiSTam | anena tAvat sakalena sthAnena gAmbhIrya darzitam | saMvRtau cAzeSavastusvabhAvAdhimagalakSaNasya tathAgatajJAnasya nirdezena audAryamapi nirdiSTam | 6. saMsAre nirvANe cApratiSThAnam : (a) nirvANe’pratiSThAnam paramArthata: sarvadharmANAmabhAvAd yadi sA dharmatA vijJAtuM na zakyata iti cet tata ucchedavAdI bhavAn syAt | tatazca tathAgatasyApyabhAvAd apratiSThitanirvANamapi na sidhyatIti yadAzaGkitaM tadarthaM saMsAranirvANayo: apratiSThAnamadhikRtya subhUte ... evaM ... bodhisattvayAnasamprasthitai: ... ityAdyAha | na ca bhUtavinAzo’pi prajJapta:, {1. bhAvamabhyupapannasya naivocchedo na zAzvatam | udayavyayasantAna: phalahetvorbhava: sa hi |. -ma. zA., 21/15 |} dharmatAyA yathAvadavabodhAt | ata eva coktam{2. abhi. a., 5/21 |} - nApaneyamata: kiJcit prakSeptavyaM na kiJcana | draSTavyaM bhUtato bhUtaM bhUtadarzI vimucyate || anAgate dharmapravRttipratibandhakatvena ucchedo’pi na prajJapta:, yathAbhUtadharmatAyA dezanAt | sarve dharmA avicAraramaNIyatayA yathAbhUtai: pratyayairutpadyamAnA abhyupeyante, ato bhagavatA buddhena tathyasaMvRtisvabhAvAyA: mahAkaruNAyA nirmANAdau adhipatitvamAdAya punarvineyebhyo yathAvadupAyopadarzanena @211 yazca khalu puna: subhUte, kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA gaGgAnadIvAlukA samAllokadhAtUn saptaratnaparipUrNaM kRtvA tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhya: samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, yazca bodhisattvo nirAtmakeSvanutpattikeSu dharmeSu kSAntiM pratilabheta, ayameva tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasavedaprameyamasaMkhyeyam | niravacchinnasaMsArapravAho’bhyupeyate | anena bhagavato nirvANe’pratiSThitatvaM nirdiSTam | tathAvidhe bhagavatkAye chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti tadapi nirdiSTam | (ba) saMsAre’pratiSThAnam : yadyevaM bhagavAn saMsArapravRttimabhyupaiti, tadA saMsartA eva bhavatIti vikalpya saMsAre’pratiSThitatvaM darzayituM yazca khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | nirAtmakeSu iti mAyAvat paratantratvAt, na svata AtmabhAva:, nityasya kramAkramAbhyAM hetorvirodhAt, ahetukasya akiJcitkaratvAt | svaparayornAdhiSThAnamapi, adhiSThAturevAsambhavAt, tasmAt sarvadharmAste ubhayavidhA: nirAtmakA: | yathoktam{1. abhi. ko. 3/28, pR. 462, (uddhRtam) bau. bhA. pra. 1887 |} “AtmA Atmeti bhikSavo bAlo’zrutavAn pRthagjana: prajJaptimanupatita:, na tvatrAtmA vA AtmIyaM vA |” anena sarvadharmeSu pudgalanairAtmyakSAnti: sandarzitA | anutpattikeSu ityanena dharmanairAtmya- kSAntinirdiSTA | yadi bhAvAnAmutpAdo bhaved, ahetuko vA bhavet, sahetuko vA |{2. utpAdo vA bhAvAnAmahetuko vA syAt sahetuko, vA, na tAvad ahetuka: kAdAcitkatvadarzanAt | kAraNAnapekSA hi vizeSAbhAvAd utpAdakAlavat sadA sarvatraiva ca bhAvA: kiM na bhaveyu: | abhAvakAlAd avizeSAd vA utpAdakAle’pi naiva bhaveyu: | evaM tAvanna nirhetuko yukta: | dra^- bhA. kra. 1, pR. 177, ti. saM. saM.,1985 |} sahetuke’pi nityahetuko vA anityahetuko veti vikalpadvayam | tatra na tAvat @212 prathamo vikalpa: kAdAcitkatvapratIte: | nirapekSasya sadasadavasthAsamatvena sarvatra nirviziSTatvAt nityaM sattvamasattvaM vA syAt |{1. nityaM sattvaM asattvaM vA’hetoranyAnapekSaNAt | apekSAtazca bhAvAnAM kAdAcitkasya sambhva: || -pra. vA. 3/35, bau. bhA. pra. 1968 |} atazca kAdAcitkatvasambhavAd dvitIyo’pi pakSastAvanna yujyate |{2. nApi sahetuka: | tathA hi yastAvadIzvarAdistIrthikairnityo hetu: kalpitastato bhAvA na jAyante krameNotpAdadarzanAt | na tvavikalakAraNasya (phalasya) krameNotpAdo yukto nirapekSatvAt | -bhA. kra. 1, pR. 177-178, ti. saM. saM. 1985 |} nityasya itarai: sahakAribhistAvanna kazcit sAmarthyavizeSa: kriyate | kutracidapyanapekSa: san kimiva krameNa kAryamutpAdayenna yugapaditi | kAraNe’vikale na kAdAcitkakAryatirodhAnaM yujyate | kathaM krameNotpAda: syAditi | ye svahetuM bhAvAnAM vadanti, te’pyarthato’bhAvAdevAbhyupagacchanti | svabhAve siddhe heturapi syAnna tvasiddhe, sarvasAmarthyavirahalakSaNatvAttasya | svabhAve siddhe tasyAhetukasiddhirevAbhyupagatA syAt, taditarAnyahetau cAnabhISTe kathaM na nirhetuka: syAt | na bhAva: svabhAvAd bhinna: | ata: sidhyati tatsiddhe, (phalata:) ahetuka eva syAt | anyathA tatsiddhe’pyasiddhatvAt kathaM tadabhinnasvabhAvatvam | tato yo’hetuvAdI pakSo nirasta:, sa atrApi tulya: | na tAvad yujyate tRtIyapakSo’pi samAnAsamAnakAlayo: kAraNatvavirodhAt |{3. nApyanityAttatrAtItAnAgatayoravastutvAnna tAvattato janma yuktam ahetukatvaprasaGgAt | nApi vartamAnAt, samAnAsamAnakAlayostata utpAdAyogAt | tathA hi na tAvat samAnakAlaM kAraNaM svabhAvavat kAryasyApi tatsamAnakAlabhAvitayA niSpannatvAt | -bhA. kra. 1, pR. 178 |} tathA hi, hetau sati sa phalena (kAryeNa) samAnakAlo vA bhaved bhinnakAlo vA ? na tAvat samAnakAlAt, svayamaprAptAtmasvabhAvasya sarvasAmarthyazUnyatvAt kutrApi phale yogAbhAvAt | AtmasvabhAve ca (prApte) tatsvabhAvavat phalasyApi tatsamAnakAlabhAvitayA AtmasvabhAvatvameva | na tatra phalaM yujyate | @213 bhinnakAle’pi tAvat taditarakAlavyavadhAnena vA bhaved, yathA- vaibhASikairvipAkaheturiSyate, tathA | athavA avyavadhAnena vA bhaved, yathA{1. api ca bIjaM ca nirudhyate, tasminneva samaye aGkura utpadyate “tulAdaNDonnAmAvanAmavat” | - zAli. sU. (ma. sU. saM.) pR. 102, darabhaMgA saM. 1961 |} sautrAntikai: kAryakAraNayorutpAdavinAzau `tulAdaNDonnAmAvanAmavad’ ucyete tathA syAditi ? tatra taditarakAlavyavadhAnena phalotpAde sati vinAzAdevotpAda: abhyupagamyeta,{2. nApi bhinnakAlam, kAlAntaravyavadhAnenotpAde’tItAderevotpattiprasaGgAt | -bhA. kra. 1, pR. 178 |} sarvasAmarthyavirahitatvAttasya vinAzasya na yujyate hetubhAvatvam, anyathA akArakasya vinaSTavastuno vinAzAt kathaM (utpAda:) bhavet |} avyavadhAneneti pakSe’pi yadi sarvAtmanA avyavahitastadA tadeva samakAlatvaM syAt | niravayavayordvayorvastuno: sarvAtmanA avyavahitatve ekakAlatvAtiriktA nAnyA gati: | tasmAt sarvAtmanA avyavahite sati pUrvaM yathA aNumAtrakam (iti prasaktam), tathaiva kalpasyApi kSaNamAtrakatvaM durnivAram |{3. avyavadhAnenApyutpAde sarvAtmanA yadyavyavadhAnaM tadaikasminneva kSaNe sarvakSaNAnAm anupravezAt kalpasya kSaNamAtratAprasaGga: | yathA paramANo: sarvAtmanA saMyoge piNDasyANumAtratAprasaGga: | -bhA. kra. 1, pR. 178} ekadezena cAvyavahite sAvayavatvaM prasajyate, ata: paramArthata: sarve bhAvA anutpannA eva |{4. athaikadezena, tadA kSaNasya sAvayavatvaprasaGga: | svato’pi notpadyante, nirhetukapakSeNaivAsya pakSasya saGgRhItatvAt svAtmani ca kAritravirodhAt | -bhA. kra. 1, pR. 178 |} avicAraramaNIyA mithyAtvenotpannA iva pratIyanta eva, yathA bhrAntijJAne pratibhAsasvabhAvA: | (yadi) na syAt prasiddhamAtraM pramANaM (tadA) `kAryakAraNayorAgopAlaM prasiddhatvAnna yujyate vimarza:’ iti vAda: kathaM yujyeta, prasiddhasya rUpAde: pramANata: vizIrNatvAt | tasmAduktaM bhagavatA candrapradIpasUtre (samAdhirAjasUtram) {5. samAdhirAjasUtram 9/23-24}- na cakSu pramANaM na zrotraghrANaM na jihvA pramANaM na kAyacittam | pramANaM yadyeta bhaveyurindriyA: kasyAryamArgeNa bhavet kAryam || @214 yasmAdime indriya apramANA jaDA svabhAvena avyAkRtazca | tasmAd ya nirvANapathaiva arthika: sa AryamArgeNa karotu kAryam || yatpratyakSalakSaNamAhurAcAryAstacca pratyakSaM saMvRtita:, paramArthe’vatAraNAya draSTavyam | na ca saMvRtau na samAnaparyanuyoga:, tatastasya saMvRtAvuktatvAnna parIkSaNaM kSamate | ato bhagavatA zAlistambAdiSu bhAvAnAM svaparodayo niSiddha: |{1. dra.- zAli. sU., pR. 102, (ma. sU. saM.) 1961 | ; api ca tulanIyam- na svato jAyate bhAva: parato naiva jAyate | na svata: paratazcaiva jAyate jAyate kuta: || -ma. zA., 21/13|} tathoktam AryalaGkAvatAre{2. laM. sU., 127 kA., pR. 27, darabhaMgA saMskaraNam |} “sadasatorutpattivirahitatvAnmahAmate, sarvadharmA anutpannA: |” vistRtaprajJApAramitAsu coktam – “subhUte, na kazcid dharma utpanna:, sA (api) anutpannA” tatra yA prajJA, sA’nutpattikadharmakSAntirityucyate | tathoktaM ratnAkaranAma(mahAyAna) sUtre{3. ##Toh: 124 Sde bka (Mdo Sde, Tha p. 285).##}- sva eva yadA nAsti paro hetu: kathaM bhavet | svAbhAvAt kathamutpAda: parasmAt sugato’vadat || api ca, {4. bhAvA jAyanti saMvRtyA paramArthe’svabhAvakA: |} tadA sarvamidaM satyamasatyaM paramArthata: || -laM. sU. 10/429; uddhRtam- Aloka:, pR. 408 |} bhAvA jAyanti saMvRtyA paramArthe’svabhAvakA: | yadyetat sarvaM parikalpitasvabhAvamadhikRtyoktamiti cet ? na, sarvasvabhAvAnAM pramANato nirAkRtatvAt | anenAparo’lpakuzalamUlo’pi (jano yadA) saMsAradu:khaM nAnubhavati, (tadA) anutpattikadharmakSAntiprAptatvAt mahAjJAnAlokodayA labdhAnuttarapuNyaskandhA bodhisattvA: kathaM saMsAradu:kham anubhaveyurityevamAveditam | @215 na khalu puna: subhUte, bodhisattvena mahAsattvena puNyaskandha: parigrahItavya: | AyuSmAn subhUtirAha- nanu bhagavan bodhisattvena puNyaskandha: parigrahItavya: | bhagavAnAha- parigrahItavya: subhUte, nodgrahItavya: | tenocyate parigrahItavya iti | dvividho hi saMsAradu:khasyAnubhava:- kAyiko daurmanasyalakSaNazca | tatra pUrvakastu pApakarmaNa: phalam, aparastu mohaja:, viparyastajJAnasambhUta eva | tatrAnutpanneSu dharmeSu kSAntiprAptyA bodhisattveSu nAstyubhayavidho du:khahetu:, pApaM mohazceti | akAraNAnna sambhavati du:khasparzavihAra: |{1. sparza: sukham, tena saMhito vihAra: sparzavihAra:, na sparzavihAra: ‘asparzavihAra:’ du:khasahita ityartha: | -vi. mA. si., pR. 204, saM. saM. vi. vi. saMskaraNam |} anena kathaM bodhisattvena pratipattavyamiti dezitam | utpAditabahutarapuNyaskandhA rUpAvacarAdisattvA iva kiM (te) saMsAra eva na bhavanti ? kathaM vA bahutarapuNyaskandhotpAdamAtreNa saMsAre’pratiSThitatvaM sandarzitamityAzaGkya puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | anena tAvad utpannapuNyaskandhe’pi teSAM mithyAbhinivezena puNyaskandhaparigrahasya sarvasaMklezamUlaviparyAsasyAprahINatvam, ata: (te) viziSTagatiM prAptA api saMsAre vyavasthApyante, bodhisattvAnAM tu anutpattikadharmakSAntiprApte: puNyaskandheSu nAsti satyAbhiniveza:, atasteSAM sarvasaMklezamUlasaMmohasya prahINatvAnna saMsAre’vasthAnabhityevaM nirdizyate | paravikalpanirAkaraNArthamAryasubhUtiraviditAbhiprAya iva nanu parigrahItavya: iti viparItamabhyadhAt | tadayamAzaya:-tattatsUtreSu bhagavatA `bodhisattva: puNyaskandhaM parigRhNAti’ ityuktam | atra na parigrahItavya: iti vacanena kathaM na virodha iti ? bhagavAnapi yenAbhiprAyeNoktavAn tadubhayamapi darzayitumAha- parigrahItavya: iti | parigrahIta iti yadAha tattu parigrahalakSaNanaya upasaMhAralakSaNa: | viparItagrAhakalakSaNanirAkaraNena nAtra virodha: | vitathamArgagrAhakatvaM viparItagrahaNamityanena tadvikalpaprahANAccittapragrahaNaM darzitam | yazca khalu - @216 api tu khalu puna: subhUte, ya: kazcidevaM vadet- tathAgato gacchati vA Agacchati vA tiSThati vA niSIdati vA, zayyAM vA kalpayati, na me subhUte, sa bhASitasyArthamAjAnAti | tatkasya heto: ? tathAgata iti subhUte, ucyate na kvacidgato na kutazcidAgata: | tenocyate tathAgato’rhan samyaksaMbuddha iti | puna: subhUte, kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA ityata: prArabhya audAryamuktam, avaziSTapUrvabhAgairgAmbhIryaM nirdiSTam | etena sakalena sthAnena zAzvatocchedAntaM parihRtya madhyamamArgo dezita:, nirdiSTaM ca saMsAre nirvANe cApratiSThitatvam | 7. prasthiti-parizuddhi: prasthiti: parizuddhirucyate | trividhastasyA: prabheda: - 1. IryApathena prasthiti:, 2. sattvabhAjanalokAdhipatyena prasthiti:, 3. asaMklezena prasthitizca | 1. IryApathena prasthiti: tatra yadi buddho draSTavyo dharmakAyena, na tu rUpakAyena, tadA bhagavatazcaturIryApathena janmAbhiniSkramaNAdinA cAgamaprasiddhena kathaM na virodha iti yo manyate tadarthaM prasthAnasampada IryApathena prasthitimadhikRtya api tu khalu puna: subhUte ya: kazcid ityAdyAha | gacchati vA Agacchati vA ityetaddvayena caGkramaNam, tiSThati ityAdibhi: krameNAvaziSTA IryApathA uktA: | {1. na ca kulaputra, dharmatA Agacchati vA gacchati vA | evameva kulaputra, nAsti tathAgatAnAmAgamanaM vA gamanaM vA | tu.-a. pra., pR. 253} IryApathanirdezastUpalakSaNamAtram tena janmAdInAmapyatra nirdezo draSTavya: | bhagavata Agamena paridIpitAnAmIryApathAdInAM ya: samyaktayA zabdazo’bhinivezastasya viparItAbhinivezAnna jAnAti tathAgatena bhASitasyArtham |{2. ...ye- mAM ghoSeNa cAnvayu: | mithyAprahANaprasRtA na mAM drakSyanti te janA: || -vajra.sU, 26 adhyA. pR. 41, ti. saM. saMskaraNam |} @217 yazca khalu puna: subhUte, kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA yAvanti trisAhasramahAsAhasre lokadhAtau pRthivIrajAMsi, tAvatAM lokadhAtUnAm - na ca bhagavAn rUpakAyena prabhAvita:, asau tu jJAnaparizuddha:, tasyAmUrtatvAjjJAnasya saMvRtAvapi gatyAdayo na sambhavanti | gatyAdayastu rUpaskandhasya sthAnavizeSaprabhAvitatvAt | te ca bhagavato nirmANakAyamAzrityoktA:, na ca jJAnakAyamAzritya, tatra saMvRtita: paramArthato vA gatyAdInAmasambhavAt | tasmAd evaMvidhAyAM IryApathaprasthitau bodhisattvena chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti sandarzitam | yadi tathAgate gatyAdayo na saMvidyante (tarhi) kathaM tathAgata: iti gatyA prabhAvita ivocyata iti cittAzayaM vitarkyAha- tatkasya heto: ? iti | na me sa bhASitasyArthamAjAnAti ityanena yojanIyam | atrottarArtha tathAgata: ityAdyAha | evamabhipreyate- vyapadezo’yaM na gatyA prabhAvita:, api tu adhigamena prabhAvita:, gata: ityasyAdhigatyarthakatvAt | vastutattvaM yathAsthiti:, tathaivAdhigamyate, adhigatatvAt tathAgata: | athavA pUrvakairbuddhairyathA vastutattvamadhigatamaviparyayeNa tathaivAnenApyadhigatamityadhigatatvAt tathAgata: | sa ca tathyasaMvRtau jJAnakAyatvena yujyate, na cAnyatrAvikalpitatvAt | tacca gamanAdi kvacit saMvRtAvapi na sambhavati, amUrtatvAt | paramArthe tu na sambhavatitarAm, anutpannatvAt | tata: sa vastusvabhAvAdhigatyA samastalokasya jyeSThatvAt pUjanIyatvAt arhan ityucyate,{1. dra.- Aloka:, pR. 273 |} samyagavabuddhatvAt samyaksambuddha: ityucyate,{2. dra.- Aloka:, pR. 351 |} anyathAtvena jaDasvabhAvena rUpakAyastu tathA nocyata iti bhAva: | anena yogasamApatti: cittapragrahazca sandarzita: | anena tAvat sakalasthAnena gAmbhIrya nirdiSTam | saMvRtau tathAgatasya nirmANakAyamAzritya anantalokadhAtuSu apratihatagamanAdipradarzanena audAryamapi pradarzitam | @218 evaMrUpaM maSiM kuryAt yAvadevamasaMkhyeyena vIryeNa tadyathApi nAma paramANusaMcaya:, tatkiM manyase subhUte- api nu bahu: sa paramANusaMcayo bhavet ? subhUtirAha- evametad bhagavan, evametat sugata, bahu: sa paramANusaMcayo bhavet | 2. (a) bhAjanalokAdhipatyena prasthiti: yastathAgatasya nirmitarUpakAya:, yazca manomayakAya:, tasyApi ekAnekasvabhAvavisaMyogAnmAyAnirmitabuddhavat mRSAtvaM darzayituM bhAjanasattvaloka- bhAvavigamAt prasthitimadhikRtya yazca khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | pUrvaM tvadhimukticaryAbhUmau bodhisattvasyAbhAvo darzita:, samprati buddhabhUmau bhagavata: prasthitidarzanAnna punarukti: | atra punadvividhenopAyena ekAnekasvabhAvaviyogAvabodhAnnairAtmyaM darzitam | tadyathApi nAma maSiM kuryAt...paramANusaJcaya:{1. tu.- saddharma.sU., saptamo’dhyAya: |} ityanena ekAnekasvabhAvaviyogAvagamena tanUkaraNopAyo darzita: | atrApi pUrvavad vyAkhyAnaM (veditavyam) | nanu digbhAgabhedena paramANavo’siddhA: (tadA) kathaM te saJcitA: ? iti saJcintya tatkasya heto: ? ityAzaGkyottaramAha (pariharannAha)- saced bhagavan iti vijJAya ekatvagrAhakanivRttyupAyArthameva paramANuprabhedena (ya:) saJcaya: sa ukto na tu paramArthato’navasthitatvAt, anyathA paramANusaJcaya: sarvatra pratyakSatvena prasiddhyeta | tasmAt na bhagavAnavakSyat paramANusaJcaya iti abhASite’pyevamAkhyAtatvAt | anena tathAgatasya rUpAbhAvatvena tAdRzyAM sthitau chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti dezitam | yadi na syAt saJcaya: (tadA) api nu bahu: sa paramANusaJcayo bhavet ? iti kasmAd bhagavAnavakSyadityAzayaM viditvA tatkasya heto: ? ityAha | asaJcaya: sa: iti pUrvottarAdidigbhAgabhedena avasthitAnAM teSAM paramANUnAM svabhAvenAsiddhatvAnna yujyate tattvata: saJcaya: |{2. yasya pUrva: pradezo’sti pUrvo’zastasya vidyate || -catu. za. 9/15 |} ekatvagrAha- @219 tatkasya heto: ? saced bhagavan bahu: paramANusaMcayo’bhaviSyat, na bhagavAnavakSyat- paramANusaMcaya iti | tatkasya heto: ? yo’sau bhagavan paramANusaMcayastathAgatena bhASita:, asaMcaya: sa tathAgatena bhASita: | tenocyate paramANusaMcaya iti | nirAkaraNAyaiva bhASitam tenocyate paramANusaJcaya iti | asati ca digbhAgabhede paramANava: paramANvantarai: pUrvAparordhvAdhodigbhAgabhedena parivRtA na syu:, {1. SaTkena yugapadyogAt paramANo: SaDaMzatA | SaNNAM samAnadezatvAt piNDa: syAdaNumAtraka: ||12|| AvaraNaM ca kathaM bhavati, paramANo: paramANvantareNa yadi digbhAgabhedo neSyate | na hi kazcidapi paramANo: parabhAgo’sti, yatrAgamanAdanyenAnyasya pratighAta: syAt | asati ca pratighAte sarveSAM samAnadezatvAt sarva: saMghAta: paramANumAtra: syAdityuktam | -vi. mA. si., pR. 42-53, sa. saM. vi. vi. saMskaraNam ; aNvantarAbhimukhyena rUpaM cedanyadiSyate | kathaM nAma bhavedeka: paramANustathA sati || -ta. saM. paM. 1991 zloka:, pR. 679 |} tato na bhavedupacayazcitta- caittAdivat |{2. na ca paramANava: stambhAdivat paramArthata: santi, arvAGmadhyaparabhAgasadbhAvAt | tadanabhyupagame vA pUrvadakSiNAparottarAdidigbhedo ya:, sa paramANorna syAt | tatazca vijJAnavat paramANorapyamUrtatvamadezasthatvaM ca prasajyate | - vi. mA. si. pR. 113, sa. saM. vi. vi. saMskaraNam |} bhAga eva bhavati paramANurityapi kathanaM na yujyate, tatrApi tarkasAmyAt | evaMbhUte’niSThito’pi na yujyate | aniSThitA: paramANava: svabhAvena tarhi tvayA kiM sAdhyate ? aniSThitasvabhAve bhAvo na sidhyati, tata: siddhamasmAkaM matamiti | anekasvabhAvatvamaNUnAM yadRcchayApi nocyate, (tadA) aniSThite paramANau (anekasvabhAvatvaM) kathamupapadyeteti mayoktam | ye paramANavastvayA niravayavatvena vyavasthApyante teSAM pUrvottarAdidigbhedAbhyupetatvAt digbhAgabhedenAbhyupagamyante, tena sAvayavA: (te) prasajyante | tata: prasaGgasiddhau hetorAzrayAsiddhi:, na ca kevalaM cittacaitasikAbhyAmanaikAntikA:, amUrtatvAtte na dikSvavasthitA:, pUrvottarAdidigbhirapi nAvatiSThante | tenoktam{3.- mUlasroto nAdyAvadhi prAptam |}- @220 yazca tathAgatena bhASitastrisAhasramahAsAhasro lokadhAturiti, adhAtu: sa tathAgatena bhASita: | tenocyate trisAhasramahAsAhasro lokadhAturiti | tatkasya heto: ? sacedbhagavan lokadhAturabhaviSyat, sa eva piNDagrAho'bhaviSyat | yazcaiva piNDagrAhastathAgatena bhASita:, agrAha: sa tathAgatena bhASita: | tenocyate piNDagrAha iti | bhagavAnAha- piNDagrAhazcaiva subhUte, avyavahAro’nabhilApya: | na sa dharmo nAdharma: sa ca bAlapRthagjanairudgRhIta: | na rUpe naiva netre ca tayormadhye’pi na sthita: | yatra sthito bhavettatra na sannaiva hi cApyasat || alaM prasaGgeneti | anena tvanekasvabhAvarAhityamavagamya nirAbhAsopAya- sandarzanena yogasamApattizcittapragrahazceti nirdiSTam | bahu: sa paramANusaJcayo bhavet ityanenaudAryaM cAbhihitam, avazeSeNa tu gAmbhIryam | (ba)sattvalokAdhipatyena prasthiti: samprati sattvalokAbhAvaprasthitimadhikRtya bhASitastrisAhasramahAsAhasro lokadhAturiti sa: ityAdyAha |{1. dra.- upari TIkAyAm, pR. 160 ; abhi. ko. 3/73-74 |} bhAjanalokasya pUrvamuktatvAdatra lokadhAtustAvat sattvalokatveneSTa: | ubhayatra trisAhasramahAsAhasrAbhidhAnena tAvadanantalokadhAturupalakSyate | ata eva adhAtu: sa tathAgatena bhASita: iti paJcaskandhAtmaka: sa sattvaloko’pyekAnekasvabhAvavirahita: pUrvavadukta: | anena tathAgatasya tathAvidhAyAM sattvalokAbhAvaprasthitau bodhisattvena chandapraNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti nirdiSTam | nirAbhAsena tu yogasamApattiriyaM kathaM pratipattavyetyapi sandarzitam | idAnIM cittaM kathaM pragrahItavyamiti darzayituM tatkasya heto: ? iti pRSTavAn | `adhAtu: sa tathAgatena bhASita:’ ityanena yojanIyam | uttarArthaM saced bhagavan ityAdyAha | yadi sattvaloko yathAprasiddhastathA paramArthata: syAt sthUlaikasvabhAvastadA tathAgatena yathAsthiti vastutattvamadhigatamiti sa eva @221 tatkasya heto: ? yo hi kazcitsubhUte evaM vadet- AtmadRSTistathAgatena bhASitA, sattvadRSTirjIvadRSTi: pudgaladRSTi: tathAgatena bhASitA, api nu sa subhUte, samyagvadamAno vadet ? piNDagrAha: syAt | skandheSu piNDagrAha evAtmagrahaNahetu:, sa eva ca tathAgatasya piNDagrAho’tigADhatara: syAt, tadaprahANaM cAbhipretaM bhavet | na tvevam, ata evAnyatra yo bAlajanebhya: piNDagrAha AtmagrAhasya hetutvena bhagavatA bhASita:, sa paramArthato’grAhya eva | grAhye hi piNDe ekAnekasvabhAvasya kasyacidabhAvAt | bAlajanaprasiddho bhAva: kevalaM saMvRtita ukta: | tenocyate piNDagrAha iti | tadarthasAdhanAyaivaM bhagavAn piNDagrAhasyArthamuktavAn | kimucyata iti cet ? vyavahAre piNDagrAha iti paramArthe’bhAvAt sa dharmastvanabhilApya ityuktatvAn | yadyevaM grAhya: piNDo na syAt tadA tatra grAhakasyApyabhAvAt kathaM vyavahAre piNDagrAha iti vicintyAha- sa ca bAlapRthagjanairudgRhIta: iti | bAlAstu bhrAntivazAdasantamapi sadbhUtamiva gRhNanti | tadAzayavazena vyavahAra: prajJapyate, (ato) na virodha ityabhiprAya: | tasmAt te bAlA ityucyante, anyathA yathAvastu vyavahAraprajJaptau kathaM te bAlA: syu: ? uktamatra kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyamiti | gAmbhIryamaudAryamapi cAtra pUrvavad yojanIyam | anena yadA sarve bhAvA: paramArthata: svabhAvazUnyAstadA rUpakAya: jJAnakAyazca kathaM bhavet paramArthata: sasvabhAva:, mUlasattvasyAbhAvAditi dezitam | samprati yo hi kazcit subhUte ityAdinA sarvasthAneSu yogasamApatte: kenopAyena sarvatra samAdheyamiti tat pradarzyate | evamanusandhi: - yadi nAsti piNDagrAhastadA tanmUlaprabhavAyA: satkAyadRSTerevAbhAvAt kathaM bhagavAn paJcasu dRSTiSu satkAyadRSTimoheti tadarthaM yo hi kazcit subhUte ityAdyAha | atra kathamavikalpyam, yazcAvikalpaka:,{1. ayaM pATha: pekiMga saMskaraNAnusArI, de. ge. saMskaraNe tu “kAyavikalpaka:” iti pATha upalabhyate, sa cAzuddha iti pratIyate |} yasminnavikalpyam, yenAvikalpaka:, yazcAvikalpa:, taddarzanena yogasamApatte: samyagupAyo darzito bhavati | @222 subhUtirAha- no hIdaM bhagavan, nohIdaM sugata, na samyagvadamAno vadet | tatkasya heto: ? yA sA bhagavan AtmadRSTi: tathAgatena bhASitA, adRSTi: sA tathAgatena bhASitA | tenocyate AtmadRSTiriti | bhagavAnAha-evaM hi subhUte, bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitena sarvadharmA jJAtavyA draSTavyA adhimoktavyA: | tathA ca jJAtavyA draSTavyA adhimoktavyA:, yathA na dharmasaMjJA pratyupasthAmahe | tatkasya heto: ? dharmasaMjJA dharmasaMjJeti subhUte, asaMjJaiSA tathAgatena bhASitA | tenocyate dharmasaMjJeti | tatra yo hi kazcit subhUte ityArabhya tenocyate AtmadRSTi: etatparyantamanena kathamavikalpyaM taduddiSTam | kathamiti cet ? ukto’nyaistairthikairAtmA, bhagavatA tu pudgalanairAtmyapratipAdanAdAtmaniSedhArthamAha AtmadRSTi: iti tasyA: AtmadRSTernirAkaraNena dharmanairAtmyaM vyavasthApyate adRSTi: sA tathAgatena bhASitA ityuktam | tAmAtmadRSTiM yadi satyato na gRhNAti (tadA) evaM prayoge bodhisattvo yogasamApattau pravartate | yasmAdavikalpakastasmAt sa tatrAvataraNopAya: | evaM hi subhUte bodhisattvayAnasamprasthitena ityanena yo’vikalpaka: sa paridIpyate | sarvadharmA: ityanena yasminnavikalpyam taddarzitam | jJAtavyA draSTavyA adhimoktavyA: ityanena yenAvikalpyaM tadabhihitam | kenAvikalpyamiti cet ? jJAnena darzanena adhimuktyA ca | tatra jJAnaM zrutamayI prajJA, darzanaM cintAmayI prajJA, tayopanidhyAnatvAd, adhimukti: bhAvanAmayI prajJA, adhyAzayo’trAdhimuktizabdena vaktumiSyate | sA tu bhAvanAbalena sidhyatIti, ata eva bhAvanAmayI prajJA nirvedhabhAgIyAvasthAyAmadhimuktizabdenoktA | tathA cAdhimoktavyA, yathA na pratyupasthAmahe ityanena yo’vikalpastaM darzayati | asaMjJaiSA tathAgatena bhASitA ityatra hetu: parikIrtita: | kasyacit saMjJeyasya abhAvo’pi, ekAnekasvabhAvazUnyatvAt paramArthata sA asaMjJA | saMvRtisatyamadhikRtyAnyatra tathAgatena bhASitam | tasyA @223 yazca khalu puna: subhUte, bodhisattvo mahAsattvo’prameyAn asaMkhyeyAMllokadhAtUn saptaratnaparipUrNaM kRtvA tathAgatebhyo’rhadbhya: samyaksaMbuddhebhyo dAnaM dadyAt, yazca kulaputro vA kuladuhitA vA ita: prajJApAramitAyA dharmaparyAyAdantazazcatuSpAdikAmapi gAthAmudgRhya dhArayeddezayedvAcayet paryavApnuyAt, parebhyazca vistareNa saMprakAzayet, ayameva tato nidAnaM bahutaraM puNyaskandhaM prasunuyAdaprameyamasaMkhyeyam | kathaM ca saMprakAzayet ? yathA na prakAzayet | tenocyate saMprakAzayet iti | mithyArthAdhigamAvasthAyAM kathaM na syAdavikalpa ityabhiprAya: | sarvasthAneSu yogasamApattyupAyo’bhihita: | 3. asaMklezena prasthiti: (a) dezanA’saMkleza: dvidhA tAvadasaGkleza: - dezanA’saMkleza:, saMsArAsaMklezazca | tatra yadi nAsti dharmasaMjJA tadA tathAgatasya sattvebhyo taddharmadezanAsaMjJAsamutpAde kathaM na bhavet saMkleza: ? kRpayA sattvArthaM yAvatsaMsArAvasthAne sati dharmasaMjJayA kathaM na syAt saMkleza: ? iti vicintya tayaiva cittasampadA dezanA’saMklezaM gAthayA ca saMsArAklezamAvedayitum yazca khalu puna: subhUte ityAdyAha | pUrvaM prasaGgAntare lokadhAtuprazastipradarzanamanuzaMsAyA: prazaMsanam, sampratyasaMklezAdhikAre’nantalokadhAtudezanayA nocyate anuzaMseti na punarukti: | atrApi yuktistu prAgvad vaktavyA | udgRhya iti svAdhyAye’dhItam, dhArayet iti padam, vAcayet iti pustakAdikaM vAcayet, paryavApnuyAt iti tvarthagrahaNamityartha: | anena yasmAnmahArtho’yaM dharmastasmAdbodhisattvenaivaMvidhAyAM mahArthadharmadezanAyAmavazyameva chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyaM tatparidIpitam | bhASyamANAyAmapi kathaM na syAtsaMkleza ityetaddarzayituM kathaM na samprakAzayet ityAha | ayamabhiprAya:-paramArthato’nutpannatvenAnabhilApyatvena dezitatve’pi sarvadharmANAm, te dharmA anabhilApyasvabhAvena nocyante | evamuktam- yathA vineyajanAstathA sarve dharmA Adito’nutpannatvAdanabhilApyA: @224 tArakA timiraM dIpo mAyAvazyAya budbudam | svapnaM ca vidyudabhraM ca evaM draSTavyasaMskRtam || idamavocadbhagavAn | AttamanA: sthavirasubhUtiste ca bhikSubhikSuNyupAsakopAsikAste ca bodhisattvA: sadevamAnuSAsura- gandharvazca loko bhagavato bhASitamabhyanandanniti | AryavajracchedikA prajJApAramitAsUtram samAptam || tasmAnna te kenApi vyapadezyA ityevaM darzyata iti | tathA sati asaMklezena dezanA, aviparItArthatvAt | anyathA saMkliSTA syAd viparItadezanatvAt | ata eva tathAgato dharmadezanAkAle vizuddhalokajJAne prasthita:, ato dharmasaMjJAbhAsasamudbhave’pi tattvato’bhinivezAbhAvAt saMklezadoSAbhAva: | anena yogasamApatti:, cittapragraha: gAmbhIryaJca nirdiSTam, pUrveNa tAvadaudAryam | (ba) saMsArAsaMkleza: sAmprataM nikhilaprajJApAramitAkAyaM vyavasthApya gAthayA saMsArAsaMklezo dezyate | anayA gAthayA catvAri saMskRtalakSaNAni paridIpitAni | (tAni tAvat) svabhAvalakSaNam, viSayarasAsvAdanalakSaNam, AdInavAnvayalakSaNam, niryANAnvayalakSaNaM ceti | tatra paJcaskandhAtmakAnAM bhAvAnAM yathApratIti pratItyasamutpAdastAvad hetupratyayasaMgRhItatvAt saMskRta ityucyate | eteSAM sarveSAM svabhAva: tArakA: iva draSTavya: | rAtrau yathA tArakA avabhAsante, na tu divase, tathaiva saMskRtA api avidyAjJAnAndhakAre sati pratibhAsante, jJAnasUryAloke sati nAvabhAsante, ata: (te) tArakasvabhAvA iva draSTavyA: | pudgaladharmadRSTyabhinivezAtmakA: saMskRtAstu mithyApratItihetutvAt timiravajjJAtavyA: | vijJAnalakSaNaM ca karmavartikaM tRSNAsnehaM cAzritya prajvalanAd dIpa iva draSTavyam, evametannidarzanena saMskRtasvabhAvalakSaNaM paridIpitam | mAyopamayA viSayarasAsvAdanalakSaNaM nirdizyate, vitathAvabhAsamAnatvAt | tatrAdInavAnvayalakSaNaM saMskRtasvabhAvaM dvividham – anityAnvaya: du:khAnvayazca | avazyAyopamayA anityatAnvaya: pradarzyate, na ciraM sthitatvAt | bud-budopamayA tAvad @225 du:khatAnvaya: pradarzyate, vedanA budbudopamA iti, yA kAcid vedanA seha du:khamiti bhASitatvAt | trividhai: du:khai: sarvA vedanA du:khA veditavyA | tatra du:khavedanA tAvad du:khadu:kham, tatsahitA ye saMskArAste’pi tadanurUpatayA du:khameva; sukhAvedanA tAvad vipariNAmadu:khena du:kham, tatsahitA ye dharmAste’pi tadanurUpatayA du:kham, na du:khA na sukhA vedanA, tatsahitAni vastUni ca saMskAradu:kham, utpAdabhaGgalakSaNatvena tAni du:kham | {1. du:khAstridu:khatAyogAdyathAyogamazeSata: | manApA amanApAzca tadanye caiva sAsravA: ||6/3 tisro hi du:khatA du:khadu:khatA saMskAradu:khatA vipariNAmadu:khatA ca | tAbhiryathAyogamazeSata: sarve: sAsravA: saMskArA du:khA: | tatra manApA vipariNAmadu:khatayA | amanApA du:khadu:khatayA | tebhyo’nye saMskAradu:khatayA | -abhi. ko. bhA., pR. 329, jAyasavAla saMskaraNam, 1975 ; api ca draSTavyam- saddharma. sU., pR. 80 ; utpAdasthitibhaGgAnAmanyat saMskRtalakSaNam | uktaM hi- trINImAni saMskRtasya saMskRtalakSaNAni | saMskRtasya bhikSava:, utpAdo’pi prajJAyate, vyayo’pi sthityanyathAtvamapi iti | -ma. zA. vR., 7/3, pR. 61, bau. bhA. pra. 1983 |} evaM sarvaM saMskRtaM du:khAnvitaM draSTavyam | tatra niryANAnvayalakSaNaM tAvat pudgaladharmazUnyatAnvayam, tadAlambana- nirvRtatvAdbhagavatA khalu dvividhaMniryANAlambanamuktam | AryasamAdhirAjasUtre cApyuktam :{2. samAdhi sa 9/37} nairAtmyadharmAn yadi pratyavekSate tAn pratyavekSya yadi bhAvayeta | sa heturnirvANaphalasya prAptaye yo anyaheturna sa bhoti zAntaye || dvividhanairAtmyasamprayuktA: sarvasaMskRtA:, tathA hi- atIta-pratyutpanna- anAgatabhedena trividhA: saMskRtA: | tatra ye tAvadatItAste smRtimAtrAvasthitA ato ni:svabhAvatvena, dharma-pudgalatayA zUnyA: AtmanA’nadhiSThitatvAt, tatazca svapnaupamyena dvividhanairAtmyAnvayAste vyapadiSTA: | pratyutpannA vidyudaupamyena ekAnekasvabhAvarahitA: agrAhyasvabhAvatvAditi tenAnvitA vyapadiSTA: | @226 anAgatAstAvadalabdhasvabhAvA:, abhraupamyena AkAzasamacitte tadbIjadauSThulyena janitatvAditi nairAtmyadvayaM tAvaddezitam | ato’nena khalu samagreNAtra bodhisattvai: sadA sarvasaMskRtasvabhAvameva vicArya chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAM sthAtavyamiti paridIpitam | niryANAnvayapradarzanena tAvad yogasamApattizcittapragrahazca nirdiSTa: | anena sampUrNenasthAnena gAmbhIryaJca vyapadiSTam | gAthAyAmasyAM tAvadidaM paridIpyate- saMklezamUlaM tAvad viparyAsa: | ata: saMskRtasvabhAveSvanekaza: kenacid vicArayatA manasikurvatA apyevaM saMskAraparijJAnAdyadA viparyAsAbhAvAt na bhavati saMkleza: (tadA){1. kAma jAnAmi te mUlaM saMkalpAt kila jAyase | na tvA saMkalpayiSyAmi tato me na bhaviSyasi || -ma. zA. vR. 23/1 ; (ma. vagga, 3/190)} kathaM (nAma) yathAvadazeSavastusvabhAvaparibhAvako vidhUtAzeSaviparyAsajAlastathAgata: saMkliSTo bhavet | ata eva samastasaMskRtadoSAn avagacchan tathAgata:, padmamiva saMsAradoSAmbhasA’navaliptacitta:, pratijJAtasamastajagatsamuddharaNAzaya:, saphala- kAritra:, mahAkaruNAnvitacitta:, niravadhijagaddhitasukhasAdhanAbhiprAyeNa saMsAracakra- saMsaraNaM yAvat pratiSThito veditavya: | tathA coktam - kartuM loke sukhaM zAntau bhave cApyanadhiSThita: | iti sarvasattvAnavalokituM bhUmAvasthIyata ityapyuktam | traiyadhvikAnAM jananI munInAM khyAtA yathAzakti mayA tato jagat | vipulena puNyena viyatsamena vidhUya cAndhyaM sugatatvamApnuyAt || AcAryakamalazIlena mAdhyamikanayena viracitA vistRtA AryavajracchedikATIkA parisamAptA | aSTamyAM zatAbdyAM bhAratIyAcArya- maJjuzrImitreNa bhoTa-locAvA yeze-demahAbhAgena ca bhoTabhASAyAmanUditA | viduSAM vazaMvadena AcAryapemAtenajinamahAdayena bhoTabhASAta: saMskRtabhASAyAM punaruddhRtA sarvasattvahitasukhArtham iti | @417 pariziSTAni prathamapariziSTam akArAdikrameNa sahAyakagranthAnukramaNI ##Toh:## 1395 amRtakaNikAnAma AryanAmasaMgItiTippaNI, tibbatI saMsthAna saMskaraNa | ##Toh:## 4299 amarakoza:, caukhambA saMskRta saMsthAna, vArANasI | pAli aMgutaranikAyo, nAlandA saMskaraNa, bhikSu jagadIza kAzyapa | ##Toh:## 12 Arya-aSTasAhasrikA prajJApAramitA, mithilA insaTITyUTa, 1960, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 317 arthavinizcayo nAma dharmaparyAya:, ke. pI. jAyasavAla risarca insaTITyUTa, paTanA, 1971, ena. eca. samtAnI | ##Toh:## 4365 arthavinizcayaTIkA, ke. pI. jAyasavAla saMskaraNa, 1971, sampAdaka, ena. eca. samtAnI | ##Toh:## 3786 abhisamayAlaMkAro nAma prajJApAramitopadezazAstrakArikA, ti. saM. saMskaraNa, 1977, pro. rAmazaMkara tripAThI | @418 ##Toh:## 4019 abhidharmakozakArikA, ke. pI. jAyasavAla saMskaraNa, 1975, sampAdaka, pro. prahlAda pradhAna | ##Toh:## 3791 aSTasAhasrikAprajJApAramitAvyAkhyAbhisamayAlaMkArAloka:, mi. insaTITyUTa, sampAdaka, 1960, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 117 AryaratnakaraNDanAma mahAyAnasUtram, tibbatI 'de-ge’ saMskaraNa | ##Toh:## 4301 kAvyAdarza:, kalakattA vizvavidyAlaya saMskaraNa, 1939, anukUlacandra banarjI | ##Toh:## 44 gaNDavyUhasUtram, mithilA insaTITyUTa, 1960, vaidya | ##Toh:## 1119 niraupamyastava:, nepAla saMskaraNa | ##Toh:## 4266 tattvasaMgraha:, bauddha bhAratI vArANasI, 1982, svAmI dvArikAdAsa zAstrI | ##Toh:## 4267 tattvasaMgrahapaJjikA, bauddha bhAratI vArANasI, 1982, svAmI dvArikAdAsa zAstrI | ##Toh:## 5070 trizatikAprajJApAramitAkArikAsaptati:, tibbatI saMsthAna saMskaraNa, 1978, pro. ela. ema. jozI | @419 ##Toh:## 4064 triMzikAvijJaptimAtratAsiddhi:, saM. vi. saMskaraNa, 1972, zrI thubatena chogaDuba evaM paM. rAmazaMkara tripAThI | ##Toh:## 238 dharmasaMgItinAma mahAyAnasUtram, tibbatI ‘de-ge’ saMskaraNa | dharmasaMgraha: (mahAyAnasUtrasaMgraha:), mithilA insaTITyUTa, 1961, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 4212 nyAyabindunAma prakaraNam, caukhambA saMskRta saMsthAna, vArANasI, 1982, sampAdaka, candrazekhara zAstrI | ##Toh:## 3804 prajJApAramitApiNDArtha:, mi. insaTITyUTa, 1960, vaidya | ##Toh:## 4210 pramANavArtikakArikA, bauddha bhAratI vArANasI, 1968, svAmI dvArikAdAsa zAstrI | ##Toh:## 3871 bodhisattvacaryAvatAra:, mi. insaTITyUTa, 1960, vaidya | ##Toh:## 3872 bodhisattvacaryAvatArapaJjikA, mi. insaTITyUTa, 1960, vaidya | ##Toh:## 3915-17 bhAvanAkrama:, ti. saM. saMskaraNa, 1985, AcArya jJalachena namaDola | ##Toh:## 3884 madhyamakAlaMkArakArikA, tibbatI ‘de-ge’ saMskaraNa | pAli majjhimanikAyo, nAlandA saMskaraNa, vihAra, sampAdaka, bhikSu jagadIza kAzyapa | ##Toh:## 4021 madhyAntavibhAgakArikA, ke. pI. jAyasavAla risarca insaTITyUTa 1967, paTanA. DA.c^ nathamala TATiyA | @420 ##Toh:## 4032 madhyAntavibhAgabhASyam, ke. pI. jAyasavAla risarca insaTITyUTa, 1967, paTanA, DA.c^ nathamala TATiyA | ##Toh:## 3824 madhyamakazAstrakArikA, bauddha bhAratI vArANasI, 1983 | ##Toh:## 3860 madhyamakazAstravRtti:, bauddha bhAratI vArANasI, 1983 | ##Toh:## mahAyAnasUtrasaMgraha:, mithilI insaTITyUTa, 1961, sampAdaka, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 231 Aryaratnamegho nAma mahAyAnasUtram, tibbatI 'de-ge’ saMskaraNa | ##Toh:## 4158 rAjaparikathAratnamAlA, tibbatI saMsthAna saMskaraNa, sampAdaka, AcArya GavaG samatena | ##Toh:## 107 AryalaMkAvatAranAma mahAyAnasUtram, mithilA insaTITyUTa, 1963, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 3817 vajracchedikAprajJApAramitATIkA, tibbatI saMsthAna saMskaraNa, punaruddhAra, 1994, AcArya pemA tenajina | ##Toh:## 16 vajracchedikAprajJApAramitAsUtram, tibbatI saMsthAna saMskaraNa, 1978, pro. ela. ema. jozI | @421 pAli vizuddhimaggo, mahAbodhisabhA saMskaraNam, 1957, sampAdaka, bhikSu dharmarakSita | ##Toh:## vijJaptimAtratAsiddhiprakaraNadvayam, saM. vi. saMskaraNa, 1972, zrI thubatena chogaDuba evaM pro. rAmazaMkara tripAThI | ##Toh:## 3825 vyAkhyAyukti:, tibbatI ‘de-ge' saMskaraNa | ##Toh:## 3940 zikSAsamuccaya:, mithilA insaTITyUT, 1960, sampAdaka, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 210 AryazAlistambanAma mahAyAnasUtram, mi. insaTITyUTa, 1961, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 113 saddharmapuNDarIkanAma mahAyAnasUtram, mi. insaTITyUTa, 1960, pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 127 AryasamAdhirAjanAma mahAyAnasUtram, mi. insaTITyUTa, 1961. pI. ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 4020 mahAyAnasUtrAlaMkAranAma kArikA, mi. insaTITyUTa, 1970, sampAdaka, pI: ela. vaidya | ##Toh:## 207 hastikakSyanAma mahAyAnasUtram, tibbatI 'de-ge’ saMskaraNa @422 dvitIyapariziSTam akArAdikrameNa granthAgatagadya-padyoddharaNAnAmanukramaNI anutpAdadharma: satataM tathAgata: … 187-188 AtmA Atmeti bhikSavo ! bAlo’zrutavAn … 211 Atmani sati parasaMjJA sva-paravibhAgAt … 169 aizvaryasya samagrasya rUpasya … 99 kartuM loke sukham … 226 tathAgatastu kSutpipAsAvarjita: mUtrapurISavirahito...103 tAyAt tattvasthirAzeSavizeSa … 173 duSkarAduSkarAM veti kalpanAM … 113 na cakSu pramANaM na zrotraghrANaM … 213 na cAtmadRSTi: svayAtmalakSaNA … 117 na tattvasya bhAvAditaro’rtha: … 139 na rUpe naiva netre ca tayormadhye’pi … 220 nApaneyamata: kiJcit prakSeptavyaM … 210 nairAtmyadharmAn yadi pratyavekSate … 225 parokSopeyatadhetostadAkhyAnaM...172 buddhAnAM rUpikAyo hi puNyaM sambhRtya … 145 buddhyA vivecyamAnAnAM svabhAvo … 126 bhadanta subhUte, kolopamaM dharmaparyAyamAjAnadbhirdharmA … 137 bhAvA jAyanti saMvRtyA … 214 yathA hi darpaNe rUpamekatvAnyatva … 126 yathA yathArthAzcintyante ...125 yathaiva ArdraM kadalIyaskandhaM … 126 yasmAdime indriya apramANA … 214 yena yena hi nAmnA vai yo yo … 199 @423 yo Ananda ! dharmo’nutpanna:, aniruddha: … 139 vastusvabhAvacintAyAM yathA na … 126 sadasatorutpattivirahitatvAnmahAmate … 214 sva eva yadA nAsti paro hetu: … 214 @424 [OTHER LANGUAGE] @425 tRtIyapariziSTam akArAdikrameNa granthaprayuktaviziSTasaMskRta-bhoTazabdAnukramaNI akRtAbhyAgama: akSaNotpannebhya: agrayAnam agrAhya: acintyam aNu: aNDajA: atIta-pratyutpanna-anAgatabhedena atulyam atyantaparokSArtha: arthakriyAsAmarthyarahitatvAt advaitasvabhAvatAyA: adhigamadharmakAya: adhimukticaryAbhUmi: adhimuktisamutpAdAya adhyAropAnta: ananumeyatvAt anabhilApyA: anavamardanIyatvAt anAgAmina: @426 anAthapiNDadasyArAme anityAnvaya: anuttarajJAnaparizuddhisampad anuttaradRSTiparizuddhisampad anuttarapadam anuttarA samyaksaMbodhi: anutpattikadharmakSAnti: anutpannadharmatA anutpannAryamArga: anutpAdadharma: anekabuddhazatasahasra: anaikAntikatvam antadvayaparihAra: anyAkAra: apakAramarSaNakSAnti: aparimANam aparimitapuNyajJAnasambharaNAt aparimitavineyAnAm apavAdAnta: @427 apratiSThitanirvANam apratiSThitanirvANadhAtau aprameyam abhayadAnena abhisamayakAle’hamiti vikalpaviyoga: abhisambuddha: abhisambodhi: abhraupamyena amApyam araNA: arhan avaropitakuzalamUlA: avavAdaparyeSaNam avazyAyopamayA avAGmukha-azuci-sacchidrabhANDAnAm avikale hetau avicAraramaNIyatayA avidyAjJAnAndhakAre avinivartanAya avyAkRta: azItiranuvyaJjanAni azruNi prAmuJcat @428 asamAhitAvasthAyAm asurendro rAhu: asaMklezena prasthiti: asaMkhyeyam asaMkhyeyakalpa: asaMviditatvAt asaMskRtaprabhAvitA: ahetuvAdI AtmagrAha: Atmaparigraha: AtmaprAmANyapratipAdanAt AtmabhAva: AtmasaMjJA AtmA Atmeti AtmAdidRSTikai: Adito’nutpannatvAt AdInavAnvayalakSaNam AdhArAdheyalakSaNam AmiSadAnena AryapudgalA: Aryasatyam AryasubhUti: @429 AvaraNadvayaprahANam AvRtAnAvRtayo: Azrama: IryApathena prasthiti: utkhAtamUlAni uttamAM samAdhim ucchedavAdinAmiva upacitahetu: upadeza: upavasatAm upAlambhAvakAza: upetakAya: upodghAta: ekAnekasvabhAvazUnyA evaMvidhadharmaratnazravaNam durlabham aizvaryasya kathaM cittaM pragrahItavyam kathaM pratipattavyam kathaM sthAtavyam kapilaparikalpitasya karanakhAmRtena @430 karttA bhoktA smartA karmaphalam karmavartikam karmAvaraNam kaliGgarAjA kalyANamitreSu kAmadhAtau kAyacittaparizrAntau kAyasampad kAryakAraNabhAvamAtreNa kAryakAraNalakSaNam kAryakAraNasambandha: kAraNazakte: pratiniyatatvAt kAraNe’vikale kucodyam kudRSTijAle kuzalairdharmai: kRtavipraNAza: kolopama: kausIdyam kramotpattyA kriyAtantram kleza: kSutpipAsAvarjita: kSetraparizuddhisampad @431 kSetravizuddhipraNidhAnam kSetravyUhA: gaganAravindavat gaGgAnadIvAlukAsamAn gaNakai: gambhIreSvartheSvavatAraNAya gAmbhIryam guNavanta: gotrasamparigrahajJAnam govalIvardanyAyena gosadRzo gavaya: grAhyo grAhako vA ghoSeNa cAnvayu: cakrAGkahastapAdatAdIni cakSuSmAn caturdIpAdInAm caturbhirIryApathai: caturAryasatyalakSaNam cittacaittAdi cittadhArA cittadhArA cittasampad cittotpAda: cintAmayI prajJA cIvara-piNDapAtAdibhi: @432 cIvaramAdAya caitya: caityabhUta: codakaM prati samAdhAnam chatradhvajapatAkAdibhi: chanda-praNidhAnAbhyAm jagaddhitasukhasAdhanA jinai: jIvasaMjJA jetavane jaiminyAdInAm jJAnakAya: jJAnagocara: jJAnajJeyAtmaka: jJAnaparizuddha: jJAnasUryAloke jJAnahetuka: jJApakahetau tadbIjadauSThulyam tathAgata: tathAgatAnubhAva: tathAgatapUjAsatkAra: @433 tathAvAdI tathyasaMvRtisvabhAvam tadyathApi nAma tanUkaraNopAya: tarkasAmyAt tAmravarNanakhAdIni tArakA: timiravat tribhirasaMkhyeyakalpai: trisAhasramahAsAhasra: tRSNAzikhara: tRSNAsneha: tairthikakuJjaravRndAnAm tairthika: traikAlikaM cittam traiyadhvikasarvabuddhaprasUm dazacaritAni dazabhi: pAramitAbhi: dAnapAramitA dIpaMkara: du:khadu:kham du:khAdhivAsanam du:khAdhivAsanakSAnti: @434 du:khAnvaya: du:khasatyam du:khotpAdahetutvAd duravagAha: durlabhapadam duSkarakRtyavidhAnam dRSTa eva dharme dRSTAntasyApi deya-dAyaka-pratigrAhaka: devadatta: devaputra: devAdibhi: satkAra: dezanA’saMkleza: daurmanasyam daurmanasyalakSaNam dharmakAya: dharmakAyaparigrahaNam dharmakAyAptikAmatA dharmacakrapravartanAkAle dharmadAnena dharmadhAtu: dharmanidhyAnakSAnti: @435 dharmanairAtmyakSAnti: dharmanairAtmyAnadhigamAd dharmaparyAyam dharmavegena dharmavRSTi: dharmasaMgItau dharmasaMjJA dharmastutivaiziSTyam dharmAyatanam dhUtaguNeSvavatAraNAya dhyAnarasAsvAdavirati: na rUpapratiSThitam na vitathavAdI nAtinamraM nAtistabdham nikhilaklezajAla: nidAnam niravayavAnAmamUrtAnAm nirAkAreNa nirAbhAsakaraNopAya: niryANAnvayalakSaNam nirvANakAya: nirvANapatha: @436 nirvANamahAnagaram nirvedhabhAgIya: nivAsya niSyandAdiphalAni nairAtmyadvayamArgeNa nairAtmyavAdinAm naiva saMjJino nAsaMjJino vA nyagrodhavRkSam paJcakaSAyANAmAdhikyAd paJcajAtizatAni paJcazatavarSANi sthAsyatIti padAnAmanusandhi: paramapramodasaJjananAya paramavicakSaNairbauddhairiti paramANava: paramANusaJcaya: paramArthasatyagrAhaka: parasparaparihArasthitalakSaNatvAt paramArthasampad parinirvANapradarzanam paribhASaNabhaNDanAdi paribhUtA: paribhogavaikalyadu:kham @437 parvatazikhara: pazcAdbhaktam pazcimAyA paJcazatyAm pApakarma pApaparizodhanam pAramitAyoga: piNDakAla: piNDagrAha: piNDaparikarma piNDArtha: puNyaparigraha: puNyaskandha: puNyahetuka: pudgalanairAtmyam pudgalanairAtmyakSAnti: pudgalasaMjJA pUjanIya: pUrvAparordhvAdhodigbhAgabhedena pUrvAhNakAlasamaye pRthagjanai: pRthivIpradeze pRthivIraja: paurvajanmikAni paurvAparyAvasthiterayuktatvAt @438 prajJapta evAsane prajJAcakSu: prajJApAramitA prajJApAramitAkAyam prajJAvanta: praNidhAya praNidhi-prasthAnacittAbhyAm praNItaphale pratipattilakSaNam prattipattyarcayA pratizrutkAdivat pratItyasamutpAdavAdiSu pratyaGgAni pratyakSamanumAnam pratyAtmavedanIyatvena pradakSaNIya: prabhAtAyAm prabhAvitatvAt pravacanadharmakAya: pravrajitAnAm prasthitiparizuddhi: prekSAvAn bandhamokSau @439 bAdhakapramANam bAlapRthagjanA: bAlabuddhaya: bAlo’zrutavAn bAhyazAstreSu vyapagatarAgatA bAhyArtha: buddhakSetram buddhadharmA: buddhabhUmiparyeSaNam buddhabhUmim budbudopamayA buddhA bhagavanta: buddhotpAda: buddhotpAdArAgaNatA buddhavaMzAnupaccheda: bodhibhArodvahanam bodhisattvakSetram bodhisattvayAnasaMprasthitena bodhisattvAbhisamaya: bhagavata: siMhanAda: @440 bhadanta subhUte bhavAgrajA: bhAgyavanta: bhAvanAphalam bhAvanAmayI prajJA bhAvanAvizeSalAbhe’nabhimAna: bhUtakoTi: bhUtadarzI bhUtavAdI bhUtasaMjJA madhyamamArgam manomayakAya: mayArAgitA marIcikAsu udakopalambhavat maSiM kuryAt mastuluGgalAkSAdi mahatAbhikSusaMghena mahAkaruNAnvitacitta: mahAkAya: mahAkAruNika: mahAdharmArthaprajJapti: mahAyAnam @441 mahAvavAdArthaprajJapti: mahAsattvA: mahaujaskA yakSAdaya: mAyAnirmitabuddha: mAyopamayA mithyAprahANaprasRtA: mUtrapurISavirahita: mRtyu: mohaja: yajJadatta: yathA yathArthAzcintyante yugapad yogasamApattyA yogijJAnam yonibhedena rAjApi cakravartI rUpakAyAptikAmatA rUpagrAhaka: rUpiNAmarUpiNAm rUpeNa cAdrAkSu: lakSaNasampadA lakSaNAnuvyaJjanairalaGkRta: @442 lajjAsthAnam lAbhasatkArAdisvArthArthitayA lokadhAtu: laukikalokottara: lauhazalAkAvat vajravaddurbhedyAni vajrAkArasAdRzyena vadhabandhanAdibhi: vandanIya: vandhyAputra: vastupratiSThitena vAksampad vAcanam vikalpanirAkaraNArtham vikAlabhojanam vikSepanigraha: vicikitsA’bhAvAt vijJAnakSaNAnAm vitathamArgagrAhaka: vitathAbhiniveza: vidyudaupamyena vindhya: viparItagrAhakalakSaNam @443 vipariNAmadu:khena du:kham viparyAsajAla: viprasthitAnAm vimuktyupadezakAle viziSTagatim viziSTapuNyasaJcaya: viziSTeSTaphalAni vizuddhalaukikajJAnam viSayarasAsvAdanalakSaNam vIradatta: vIrya-dhyAnaprajJApAramitA vaibhASikai: vyAcikhyAsu vyApAdasaMjJA zatatamImapi kalAM nopaiti zatasAhasrikA prajJApAramitA zabdAbhinivezamAtram zazaviSANam zAzvatocchedAntam zikSAtrayapratipattisamanvitA: @444 zilAputrakasya zarIravat zIlakSAntipAramite zIlavanta: zuddhAdhyAzayabhUmim zubho vA azubho vA zaikSAzaikSajJAnam zravastestannAmakarSe: zrAvaka-pratyekabuddha: zrAvastI zrutamayI prajJA zreSThayAnasamprasthitAnAm saMklezavyavadAnabhAvena saMklezavyavadAne saMgItikArai: saMyogalakSaNa: saMvRtisatyagrAhakam saMvRtita: saMzayopaccheda: saMsAradu:kham saMsArArNavottaraNAya @445 saMsArAdoSAmbhasA saMsArAsaMkleza: saMsAre nirvANe cApratiSThitam saMskAradu:kham saMskRtalakSaNAni sakRdAgAmina: satyavAdI sattvaparipAka: sattvaparipAkArtham sattvapratikUlapravRttidu:kham sattvabhAjanaloka: sattvasaMjJA saddharmavipralopakAle saddharmotthAnakAle saddharmasya cirasthityai saptadravyAtmakatvAt saptaratnAni samatAjJAnam samanantarapratyaya: samAnAsamAnakAlayo: samAhitena IryApathena @446 samyaksaMbuddha: samyagjJAnasya phalam sarajaskapAdAbhyAm sarvajJa: sarvajJapadalAbha: sarvatragodArAkSayatvai: sarvatrApratihatajJAnena sarvasaMjJApagatA: sarvasattvAnAmarthAya sarvAkArajJeyagrAhakam sahakArikAraNamapekSya sAkAreNa sAdhakapramANAbhAvAd sAdhyavikalatvam sArdhamardhatrayodazabhi: zatai: siddhasAdhanam sthite: sthAturabhinnatvAt sItAharaNam sugata: sunaSTajvaravat supUrNaghaTavat sumeruparimANa: @447 surUpavat sUkSmaklezajJeyAvaraNAni srota Apanna: skandha: strI vA puruSo vA sthavira: sthAnasthottaptapUrNatvena smRtyupasthAnam svapnaupamyena svabhAvalakSaNam svayamabhyupagamya svayambhUsarvajJajJAnam svasAmAnyalakSaNagrahaNam svArthasampad svAdhyAya: himavatA hInaphalArthitA hInAdhimuktikai: hInAlambanamanasikArabhAvanA hetupratyayasaMgRhItatvAt heyopAdeyatattvam @448 caturthapariziSTam AcAryakamalazIlakRtAnAM granthAnAmanukramaNI ##Toh: 2321 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## bodhicaryApradIpa: ##Toh: 2322 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## yogapathapradIpa: ##Toh: 2323 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## cittaguhyapradIpa: ##Toh: 2324 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## maNDalavidhi: ##Toh: 2325 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## mahAmudrAtattvAnakSaropadeza: ##Toh: 2326 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## prajJApAramitAsAdhanA ##Toh: 2327 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## mahAbhaTTArikAryatArAsAdhanA ##Toh: 2328 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## vajravArAhIsAdhanA ##Toh: 2329 Sde bstan Rgyud “Shi”## maJjuzrIkrodhasAdhanA ##Toh: 3815 Sde bstan Ser phyin “Ma”## AryasaptazatikAprajJApAramitATIkA @449 ##Toh: 3817 Sde bstan Ser phyin “Ma”## AryaprajJApAramitAvajracchedikATIkA ##Toh: 3886 Sde bstan Ser phyin “Sa”## madhyamakAlaMkArapaJjikA ##Toh: 3887 Sde bstan Ser phyin “Sa”## madhyamakAloka: ##Toh: 3888 Sde bstan Ser phyin “Sa”## tattvAloko nAma prakaraNam ##Toh: 3889 Sde bstan Ser phyin “Sa”## sarvadharmani:svabhAvatAsiddhi: ##Toh: 3913 Sde bstan dBuma “Ki”## bodhicittabhAvanA ##Toh: 3915-17 Sde bstan dBuma “Ki”## bhAvanAkrama: ##Toh: 3918 Sde bstan dBuma “Ki”## bhAvanAyogAvatAra: ##Toh: 4000 Sde bstan Mdo hgrel “Ji”## Arya-avikalpapravezadhAraNITIkA ##Toh: 4001 Sde bstan Mdo hgrel “Ji”## AryazAlistambakaTIkA ##Toh: 4128 Sde bstan hdul-ba “Su”## zramaNapaJcAzatkArikApadAbhismaraNam ##Toh: 4193 Sde bstan Sprin-yig “Ne”## brAhmaNIdakSiNAmbAyai du:khavizeSanirdeza: @450 ##Toh: 4195 Sde bstan Sprin-yig “Ne”## zraddhotpAdapradIpa: ##Toh: 4232 Sde bstan Tshad-ma “We”## nyAyabindupUrvapakSasaMkSepa: ##Toh: 4267 Sde bstan Tshad-ma “Ze”## tattvasaMgrahapaJjikA ##Toh: 4393 Sde bstan sNa-tshogs “No” AcAryakamalazIlapraNidhAnadvayavidhA